Fantasy Premier League: Player Value and Sustainable Returns Analysis
TL;DR
- Selling Ekitike for a replacement like Mitoma (7.6M) is viable, as Mitoma offers penalty duties and better value than Watkins (8.7M) despite a less favorable fixture run.
- Malik Thiaw (5.1M) presents a strong defensive option for Newcastle, averaging nearly 10 defensive contributions per start and offering goal threat, making him a good pick if a new defender is needed.
- Ignoring both Botman and Visser is advised due to uncertain minutes and potential rotation, even with Newcastle's numerous fixtures and Botman's historical quality.
- Bruno Guimarães (7.1M) is a reasonable pick with good upcoming fixtures, but his underlying stats suggest his current high returns may not be sustainable long-term.
- Declan Rice (7.2M) is a strong midfielder choice, outperforming Guimarães in defensive contributions and benefiting from Arsenal's clean sheet potential, though not an essential pick.
- Gabriel (6.6M) is a must-own Arsenal defender due to consistent performance and potential price rises, making him a priority over midfielders like Rice if a transfer is needed.
- Phil Foden (8.9M) remains a strong pick despite recent blanks, with favorable upcoming fixtures against Brighton and Wolves, and consistent 90-minute game time.
Deep Dive
Fantasy Premier League (FPL) transfer decisions for Game Week 21 reveal a strategic tension between player form, fixture difficulty, and the potential for price rises. While many popular options present clear pros and cons, the underlying challenge is identifying sustainable returns versus fleeting point hauls, particularly for forwards and midfielders whose underlying metrics may not justify their current scoring rates. This necessitates a disciplined approach, prioritizing long-term team structure and avoiding panic transfers based on single-week performances.
The forward landscape is particularly challenging, with Hugo Ekitike's fitness concerns creating a dilemma for owners. While he may return for Game Week 21, his history of not completing full matches and a recent hamstring issue raise doubts about his long-term reliability. Selling Ekitike is a reasonable option, but potential replacements like Ollie Watkins are also not without their concerns regarding minutes and price. Mitoma emerges as a potentially undervalued option at a lower price point with recent good minutes and penalty duties, offering a more stable alternative than Bowen, whose attacking output is lower. For those seeking significant savings, cheaper options like Calvert-Lewin exist, but their fixtures are poor, pushing focus towards differentials like Jesus or Barry, whose minutes are less guaranteed. The general consensus is that the forward pool is weak, suggesting a strategy of "tanking" one forward spot to invest elsewhere or sticking with a two-forward formation for many managers.
Defensively, Newcastle's Malick Thiaw is highlighted as a strong option despite his recent injury concerns and the return of other defenders; his consistent minutes and defensive contributions make him a reliable pick over the next few fixtures. Conversely, Nick Botman is flagged as a player to sell due to an uncertain minute situation, with manager Eddie Howe seemingly preferring others. In midfield, Bruno Guimarães is performing well with multiple double-digit hauls, but his underlying statistics suggest his current scoring rate may not be sustainable long-term, making him a player to acquire if convenient rather than a priority transfer. Declan Rice, however, presents a more compelling case due to his strong defensive contributions, Arsenal's strong defensive record, and relatively good upcoming fixtures, making him a solid, if not essential, midfield choice. Arsenal defender Gabriel is presented as a must-own player, with his price continuing to rise and his consistent returns making him a top priority for defensive transfers, even ahead of Declan Rice in terms of FPL value. Nico Rys is identified as a strong defensive option for the next three weeks, particularly due to potential injuries to Manchester City teammates, offering good attacking potential despite a lack of recent clean sheets. Phil Foden, despite several recent blanks, remains a strong option due to his guaranteed minutes and favorable upcoming fixtures for Manchester City, representing a stable choice in a volatile midfield.
Ultimately, the analysis underscores the importance of evaluating player consistency and underlying metrics over short-term point returns. While certain players like Gabriel and potentially Nico Rys offer immediate defensive strength, the midfield and forward lines require careful consideration to avoid investing in players whose current returns are not supported by their performance data. The potential for price rises on key players like Gabriel also encourages timely transfers to maximize value.
Action Items
- Audit Newcastle defenders: For Botman and Visser, assess starting probability for next 3 fixtures and determine sell/hold strategy.
- Track Arsenal defender price rises: Monitor Gabriel's price and plan transfer to acquire him before Game Week 22.
- Evaluate Foden's fixture run: Analyze Man City's next 3 fixtures (Brighton, Man Utd, Wolves) for potential returns.
- Measure Mitoma's value: Compare Mitoma's performance and fixture difficulty against Watkins and Bowen for a 7.5M forward slot.
- Assess Bruno Guimarães' sustainability: Calculate correlation between his recent returns and underlying stats to predict future performance.
Key Quotes
"The problem you've got if you own him is the game against arsenal is on thursday and the deadline is on tuesday so there is every chance that slot's press conference is on wednesday after the deadline so i'm not sure if you're going to get another update now liverpool do have burnley at home in game week 22 so it's arsenal away then i think it's barnsley at home in the fa cup then it's burnley at home in 22 so presumably whether he plays against arsenal or not he'll probably get a good rest in the fa cup so if you were thinking about keeping him for that burnley game i still think that's viable"
The speaker, Andy, discusses the uncertainty surrounding player Hugo Ekitike's availability due to a potential late press conference. Andy explains that this timing makes it difficult for Fantasy Premier League (FPL) managers to get crucial information before the transfer deadline. He suggests that Ekitike could still be a viable option for future games, even if he misses the immediate fixture.
"my one worry with him is the minutes now when he starts he's averaged 81 minutes per start which is pretty good but he just got benched in game week 18 against chelsea we know villa have got champions league matches and stuff like that in january okay it's all well and good looking at the last two games where he played 82 and 90 minutes before that 32 74 74 65 85 36 67 that doesn't read quite so good now maybe because of how well he's playing right now he'll just continue to start every single game but there are slight doubts there"
Andy expresses concern about Ollie Watkins's consistent playing time, despite his good average minutes per start. He points to a recent benching and a history of inconsistent full 90-minute performances. Andy suggests that while Watkins's current form might lead to him starting every game, there are underlying doubts about his guaranteed minutes.
"jared bowen i think i would probably ignore basically i don't think bowen is a bad pick but i think i would choose mitoma over him like bowen's goal threat this season has been quite low 0 22 expected goals per 90 mitoma has double that plus mitoma has penalties as well now bowen plays 90 minutes every single game and that will not change but it's 90 minutes for a west ham team and don't get me wrong i've got paqueta right i'm not against buying west ham players and the fixtures are slightly better next three but he's playing in a much worse team"
Andy advises against selecting Jarrod Bowen, not because he is a bad player, but because he believes Kaoru Mitoma is a superior option. Andy highlights Bowen's low expected goals per 90 compared to Mitoma's significantly higher threat and Mitoma's penalty-taking ability. He also notes that Bowen plays for a less effective team, despite playing full matches.
"bruno guimaraes in newcastle is basically that player right now if you look at his recent points back to back 10 point hauls and he got a 10 pointer against burnley in gameweek 15 he's just done really really well and obviously better than anthony gordon for a slightly cheaper price like gordon got subbed around the 60th minute against palace bruno guimaraes played the full game as he usually does and he's only 7 1 million should we be rushing out to bring him in look i can't sit here and say he's a bad pick"
Andy identifies Bruno Guimarães as a player who is performing exceptionally well, noting his recent consistent double-digit hauls. He contrasts Guimarães with Anthony Gordon, highlighting that Guimarães plays full matches and is a more affordable option. Andy acknowledges that Guimarães is not a bad pick, especially given his recent form and playing time.
"my preference is always going to be to concentrate my transfers elsewhere rather than move arsenal players around because declan rice is good but he's not essential right my other arsenal players will do fine and then i can use my moves to hopefully get more points elsewhere i still think that double arsenal defense is the way forward so if you've got saka unless you're desperate for the money for another move it's never going to be a huge temptation to move him to rice"
Andy explains his strategy regarding Arsenal players, stating that while Declan Rice is a good player, he is not essential for his team structure. Andy prefers to use his limited transfers for other areas of his squad, believing his existing Arsenal players are sufficient. He also suggests that prioritizing a double Arsenal defense might be a more effective FPL strategy than transferring Bukayo Saka to Declan Rice.
"the thing with the thing for me with gabriel why i got him early one i just needed a defender but two i know that when he's fit i want to own him like maybe double and blank game week strategy means at some point i've got to sell gabriel but without the doubles and blanks he's in my team every single week when he's fit no doubts about that whatsoever he's just that good i don't have that same feeling towards like a declan rice again i think rice is a good pick but he's not i have to own him whenever he's fit good with gabriel he kind of is"
Andy emphasizes his strong conviction about owning Gabriel from Arsenal when he is fit, stating he is a must-have defender. He contrasts this with Declan Rice, whom he considers a good pick but not an essential one. Andy believes Gabriel's consistent high performance when available makes him a priority over other midfielders, even those who are performing well.
Resources
External Resources
Books
- "The Premier League: The Making of England's Greatest Sporting Export" by Jim Roberts - Mentioned as a resource for understanding the Premier League's global impact.
Articles & Papers
- "Rob T's numbers on Twitter" (Twitter) - Referenced for projected goals and team statistics for each game week.
People
- Andy - Host of the FPL video.
- Slot - Manager of Brighton.
- Isaac - Player for Liverpool.
- Beto - Player for Everton.
- Betha - Player for Everton.
- Semenyo - Player for Bournemouth.
- Eddie Howe - Manager of Newcastle.
- Visser - Player for Newcastle.
- Trippier - Player for Newcastle.
- Livramento - Player for Newcastle.
- Botman - Player for Newcastle.
- Declan Rice - Player for Arsenal.
- Mikel Arteta - Manager of Arsenal.
- Palmer - Player for Chelsea.
- Saka - Player for Arsenal.
- Gabriel - Player for Arsenal.
- Raya - Player for Arsenal.
- Gabriel - Player for Arsenal.
- Timber - Player for Arsenal.
- Tarkowski - Player for Brighton.
- Vardy - Player for Brighton.
- Nathan Aké - Player for Manchester City.
- Pep Guardiola - Manager of Manchester City.
- Amrabat - Player for Manchester United.
- Fletcher - Interim manager for Manchester United.
- Rodgers - Player for Aston Villa.
- Bruno Fernandes - Player for Manchester United.
- Kacedo - Player for Chelsea.
- Mark Guieru - Player for Chelsea.
- Ashley Barnes - Player for Burnley.
- Manni - Player for Wolves.
- Creepy Junior - Player for Bournemouth.
- Paqueta - Player for West Ham.
- Mitoma - Player for Brighton.
- Jared Bowen - Player for West Ham.
- Thiago - Player for Liverpool.
- Calvert-Lewin - Player for Everton.
- Igor Jesus - Player for Arsenal.
- Barry - Player for Everton.
- Malik Chaw - Player for Newcastle.
- Lewis Hall - Player for Newcastle.
- Phil Foden - Player for Manchester City.
Organizations
- Tax Act - Sponsor of the podcast, mentioned for tax filing services.
- Fantasy Premier League (FPL) - The game discussed in the video.
- Liverpool - Football club.
- Fulham - Football club.
- Arsenal - Football club.
- Burnley - Football club.
- Manchester City - Football club.
- Manchester United - Football club.
- Aston Villa - Football club.
- Chelsea - Football club.
- Crystal Palace - Football club.
- Newcastle - Football club.
- West Ham - Football club.
- Sunderland - Football club.
- Everton - Football club.
- Brentford - Football club.
- Leeds - Football club.
- Bournemouth - Football club.
- Brighton - Football club.
- Wolves - Football club.
- Tottenham - Football club.
- PFF (Pro Football Focus) - Mentioned in relation to player grading data.
- Sports Social Podcast Network - The network the podcast is part of.
- Lifelock - Sponsor of the podcast, mentioned for identity theft protection.
Other Resources
- Hamstring problem - Injury affecting Hugo Ekitike.
- Penalties - Mentioned in relation to players taking penalty kicks.
- Expected Goals (xG) - A statistical metric used in football analysis.
- Expected Assists (xA) - A statistical metric used in football analysis.
- Defensive Contributions - A statistical metric used in football analysis.
- Clean Sheets - A defensive achievement in football.
- Bonus Points - Points awarded in Fantasy Premier League.
- Wildcard - A feature in Fantasy Premier League.
- Double Game Week - A period in Fantasy Premier League where a team plays twice.
- Blank Game Week - A period in Fantasy Premier League where a team plays zero times.
- AFCON - Africa Cup of Nations, a football tournament.
- Carabao Cup - A domestic cup competition in English football.
- FA Cup - A domestic cup competition in English football.
- Champions League - A European club football competition.
- Interim basis - A temporary role.
- Price Rise - An increase in a player's value in Fantasy Premier League.