Personality Spectra Enable Malleable Trait Cultivation for Goal Achievement - Episode Hero Image

Personality Spectra Enable Malleable Trait Cultivation for Goal Achievement

Original Title:

TL;DR

  • Personality traits are best understood as continuous spectra rather than discrete categories, allowing for nuanced self-awareness and targeted personal development.
  • Engaging in activities outside one's comfort zone, like improv, can shift personality perceptions and increase comfort with social interaction, demonstrating that traits are malleable.
  • The pandemic may have amplified introverted tendencies by reducing social practice, leading some to confuse temporary discomfort with a fixed introverted identity.
  • Academic personality science, particularly the Big Five model, offers more predictive and nuanced insights than popular online tests, which often lack scientific validation.
  • While societal structures often favor extroversion, introverts possess valuable traits like thoughtfulness and listening skills crucial for creativity and leadership.
  • As people age, social dominance facets of extroversion may increase while social vitality decreases, leading to a reduced desire for constant social engagement.
  • Personality is not fixed at birth; individuals can intentionally cultivate specific traits to align with their values and achieve important life goals.

Deep Dive

The popularization of introversion as a perceived trait, particularly online, has led to a widespread adoption of the label that often misrepresents its scientific definition. While many individuals now identify as introverts, this trend may be conflating genuine introversion with discomfort stemming from reduced social interaction, as experienced during the pandemic, rather than the core psychological construct. This shift in perception and self-identification highlights a societal embrace of introverted qualities, yet it also prompts questions about the fluidity of personality and the potential for individuals to cultivate traits that better serve their goals.

The academic understanding of personality, as researched by psychologists like Shannon Sowens, posits that traits exist on a continuum rather than in discrete categories. Introversion and extroversion are understood as a spectrum defined by the level of stimulation an individual requires and the energy they derive from social situations. Extroverts tend to seek higher stimulation and gain energy from social interaction, while introverts require less stimulation and can find social engagement draining. This nuanced view contrasts sharply with popular personality tests, which often assign individuals to rigid types and are less predictive of life outcomes than the "Big Five" personality model. This model, encompassing openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism, offers a more comprehensive framework for understanding individual differences by assessing the degree to which individuals exhibit each trait.

The pandemic significantly impacted social behaviors, leading many, including the podcast's listener Ladell and the author Olga Hazan, to experience heightened social withdrawal. This period of isolation may have led individuals to misinterpret their temporary discomfort or "rustiness" with social interaction as an inherent introverted disposition. Hazan's personal experiment, involving activities like improv classes, demonstrated that actively engaging in behaviors associated with extroversion can shift one's self-perception and comfort levels, suggesting that personality traits are not immutable. This challenges the notion that personality is fixed from birth, indicating that individuals can intentionally cultivate traits that align with their aspirations, such as increased assertiveness for career advancement. The "Big Five" model offers a more useful framework for this intentional cultivation, providing clear goals for self-improvement, unlike categorical personality tests which can be misleading.

Ultimately, the widespread identification with introversion reflects a positive societal recognition of the value of quieter, more contemplative traits, alongside the inherent strengths of extroversion. However, it is crucial to distinguish between genuine psychological introversion and the temporary effects of altered social circumstances. The research suggests that personality is malleable, and individuals can choose to develop traits that enhance their lives and goals, rather than being confined by labels derived from popular, often inaccurate, personality assessments. This understanding empowers individuals to actively shape their characteristics, recognizing that both introverted and extroverted tendencies offer valuable strengths.

Action Items

  • Design personality assessment tool: Measure trait continua (e.g., Big Five) instead of discrete types for 3-5 core traits.
  • Implement personality trait intervention: Develop 2-3 exercises to shift specific traits (e.g., neuroticism, introversion) for personal growth.
  • Track personality trait correlation: For 3-5 individuals, measure trait shifts against self-reported satisfaction and goal achievement.
  • Audit personality test usage: Evaluate 2-3 common online or HR personality tests for predictive validity against career success.

Key Quotes

"people are super duper precious about their personality pretty much like all of the like introvert worth nightmares were played out it seems like to me of the last five to eight years everybody and their mama is proclaiming to be an introvert a few weeks ago we got a call from a listener named ladell it just seems like the introvert thing is a new hot word that everyone is caught onto and is clinging to even if they don't demonstrate the qualities and um i'm just curious is that just a personal observation or something other people are seeing and also just why"

The speaker notes a trend of people widely adopting the "introvert" label, questioning if this is a genuine reflection of personality or a popular cultural adoption of the term. This highlights a societal fascination with personality types and the potential for terms to become trendy without full understanding. The speaker's curiosity prompts an investigation into this phenomenon.


"it's a little bit of a misconception because we think that we can put ourselves into these like discrete categories but most of the things that we use to describe people are on continua so you can be more towards the introverted side or more towards the extroverted side but this is a continuum with different poles people that are more on the introverted side they're gonna need less stimulation they're gonna have less sort of energy and they're gonna derive less energy from social situations whereas people on the more extroverted side are going to be more excitable have more positivity and tend to derive a lot of energy from social situations"

Shannon Sowers, a professor of psychology, clarifies that personality traits like introversion and extroversion are not rigid categories but exist on a spectrum. Sowers explains that individuals on the introverted side require less stimulation and gain less energy from social interactions, while extroverts are more excitable and gain energy from social situations. This perspective moves away from strict typologies towards a more nuanced understanding of personality.


"i think like any skill when we are out of practice we get rusty and so i think people may be kind of confusing discomfort and a little bit of rustiness with like i'm introverted but i do think that here in the last decade or so there's been more recognition of introverts as having qualities that are really desirable you know what no one talks about how freaking good introverts are at networking it's a whole spiritual filtration system that refuses to uh let surface level conversations sit on the same couch as their souls"

The speaker suggests that the perceived increase in introversion might stem from a "rustiness" in social skills due to lack of practice, rather than a fundamental shift in personality. This quote also points out that introverts possess valuable, often overlooked, skills like effective networking, framing their preference for deeper connections as a positive attribute. The speaker implies that society is beginning to recognize and value these introverted qualities more.


"so what things that's tend to change or increase on average as people age is what's called social dominance and this is a facet of extroversion that is the tendency to be assertive and confident on the flip side social vitality tends to decrease and this is like enthusiasm and energy for social situations kind of what you're describing like i don't necessarily i don't have the same fomo i used to have i'm happy to read my book um but what i really want to highlight though is that these are on average and like nobody is really the average person"

Sowers explains that as people age, certain aspects of extroversion, like social dominance (assertiveness and confidence), tend to increase on average, while social vitality (enthusiasm and energy for social situations) may decrease. Sowers emphasizes that these are average trends and individual experiences vary significantly, cautioning against assuming everyone fits a generalized pattern. This addresses the common observation that people may become less driven by social energy as they get older.


"most of the commercial personality tests that people have heard of that they're taking in like hr offices they're very category based right they put you into a type and you know that's that what we use what we think sort of describes personality in a much more nuanced way is the big five or the five factor model of personality these are sort of five overarching traits the first one is openness and this is the degree to which you are interested in new ideas and aesthetics philosophy art versus folks that are more um more traditional and like this is how we always do it then you have conscientiousness which is um on a continuum with disinhibition and essentially conscientiousness is like how achievement striving you are how organized how reliable and disinhibition is more like you know i kind of act before i think it through"

Sowers contrasts popular, category-based personality tests with the scientifically validated "Big Five" or "Five Factor Model." Sowers describes the Big Five traits: openness (interest in new ideas), conscientiousness (achievement striving, organization), and the beginnings of explaining conscientiousness versus disinhibition. This highlights the academic approach to personality measurement as more granular and continuous than common tests.


"i always say that you know academic personality science needs like a pr person because we're not really good at spreading the word on what personality actually is coming up some personality pr support for today explained comes from at t there's nothing worse than needing to make a call and realizing you can't connect this is at t and of course every wireless provider will claim that they're the best but at t says at t has the goods to back it up according to root metrics at t earned the best overall network performance while the other guys are busy making claims they can't keep at t says they're making connections on america's fastest and most reliable wireless network"

The speaker humorously suggests that academic personality science needs better public relations to communicate its findings effectively to the general public. This quote implies a disconnect between scientific understanding of personality and popular perceptions, often shaped by less rigorous commercial tests. The speaker believes the scientific community could do a better job of disseminating accurate information about personality.

Resources

External Resources

Books

  • "Introvert Advantage" by [Author not specified] - Mentioned as the book that sparked the listener's interest in introversion.

Articles & Papers

  • "The rise of the introverts" (Today, Explained) - Discussed as the episode topic exploring personality tests and introversion.
  • "Me, But Better" by Olga Hazan (The Atlantic) - Mentioned as the book written by Olga Hazan about her year-long experiment with personality change.

People

  • Ladell - Listener who called in with a question about the perceived rise in people identifying as introverts.
  • Shannon Sowers - Professor of psychology at the University of Kentucky who researches personality.
  • Olga Hazan - Staff writer at The Atlantic and author of "Me, But Better," who experimented with changing her personality.
  • Andrew Melnizek - Mentioned as someone who has used an Aura frame.
  • Carl Jung - Psychologist whose ideas about introversion and extroversion are discussed.

Organizations & Institutions

  • Sequoia Capital - Producer of the "Crucible Moments" podcast.
  • University of Kentucky - Institution where Shannon Sowers has a research lab.
  • Vox - Media company producing "Today, Explained" and offering Vox Memberships.
  • The Atlantic - Publication where Olga Hazan is a staff writer.

Websites & Online Resources

  • cruciblemoments.com - Website where new episodes of the "Crucible Moments" podcast are available.
  • auraframes.com - Website for Aura Frames, offering a discount with a promo code.
  • odoo.com - Website to try Odoo business software for free.
  • vox.com/members - Website for Vox Memberships.

Other Resources

  • Introvert/Extrovert Continuum - Discussed as a more nuanced way to understand personality than discrete categories.
  • Big Five (or Five Factor Model) of Personality - A model of personality traits including openness, conscientiousness, extraversion/introversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism.
  • Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) - A common personality test that is contrasted with the Big Five model, noted for being less scientifically validated.
  • Improv Class - An activity undertaken by Olga Hazan as part of her experiment to become more comfortable with social interaction.
  • AI Abundance - A concept for an upcoming episode, exploring the idea that AI can free up time for less work and more living.

---
Handpicked links, AI-assisted summaries. Human judgment, machine efficiency.
This content is a personally curated review and synopsis derived from the original podcast episode.