Listening to Glacier Melt Sounds for Climate Change Monitoring
TL;DR
- Listening to the sounds of air bubbles bursting from melting glacier ice provides a non-intrusive method for researchers to monitor melt rates and understand glacial behavior from a safe distance.
- The frequency and intensity of bubble-bursting sounds correlate with glacier melt rates, offering a potential quantitative measure for tracking climate change impacts.
- Underwater hydrophones deployed via remote-controlled vehicles can capture calving events and ice melt sounds, revealing small-scale physical processes crucial for large-scale ice sheet models.
- Submarine calving events, though often unseen, generate significant fjord circulation disturbances that contribute to additional ice melt, impacting overall ice loss calculations.
- The sounds of fracturing ice deep within glacial fjords, like those under the Thwaites ice shelf, offer insights into ice sheet stability and potential future sea-level rise.
- Robots equipped with hydrophones, cameras, and melt sensors allow for extended data collection directly at the glacier terminus, overcoming the dangers of close-proximity human research.
Deep Dive
Researchers are employing novel acoustic monitoring techniques, specifically listening to the sounds of melting glaciers, to better understand glacial melt rates and their impact on climate change. This innovative approach offers a safer and potentially more comprehensive way to gather data from the dangerous edges of glaciers, providing insights crucial for improving climate models and predicting future ice loss.
The sounds emanating from glaciers are not merely ambient noise but direct indicators of glacial processes. As glaciers form, air bubbles become trapped within the ice. These pressurized bubbles, upon reaching the glacier's terminus and melting, "pop" into the surrounding water, creating sounds that range from gentle trickling to a sizzling sizzle. The intensity and character of these sounds can correlate with the rate of glacial melt. A faster melt rate releases more bubbles, resulting in a louder sound, while a slower rate produces quieter acoustics. Scientists are working to quantify these relationships, though variations in ice structure and iceberg shapes introduce complexities.
Beyond bubble sounds, researchers are also using underwater microphones (hydrophones) to capture the dramatic events of calving, where large ice chunks break off glaciers. These calving events produce distinct low-frequency rumbles that can originate deep within the water column. Submarine calving, where ice breaks off below the water's surface, poses a particular danger to boats as these icebergs can emerge unexpectedly. While the fracturing sounds might offer a slight warning, the primary goal with calving acoustics is to estimate the size and volume of ice lost and to understand how these events disturb fjord circulation, which in turn can contribute to further melting.
The inherent danger and inaccessibility of glacier fronts have historically limited direct observation. To overcome this, researchers are deploying sophisticated remote-controlled systems. These involve a remote-controlled boat carrying a remotely operated underwater vehicle (ROV). The ROV, in turn, deploys a drilling mechanism that anchors itself to the glacier, allowing for the attachment of hydrophones, melt sensors, video cameras, and current meters. This multi-layered remote operation, often requiring a team of four and supported by drones for oversight, allows for data collection for several hours without putting researchers in harm's way. Despite the complexity and cost of the equipment, these systems have demonstrated significant success in gathering invaluable data from these critical, yet hazardous, environments.
The data gathered from these acoustic and remote sensing methods are vital for improving our understanding of glacial dynamics and their broader implications. By studying the small-scale physical processes at the ice-ocean interface, scientists can refine large-scale climate models, leading to more accurate predictions about sea-level rise and future climate scenarios. While the sounds of melting glaciers carry a melancholy note, reflecting significant ice loss, they also highlight the fascinating beauty of Earth's processes and the vast unknowns that still exist in glaciology. The unique acoustic environments, such as the quieter, bubble-dissolving sounds beneath the Thwaites Ice Shelf, offer distinct perspectives on glacial behavior compared to those observed in Alaska.
Action Items
- Audit glacier melt sounds: Analyze 3-5 distinct sound profiles for correlation with melt rate and iceberg calving events.
- Implement remote monitoring system: Deploy 2-3 tethered ROVs with hydrophones and cameras to collect data at glacier termini for 3-hour intervals.
- Develop sound-to-melt rate model: Correlate recorded bubble-bursting sound intensity with measured ice melt rates across 5-10 glacier locations.
- Track submarine calving events: Use underwater hydrophones to document the size and water displacement of 3-5 submarine calving events to assess fjord circulation impact.
Key Quotes
"When glaciers form they form from snowfall high in the mountains and that process ends up trapping air bubbles as the snow gets compressed into ice and those little tiny bubbles travel through the glacier from way high up whether it's central greenland antarctica or just up in the mountains within the us and they eventually make their way all the way down to the end of the glacier and there's there's thousands millions quadrillions of them in there and as it melts out each little air bubble is pressurized because it's had this long journey and it just goes pop into the water and oscillates a little bit and so the sound will sound anywhere from the babbling brook which is what we just heard but if you're a little farther away and the ice is melting a little bit faster it can sound like a sizzling sizzling pan of food on the stove"
Dr. Aaron Pettit explains that the sounds of melting glaciers are caused by pressurized air bubbles trapped within the ice escaping as the glacier melts. She notes that the sound can vary from a babbling brook to a sizzling pan, depending on the rate of melting and the listener's distance. Pettit highlights that these sounds are a potential source of data for researchers studying climate change.
"Sound travels amazingly well in water so oceanographers have been using sound for a long long time to listen to what's going on in the ocean but until like 20 years ago nobody had ever thought to really look closely at what's going on at the terminus of a glacier and part of that's because it's really hard to get there like it's dangerous these cliffs are calving the ice is breaking off and forming icebergs there's just a lot going on and they can be quite dangerous to approach by boat or a ship and so we go up there and use sound because sound you can be back a little ways right you don't have to be quite as close to the glacier to really start to record some of the action happening"
Dr. Pettit discusses the advantage of using sound to study glaciers, drawing a parallel to oceanography's long-standing use of acoustics. She points out that the dangerous and inaccessible nature of glacier termini has historically limited close-up observation. Pettit explains that sound allows researchers to gather data from a safer distance, making it a more practical method for monitoring glacial activity.
"Wait why is it interesting to you it's interesting to me because we're losing ice everywhere in the world and it's really hard to keep track of how much we're losing and where we're losing it faster where it's melting faster where it's melting slower but that's really important to know so that we can start to one think about where that water goes when ice turns into water it contributes to the ocean and just being able to project into the future what do we think is going to happen next with these glaciers if they're melting if they're melting faster or slower underwater that affects how they're going to respond to changes in the future and we can put that into models we can think about it we can understand like just understanding the physics of what's going on is huge for starting to put that into perspective of how all the ice is changing on the earth"
Dr. Pettit emphasizes the scientific importance of understanding glacial melt rates due to global ice loss. She explains that tracking where and how quickly ice is melting is crucial for predicting where the meltwater will go and how glaciers will respond to future changes. Pettit states that understanding these physical processes is fundamental to modeling and comprehending the broader changes occurring across Earth's ice sheets.
"we actually have had pretty darn good success the four of us that are doing this this installation we like each other so that means that that like if somebody's messing up or something's going wrong we're we spend more time kind of laughing and trying to trying to get it right but we also are really scared because there's hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of equipment that we could lose so yeah it actually we practiced a lot on icebergs that are floating in a bit calmer water before going up to the glacier but when we we typically were successful like 50 of the time"
Dr. Pettit describes the collaborative and high-stakes nature of deploying their glacier monitoring equipment. She notes that the team's positive dynamic helps them navigate challenges, but the significant financial risk of losing equipment creates underlying tension. Pettit mentions that extensive practice on icebergs in calmer waters preceded their glacier deployments, where they achieved approximately 50% success.
"there certainly is i mean ice ice melting is part of the natural process like snow falls up high and then it melts or breaks off down low and so even in a climate in which we were growing glaciers we would still have sounds of ice melting but it is quite a bit more now than normal and we are listening to this ice loss that is not being recovered by snowfall up upstream and yes there is some melancholy to it there's a um it makes me just kind of think and reflect on the world around me and hopefully our whole society can think about and reflect on the world around us"
Dr. Pettit acknowledges the melancholy aspect of studying melting glaciers, distinguishing natural ice melt from current accelerated loss. She explains that while ice melt is a natural process, the current rate exceeds normal levels and is not being replenished by snowfall. Pettit suggests that this observation prompts personal reflection and hopes it encourages broader societal contemplation of the changing world.
Resources
External Resources
Books
- "The Doomsday Glacier" - Mentioned as a label for the Thwaites Glacier.
Research & Studies
- Thwaites Glacier Research (Oregon State University) - Mentioned in relation to studying glacial melt and calving events.
People
- Dr. Aaron Pettit - Professor of geophysics and glaciology at Oregon State University, involved in monitoring glaciers using sound.
- Flora Lichtman - Host of Science Friday.
- Charles Burquist - Producer of the podcast.
- Alex Honnold - Professional rock climber and founder of the Honnold Foundation, host of Planet Visionaries.
- Mark Ruffalo - Climate champion, guest on Planet Visionaries.
- Christina Mittermeier - Biologist and photographer, guest on Planet Visionaries.
- Chris Tompkins - Conservationist, guest on Planet Visionaries.
Organizations & Institutions
- Science Friday - Podcast mentioned as the platform for the discussion.
- Oregon State University - Institution where Dr. Aaron Pettit is a professor.
- Rolex Perpetual Planet Initiative - Partnered with Planet Visionaries podcast.
- Honnold Foundation - Founded by Alex Honnold.
Websites & Online Resources
- alienware.com/deals - Mentioned for Alienware sales.
- dell.com/deals - Mentioned for Dell PC deals.
- givewell.org - Mentioned for donating to cost-effective programs.
Podcasts & Audio
- Planet Visionaries - Podcast exploring conservation and featuring guests like Alex Honnold, Mark Ruffalo, Christina Mittermeier, and Chris Tompkins.
Other Resources
- ROV (Remotely Operated Underwater Vehicle) - Used for measuring glacier activity.
- Hydrophone - Underwater microphone used to record sounds from glaciers.
- Submarine calving event - Icebergs breaking off from underwater, posing a danger to boats.
- Calving events - Large chunks of ice breaking off from glaciers.
- Glacial meltwater - Water resulting from the melting of glaciers.
- Intel Core Ultra processors - Mentioned as a feature in Dell PCs.
- Dell PC - Mentioned for its features and holiday deals.
- Alienware PCs - Mentioned for performance and holiday savings.
- Alienware 16 Area 51m gaming laptop - Specific Alienware product mentioned.
- Alienware 32 4K QD-OLED gaming monitor - Specific Alienware product mentioned.
- AT&T - Mentioned as a reliable and fast network provider.
- GiveWell - Organization dedicated to researching and funding highly cost-effective programs.