Bats Pollinate Agave for Tequila; Monarch Migration Faces Threats
TL;DR
- Nectar-feeding bats are essential pollinators for agave plants, enabling sexual reproduction and maintaining genetic diversity, which is critical for tequila and mezcal production and ecosystem health.
- Unsustainable agave harvesting, cattle grazing, land use change, and drought threaten agave populations, jeopardizing the economic and cultural products derived from them and the bats that depend on them.
- Tiny solar-powered radio tags on monarch butterflies, transmitting via Bluetooth-enabled cell phones, provide unprecedented data on their migration routes, revealing their ability to self-correct after being blown off course.
- A significant percentage of tagged monarch butterflies successfully complete their thousands-of-miles migration to overwintering sites, suggesting greater resilience than previously assumed by some experts.
- Understanding monarch butterfly migration paths is crucial for conservation efforts, as drastic reductions in colony sizes indicate the migration is in trouble and may not persist for future generations.
Deep Dive
The discussion begins by highlighting the interconnectedness of bats, agave plants, and tequila production. Dr. Kristen Lear of Bat Conservation International explains that three species of nectar-feeding bats migrate between Mexico and the U.S. and feed on agave nectar, with one species, the Mexican long-nosed bat, being endangered. These bats are crucial pollinators for agave plants, carrying pollen over long distances, estimated at 50 kilometers or more one way from their roosts. This pollination is essential for maintaining the genetic diversity of agave populations, particularly for species that reproduce sexually. The source emphasizes that without these bats, tequila and mezcal production would not be possible, as these spirits are derived from flowering agave.
The conversation then shifts to the threats facing agaves. Unsustainable harvesting for liquor production is mentioned as a concern, alongside grazing cattle which consume agave growing stocks and native grasses. Land use change, agricultural expansion, and drought are also identified as significant threats, exacerbated by climate change, which can lead to increased wildfires. Dr. Lear further explains the importance of agaves beyond their connection to bats, noting their economic value for products like tequila, mezcal, and agave syrup, as well as their cultural significance, role in erosion control, medicinal uses, and utility as cattle fodder during droughts.
The discussion explores different motivations for agave conservation, including beautifying landscapes, providing sustainable food fodder for livestock, and, from the perspective of "bat people," saving the bats. For those living on or near agave land, the reasons for protection are presented as a combination of economic, environmental, and aesthetic factors. The source also touches on ways individuals can help bats, noting that while nectar-feeding bats do not use bat boxes, planting native night-blooming flowers and agaves can create "bat gardens" that support insectivorous bats.
Progress on agave restoration efforts is detailed, with over 180,000 agaves planted across the binational migratory corridor through partnerships with various groups in the U.S. and Mexico. These efforts also include restoring the land through sustainable grazing and management practices and supporting community green business enterprises. Monitoring of bat roosts indicates that numbers for the endangered Mexican long-nosed bat are stabilizing, suggesting the restoration efforts are having a positive impact.
The episode then transitions to the migration of monarch butterflies. Science journalist Dan Fagan discusses primitive methods of tracking monarchs, such as sticker tags that only indicated origin. He highlights the recent development of radio tags small enough to be glued to a monarch's thorax, allowing researchers to track their entire journeys. These solar-powered tags transmit data continuously and can be picked up by any Bluetooth-enabled cell phone, creating billions of potential monitoring stations.
The data from these tagged monarchs has revealed surprising findings. Fagan notes that monarchs can be blown significantly off course but often have the ability to reorient themselves and continue their southward journey. He also shares that a decent percentage of tagged monarchs make it to the Mexican overwintering sites, suggesting that more may survive the journey than previously thought. The primary problem these tagged flights are attempting to solve is the drastic reduction in monarch numbers observed at their overwintering sites, which threatens the continuation of their multi-generational life cycle. Understanding their migration paths is deemed critical for protecting the future of migrating monarchs, with serious questions raised about their presence in 20 or 30 years.
Action Items
- Implement Bluetooth LE beacon tracking: Deploy 5-10 beacons along key agave restoration corridors to monitor bat movement patterns and identify critical nectar sources.
- Audit agave grazing impact: For 3-5 high-density cattle grazing areas, measure agave seedling survival rates and compare them to areas with managed grazing practices.
- Design bat-friendly agave cultivation guidelines: Create a 5-section guide for sustainable agave harvesting, detailing practices that preserve nectar-producing flowers and minimize habitat disruption.
- Track monarch butterfly flight deviations: Analyze data from 50-100 tagged monarchs to identify common off-course flight patterns and potential environmental factors causing them.
- Develop a bat garden planting guide: Outline 5-7 native, night-blooming plant species suitable for various regions to support insectivorous bat populations.
Key Quotes
"now one place that the pollinator role is crucial is in the relationship between bats and agave plants and that has consequences both for the ecosystems around the agave and for your liquor cabinets since agave is the source of drinks like tequila and mezcal now you get it right well here to explain this seemingly strange connection is dr kristen lear director of the agave restoration initiative at bat conservation international welcome to science friday"
Dr. Kristen Lear explains the vital connection between bats and agave plants, highlighting how this relationship directly impacts both the ecosystem and the production of tequila and mezcal. This quote establishes the central theme of the bat-agave interaction and its broader economic and ecological significance.
"these bats are as they're feeding from the agave flowers they're kind of these clumsy flyers when they go up to the agave flowers and they kind of clumsily fall onto the flowers and they get covered in pollen and then they spread that pollen over miles between different agave plants these bats can fly 50 kilometers or more one way from a roost at night to go feed and then go back to their roost so they're really spreading that agave pollen across those different agave populations and really helping maintain the genetic diversity of those plants"
Dr. Kristen Lear details the mechanism by which bats act as pollinators for agave plants, emphasizing their role in spreading pollen over significant distances. This quote illustrates the practical, physical process of pollination and underscores the bats' contribution to maintaining the genetic health of agave populations.
"you know because they're out at night we get to see butterflies and bees and hummingbirds you know during the day but these bats are kind of this mysterious unknown pollinator just because they're out at night and we don't get to see them so can the agaves reproduce without the bats"
Dr. Kristen Lear describes bats as "mysterious unknown pollinator[s]" due to their nocturnal activity, contrasting them with more visible daytime pollinators like bees and butterflies. This quote highlights the often-overlooked importance of bats in pollination and sets up a discussion about the necessity of bats for agave reproduction.
"there's now technology that creates a radio tag that's small enough they can actually be glued to the thorax of a monarch butterfly and for the first time we know not only where these journeys start and end but we know everywhere that monarchs go in between and it's pretty amazing"
Dan Fagan explains the revolutionary impact of new radio tagging technology on monarch butterfly migration research. This quote emphasizes how this innovation allows scientists to track the complete journey of individual butterflies, moving beyond previous, more limited tracking methods.
"as a result there are literally billions of potential monitoring stations for these tags and you can get very robust data it's not perfect data there are still spots that are not well covered but there are so many bluetooth enabled cell phones that there are not very many of these dead spots in fact some of the monarchs have even been tracked over the ocean because they come close enough to a passing boat for example"
Dan Fagan describes the widespread data collection capabilities enabled by Bluetooth-enabled cell phones acting as monitoring stations for the tagged monarch butterflies. This quote illustrates the scale and robustness of the data gathered, noting how even unexpected locations like over the ocean can be monitored.
"so we really need to understand what's happening on these migratory paths if we want to save the migration itself because there are serious questions ira as to whether we will see migrating monarchs 20 years from now 30 years from now what a shame that would be yeah it really would be i mean people love this butterfly and if we want to make progress in protecting it we need to really understand its migration much better and until now until this year the paths that monarchs took were almost a complete mystery and now we know"
Dan Fagan articulates the critical need to understand monarch butterfly migration paths to ensure the survival of the migration itself. This quote conveys the urgency of the situation, highlighting the potential for migrating monarchs to disappear within decades and stressing that current research is essential for conservation efforts.
Resources
External Resources
Books
- "The New York Times" - Mentioned as the publication for an article detailing how researchers are tracking individual butterflies as they migrate.
Articles & Papers
- "A Toast To Bats That Pollinate Agave, And Tracking Monarchs" (Science Friday) - Episode title discussing the connection between bats, agave plants, and tequila, and the tracking of monarch butterflies.
People
- Dr. Kristen Lear - Director of the Agave Restoration Initiative at Bat Conservation International, discussing the relationship between bats and agave plants.
- Dan Fagan - Science journalist and director of the Science Health and Environmental Reporting Program at New York University, discussing research on tracking monarch butterfly migration.
- Chip Taylor - Founder of Monarch Watch, who expressed surprise at findings from monarch butterfly tracking data.
Organizations & Institutions
- Bat Conservation International - Organization involved in the Agave Restoration Initiative.
- Monarch Watch - Organization involved in monarch butterfly research.
- New York University - Institution where Dan Fagan directs the Science Health and Environmental Reporting Program.
Websites & Online Resources
- sciencefriday.com - Website where a link to Dan Fagan's article on butterfly migration can be found.
- alienware.com/deals - Website for deals on Alienware PCs and accessories.
- mathworks.com - Website for MathWorks, creator of MATLAB and Simulink.
- dell.com/deals - Website for Dell Cyber Monday deals.
- givewell.org - Website for GiveWell, an organization focused on researching cost-effective charitable programs.
Other Resources
- Agave Restoration Initiative - Initiative working to restore agave plants.
- MATLAB and Simulink - Software for technical computing and model-based design created by MathWorks.
- Intel Core Ultra processors - Processors mentioned in relation to Alienware and Dell PCs.
- QLED gaming monitor - Type of monitor mentioned in relation to Alienware.
- Bluetooth enabled cell phones - Technology used for tracking monarch butterflies.
- Radio tag - Technology used to track individual monarch butterflies.
- Bat garden - Concept of planting night-blooming flowers to support bat populations.
- Bat boxes - Structures that some bat species roost in.
- Agave syrup - Product derived from agave plants.
- Tequila and Mezcal - Alcoholic beverages derived from agave plants.
- Bacanora - Alcoholic beverage derived from agave plants.
- Cyber Monday - Sales event mentioned in relation to Alienware and Dell.
- Rolex Perpetual Planet Initiative - Initiative partnered with the Planet Visionaries podcast.
- Planet Visionaries podcast - Podcast exploring conservation and solutions.
- Honnold Foundation - Foundation founded by Alex Honnold.
- Rootmetrics United States Root Score Report 1H 2025 - Report referenced for AT&T network performance.