Dollar Depreciation Expected Amidst Fed Policy Shifts and EM Carry Trade Opportunities
TL;DR
- Further dollar depreciation is expected in the first half of next year, driven by a resumption of US data and potential Fed policy shifts, impacting currency markets beyond developed economies.
- The debasement trade, initially fueled by global fiscal concerns, has stalled due to stable US interest rates, but could re-emerge if fiscal sustainability worries broaden to other developed nations.
- The Federal Reserve's upcoming rate decision and forward guidance on inflation versus unemployment risks will significantly influence short-term policy and the dollar's trajectory.
- Realized Fed rate cuts typically weaken the dollar, but market pricing suggests communication around future policy and 2026 dot plots will be more impactful.
- China's currency appreciation is a high-confidence trade for 2026, with low implied volatility in the options market suggesting a potential for dollar-China pair trades.
- Emerging market carry trades, particularly in Brazil, Mexico, and South African Rand, remain a preferred expression for dollar weakness due to higher interest rate differentials.
- Significant dollar depreciation could occur if substantial repatriation flows materialize from foreign entities holding dollar-denominated assets, exceeding current estimates.
Deep Dive
The US dollar is poised for further depreciation in the first half of next year, driven by a confluence of factors including a stabilization of US interest rates and potential shifts in global capital flows. While the dollar's trade-weighted index has been largely unchanged over the past eight months, this masks significant movements against higher-yielding currencies, suggesting that the trend of dollar weakness is likely to broaden. This outlook implies a recalibration of global investment strategies as the US becomes a relatively less attractive destination for capital.
The potential for dollar depreciation is underpinned by the expectation that US interest rates have ceased their decline, removing a key support for the currency. Furthermore, the "debasement trade," which saw a move away from fiat currencies into assets like cryptocurrency and gold, appears to have momentarily stalled due to the stabilization of US rates. However, concerns about fiscal sustainability, particularly in the UK and France, and the potential for looser fiscal policy in Japan, could reignite these debasement narratives. The upcoming announcement of the next Federal Reserve chair also carries significant implications for future monetary policy and, consequently, the dollar's trajectory. The market anticipates a Fed rate cut, with the accompanying communication regarding future policy and the outlook for 2026 likely to be more impactful than the cut itself.
The most compelling opportunities lie in currency markets beyond the traditional dollar pairings. The Chinese yuan is expected to continue appreciating, with options markets pricing in historically low volatility, making a long yuan position attractive. Additionally, a basket of emerging market currencies, specifically the Brazilian Real, Mexican Peso, and South African Rand, are favored expressions of dollar weakness due to their higher interest rate differentials. These carry trades offer significant total returns, driven by both currency appreciation and attractive yields. The potential for significant repatriation of dollar holdings by foreign investors and corporations, should carry trade dynamics shift unfavorably for the dollar, could lead to an overshooting of depreciation estimates. This signals a broader shift away from over-allocation to US assets, reflecting a less exceptional return environment compared to the past fifteen years.
Action Items
- Track currency appreciation: For China, measure monthly appreciation against USD over the next 2 years.
- Analyze EM carry trades: Evaluate Brazil, Mexico, and South African Rand for dollar weakness expression (first half of next year).
- Measure dollar depreciation: Calculate USD depreciation against developed market currencies (5-10% target) based on fair value models.
- Evaluate repatriation flows: Monitor potential currency inflows from foreign entities holding USD revenues, contingent on carry breakdown.
Key Quotes
"I do think that there is further scope for the dollar to to sell off in in the first half of next year. Um and just sort of taking stock of where we are, I think it's interesting that the conversation we had in late April of this year was very much focused on uh developed market currencies so the dollar versus things like the euro or the Japanese yen."
Brian Dunne indicates that he anticipates a decline in the US dollar during the initial half of the upcoming year. Dunne highlights that previous discussions focused on the dollar's performance against other major developed market currencies, such as the euro and Japanese yen.
"What has moved instead has actually been the dollar against uh higher yielding currencies so the best example of that would be Brazil this year. Brazil has appreciated about 17% year to date in spot returns but because of the high nominal and real interest rate carry that it has in total returns, it's appreciated almost 30% and most of that has come after we spoke."
Brian Dunne points out that significant currency movements have occurred against higher-yielding currencies, using Brazil as a prime example. Dunne explains that while Brazil's spot returns showed a 17% appreciation, the total returns were nearly 30% due to high interest rate carry.
"The debasement trade for me was really always a concern about fiscal sustainability really across the globe. You started seeing things like crypto, things like gold start to appreciate particularly rapidly around, you know, around Liberation Day actually, and that was mostly a US fiscal sustainability concern."
Brian Dunne clarifies that the "debasement trade" is fundamentally linked to concerns about fiscal sustainability globally. Dunne notes that assets like cryptocurrency and gold saw rapid appreciation, particularly around a specific event, driven primarily by worries about US fiscal sustainability.
"The difference now on the go forward is that we won't we're very unlikely to have that. We have two, you know, two things that are very significant: one being we get the resumption of US data and labor market has been particularly in focus, and then second is we're going to get an announcement of who the Trump administration is nominating to be the Fed chair."
Brian Dunne explains that the current market environment is set to change due to two key upcoming events. Dunne identifies the resumption of US economic data, with a specific focus on the labor market, and the announcement of the next Fed chair nominee as significant drivers.
"I would say, um, the market has coalesced around them cutting again. I think it'll be interesting to see what level of, um, descent, you know, is publicly made. We had two last time, one was Maren for 50 and one was Schmidt for no cut."
Brian Dunne observes that the market consensus is anticipating another interest rate cut from the Federal Reserve. Dunne expresses interest in observing the extent of public disagreement within the Fed, referencing previous instances of dissenting votes on rate decisions.
"I would say dollar China lower in optionalized format is one of my favorite trades going into 2026. And then I would say some basket of EM carries, they'll it's still our bet, our favorite and preferred expression for dollar weakness."
Brian Dunne identifies specific trading strategies he favors for the upcoming period. Dunne highlights a "dollar China lower" trade in options as a top pick and also favors a basket of emerging market carry trades as a preferred way to express a view on dollar weakness.
Resources
External Resources
Articles & Papers
- "Why the Dollar Could Drop" (The Markets) - Discussed as the topic of the podcast episode, exploring potential drivers for the US dollar's next move and trading opportunities in currency markets.
People
- Brian Dunne - Head of Americas Foreign Exchange Options Trading at Goldman Sachs Global Banking & Markets, guest on the podcast discussing currency markets.
- Chris Hussey - Host of "The Markets" podcast.
Organizations & Institutions
- Goldman Sachs - Mentioned as the institutional affiliation of Brian Dunne and the provider of the podcast content.
- US (United States) - Referenced in relation to economic data, fiscal sustainability, and monetary policy.
- China - Discussed in the context of currency appreciation and options market pricing.
- Brazil - Mentioned as an example of a higher-yielding currency that has appreciated.
- Japan - Referenced in relation to potential looser fiscal policy following election results.
- UK (United Kingdom) - Mentioned in the context of fiscal concerns.
- France - Mentioned in the context of fiscal concerns.
Websites & Online Resources
- megaphone.fm/adchoices - Provided as a link for learning more about ad choices.
Other Resources
- DXY (Trade Weighted Index) - Referenced as an index measuring the US dollar against a basket of currencies.
- Debasement Trade - Discussed as a concept related to concerns about fiscal sustainability and a move away from fiat currency.
- Crypto - Mentioned as an asset class that saw a rally as part of the debasement trade.
- Gold - Referenced as a traditional hard asset that appreciated during periods of concern about fiscal sustainability.
- Fed (Federal Reserve) - Discussed in relation to interest rate decisions and the nomination of a new Fed chair.
- Jackson Hole - Referenced as a location for previous communication from the Fed chair.
- EM (Emerging Markets) Carries - Discussed as a preferred expression for dollar weakness.
- Brazilian Real - Mentioned as an example of an EM carry trade.
- South African Rand - Mentioned as an example of an EM carry trade.
- Mexican Peso - Mentioned as an example of an EM carry trade.