Skilled Trades Offer Financial Security Amidst Gendered Industry Challenges - Episode Hero Image

Skilled Trades Offer Financial Security Amidst Gendered Industry Challenges

Original Title:

TL;DR

  • Union apprenticeships provide free, paid education and a clear career path, enabling individuals to earn 80% of journeyman wages ($34/hour) within four years, significantly surpassing typical college debt and income trajectories.
  • The trades offer substantial financial stability and fulfillment, allowing individuals like Alden to escape poverty, achieve financial independence, and pursue personal joys without the constant anxiety of scarcity.
  • Despite the financial and personal rewards, women in construction face pervasive underestimation and isolation, requiring them to constantly prove their capabilities and navigate a male-dominated culture.
  • The "work to live" ethos prevalent in the trades prioritizes financial gain and personal well-being over career advancement, fostering a culture where earning money is openly acknowledged and pursued.
  • Alden's journey highlights how overcoming extreme money anxiety, rooted in childhood financial instability, requires building security through a stable, well-compensated career that aligns with personal values.
  • The dissolution of the "Sisters of the Brotherhood" union initiative due to fear of administration lawsuits underscores the ongoing challenges for women in trades seeking organized support and power.

Deep Dive

Alden, a union carpenter in Massachusetts, demonstrates how the skilled trades can offer significant financial stability and personal fulfillment, but also highlights the persistent challenges faced by women in construction. Her experience reveals that while trade work provides a viable alternative to traditional higher education, offering substantial income and benefits, it demands resilience against industry-specific sexism and potential economic precarity during periods of layoff or training.

The core argument is that the trades offer a pathway to financial security and a sense of purpose, directly countering the societal emphasis on college degrees. Alden's apprenticeship, a four-to-five-year program combining paid on-the-job training with free schooling, allows her to earn a living wage while acquiring valuable skills. By her fourth year, she earns 80% of a journeyman's rate, approximately $34 an hour, totaling around $48,000 annually before taxes, plus health insurance and a pension. This income is life-changing, enabling her to live independently for the first time and escape the financial anxiety ingrained from her parents' struggles with money. This financial stability allows for discretionary spending on hobbies like CrossFit and contributions to shared expenses with her girlfriend, demonstrating a tangible improvement in her quality of life.

However, this stability is not without its tensions. Alden frequently encounters sexism and underestimation from male colleagues, ranging from derogatory comments to being physically prevented from performing tasks. This constant need to prove herself and the general discomfort of being in a male-dominated environment contribute to feelings of isolation. Furthermore, periods of layoff between jobs, while mitigated by her savings, create financial stress, underscoring the inherent precarity in project-based work. The dissolution of the "Sisters in the Brotherhood," a national network for women in carpentry, due to fears of administrative backlash, further exacerbates this isolation by removing a crucial support system for women entering the trades.

The implications of Alden's experience are twofold. First, it underscores the critical need to destigmatize and promote trade work as a financially rewarding and fulfilling career path, particularly for those who do not pursue higher education. The trades offer a direct route to economic independence and a sense of accomplishment through tangible skill-building. Second, it highlights the ongoing systemic challenges for women in these industries. The persistence of sexism, the lack of robust support networks, and the potential for job insecurity require active efforts to create more inclusive and equitable environments. Alden's journey suggests that while individual resilience and financial acumen can overcome many obstacles, broader cultural and structural changes are necessary to ensure that the trades are truly accessible and supportive for everyone.

Action Items

  • Audit apprenticeship program: Identify 3-5 key skill gaps for new apprentices and develop targeted training modules to address them.
  • Create a mentorship framework: Pair 5-10 experienced tradeswomen with new apprentices to foster knowledge transfer and combat isolation.
  • Develop a financial literacy module: Outline 3-5 core principles for managing income and expenses, specifically for trades professionals, to mitigate money anxiety.
  • Draft a conflict resolution guide: Provide strategies for navigating workplace microaggressions and biases, focusing on 2-3 common scenarios encountered by women in construction.

Key Quotes

"I do think that there's like at least big portions of our culture that doesn't encourage trade work in the way that we encourage white collar work why do you think that is why don't we encourage people to go into the trades I think there's two reasons I think one reason is that there is not widespread knowledge that trades people make money like a lot of money and make good money and that it's a good job and you can get paid well like you can make just as much as people who go to college."

Alden argues that a significant cultural gap exists in promoting trade work compared to white-collar professions. She identifies two primary reasons for this: a lack of awareness regarding the substantial earning potential in trades, and a general underestimation of these jobs as viable, well-compensated career paths. Alden highlights that trade professions can offer financial rewards comparable to or even exceeding those from a college education.


"I'm making more going to trade school than I ever made going to college and then I think it's just like it's hard and dirty I'm like girl I have swamp ass all day like I am sweaty I am dirty I am tired I am fighting for my life but I do feel that most days it's worth it."

Alden directly contrasts her trade school earnings with her college experience, stating she earns more now. She candidly describes the physically demanding and often uncomfortable nature of the work, including being sweaty and dirty. Despite these challenges, Alden asserts that the effort is generally worthwhile, indicating a strong sense of personal fulfillment and value derived from her chosen career path.


"A lot of people are encouraged to go to college and pay thousands of dollars for a degree whereas an apprenticeship is not something you pay for it's something that you get paid for so you do an apprenticeship and you learn by working and you get paid to do it until you finish your apprenticeship and become a journeyman."

Alden explains a key advantage of the apprenticeship system by contrasting it with traditional college education. She points out that apprenticeships are paid opportunities where individuals learn through hands-on work, rather than incurring significant debt for a degree. Alden emphasizes that this model allows participants to earn income while acquiring skills and progressing towards becoming a journeyman.


"I have a safety net now of my own you know like the only way to heal an insecure attachment is to build security with it and so I feel like by choosing a life where I was no longer afraid of money and afraid of making money and having money I've been able to start I mean I still struggle so much and I always will I think but I think I've really been able to create that secure attachment with money by knowing that it's there and it's not going anywhere and you're going to be okay."

Alden reflects on how her current financial situation has positively impacted her relationship with money. She believes that by actively choosing a career that provides financial security and stability, she has begun to overcome her previous money anxiety. Alden suggests that building this security has been instrumental in developing a more stable and less fearful attachment to her finances.


"I feel that what I want financially now in my life is not excess and not extreme wealth because that is totally fundamentally opposed to all that I believe in but I want security and enough to feel like I can really experience the joy of my life without the anxiety about money and I feel like I'm getting there I feel like I'm pretty close actually."

Alden articulates her current financial aspirations, which are centered on security rather than excessive wealth. She states that her desire for financial stability is rooted in her personal beliefs and aims to enable her to enjoy life without constant money-related anxiety. Alden expresses optimism that she is nearing this goal, indicating a sense of progress and contentment with her financial outlook.


"I feel both isolated in my work life because I'm surrounded by 98 men and that's really lonely and then I can feel really isolated in my personal life around the people who are supposed to be my peers because we just experience really different things every day like I think a lot of my friends they work with other young people other queer people they work with other women they are kind of in a different culture and I go to work and I hang out with conservative men all day."

Alden describes a dual sense of isolation stemming from both her professional and personal environments. She feels lonely at work due to being in a male-dominated field and also experiences isolation within her peer groups because her daily life and experiences differ significantly from theirs. Alden highlights the cultural divide between her work environment and her social circles, noting the contrast between interacting with conservative men at work and her peers in other cultural contexts.

Resources

External Resources

Books

  • "The Geography of Nowhere" by James Howard Kunstler - Mentioned as an example of a book that influenced a particular worldview.

Articles & Papers

  • "The Geography of Nowhere" (Source not specified) - Mentioned as a book that influenced a particular worldview.

People

  • Alden - Union carpenter in Massachusetts, featured in the episode.
  • Courtney Harrell - Host of "What We Spend."
  • James Howard Kunstler - Author of "The Geography of Nowhere."
  • Von Miller - Host of "Free Range with Von Miller."

Organizations & Institutions

  • Audacy - Mentioned in relation to listener data and privacy practices.
  • Blue Apron - Referenced as a meal delivery service that previously required a subscription.
  • Genius Bank - Mentioned as an award-winning bank.
  • Liberty Mutual - Referenced for car insurance.
  • National Football League (NFL) - Mentioned in the context of sports analytics.
  • Odyssey - Mentioned as the producer of the podcast "What We Spend."
  • Pro Football Focus (PFF) - Mentioned as a data source for player grading.
  • RingCentral - Referenced for business communication services with AI features.
  • Smbc Manubank - Mentioned as the parent company of Genius Bank.
  • Spot Pet Insurance - Mentioned as a business that uses TikTok for advertising.
  • Tito's Handmade Vodka - Referenced as a vodka brand.
  • UBC (United Brotherhood of Carpenters) - Mentioned as the union that is dissolving the Sisters of the Brotherhood.
  • USA Fencing - Referenced for information on fencing classes.

Websites & Online Resources

  • audacyinc.com/privacy-policy - Mentioned for listener data and privacy practices.
  • blueapron.com/terms - Mentioned for terms and conditions related to Blue Apron.
  • geniusbank.com - Mentioned as the website for Genius Bank.
  • getstarted.tiktok.com - Mentioned as the website to start advertising on TikTok.
  • libertymutual.com - Mentioned as the website for Liberty Mutual.
  • podcastchoices.com/adchoices - Mentioned for ad choices.
  • ringcentral.com - Mentioned as the website for RingCentral.
  • tiktok.com - Mentioned as a platform for business advertising.
  • usafencing.org - Mentioned for finding fencing classes.
  • whatwespendpodcast@gmail.com - Mentioned as the email address for the podcast.

Podcasts & Audio

  • Free Range with Von Miller - Mentioned as a podcast hosted by Von Miller.
  • The Draymond Green Show - Mentioned as a podcast hosted by Draymond Green.
  • What We Spend - The podcast featuring Alden's story.

Other Resources

  • AI (Artificial Intelligence) - Mentioned in relation to RingCentral's business communication features.
  • CrossFit - Mentioned as a fitness activity Alden participates in.
  • Fencing - Mentioned as an Olympic and Paralympic sport.
  • Sisters of the Brotherhood - Mentioned as a national collection of women in the carpenters union.
  • TikTok for Business - Mentioned as an advertising platform for small businesses.
  • Union Apprenticeship System - Discussed as a pathway to skilled trades.
  • Work-Life Balance - Discussed as a principle Alden tries to practice.

---
Handpicked links, AI-assisted summaries. Human judgment, machine efficiency.
This content is a personally curated review and synopsis derived from the original podcast episode.