Coprolite Study Revolutionized Paleontology and Revealed Eccentric Scientist
TL;DR
- Studying fossilized feces (coprolite) enabled William Buckland to deduce extinction events and reconstruct ancient food chains, revolutionizing early paleontology beyond biblical explanations.
- Buckland's scientific curiosity extended to tasting unusual substances and foods, demonstrating a unique, albeit eccentric, method of empirical investigation and understanding the world.
- The creation of a tabletop from fossilized feces highlights Buckland's eccentric personality and his desire to integrate his professional scientific passion into his domestic life.
- Buckland's research into coprolites, particularly from fossilized ichthyosaurs, allowed for the reconstruction of ancient diets and food webs, providing unprecedented insight into prehistoric ecosystems.
- Buckland's scientific contributions, including the concept of extinction derived from analyzing animal excrement, were recognized with major awards, underscoring the significance of his unconventional research.
Deep Dive
William Buckland, an early paleontologist, utilized fossilized feces, or coprolite, to make groundbreaking discoveries about prehistoric life, including the concept of extinction. His professional fascination with excrement extended into his personal life, leading to eccentric habits, including unusual dining experiences and the creation of a unique "poop table," demonstrating that scientific inquiry can emerge from the most unexpected sources.
Buckland's scientific contributions were significantly advanced by his meticulous study of coprolites. His initial breakthrough occurred when investigating bones found in Kirkdale Cave. While contemporaries attributed the presence of exotic animal bones to Noah's Ark, Buckland observed chewed bones and fossilized stones resembling hyena droppings. This led him to deduce that hyenas had inhabited Britain millennia ago, a conclusion that supported the then-nascent idea of extinction and earned him scientific acclaim. Later, working with Mary Anning, he identified coprolites within the digestive tracts of fossilized ichthyosaurs. By examining the contents of these fossilized feces, Buckland could reconstruct ancient food chains, demonstrating the profound insights that could be gleaned from studying animal waste.
This scientific curiosity bled into Buckland's personal life, manifesting in eccentric behaviors. He was known for his theatrical lectures at Oxford, often acting out animal behaviors and carrying samples of coprolite and bone to share. His household was filled with pets and constant scientific experiments for his children, such as having a turtle walk across pie crust to compare its footprint to fossilized tracks. His dietary habits were particularly unusual; he reportedly sought to taste every animal on Earth, hosting dinners that featured exotic dishes like elephant trunk, frogs, and mice on toast. He also tasted unique substances, such as licking the floor of an Italian cathedral to identify it as bat urine and consuming a piece of what was claimed to be the mummified heart of King Louis XIV. While the motivations behind these extreme behaviors remain speculative--ranging from genuine scientific inquiry and a fixation on the food chain to a desire for notoriety--Buckland's explorations did not appear to lead to significant illness, with his death attributed to tuberculosis.
The culmination of Buckland's unique interests is the "poop table," created around 1840 from fish coprolites sourced from Scotland. He prominently displayed this table in his drawing-room, often delighting in guests admiring its beauty without realizing its origins. This table serves as a tangible representation of Buckland's unconventional approach to science, where even fossilized excrement became a source of valuable knowledge and a conversation piece, highlighting how profound discoveries can arise from the most unlikely materials and eccentric pursuits.
Action Items
- Audit coprolite sourcing: Verify 3-5 distinct geological origins for fossilized feces used in decorative items.
- Create coprolite analysis framework: Define 5 key characteristics (e.g., mineral composition, fossil inclusions) for identifying and classifying fossilized feces.
- Measure public perception of coprolite: Survey 10-15 individuals on their reactions to and understanding of fossilized feces in decorative contexts.
- Document Buckland's dietary habits: Compile a list of 5-10 unique food items consumed by William Buckland for scientific analysis.
- Design coprolite-based educational display: Develop a prototype showcasing 3-5 examples of fossilized feces with explanations of their scientific significance.
Key Quotes
"These bug-type looking things are actually not bugs at all. They're a material called coprolite, which is a scientific term for essentially fossilized feces. These beautiful stones that we're looking at, this is all poop. This is not a pool table, it's a poop table. It is a lot of poop."
The hosts explain that the decorative elements on the table are made from coprolite, which is fossilized feces. This quote highlights the surprising and unusual material used in the table's construction, setting the stage for the discussion about William Buckland.
"To get a quick temperature check of how people in England thought about the world and science at this time, this is decades before Darwin, long before carbon dating, and most people's understanding of the world came from the Bible. So people were like, 'Well, sure, these animals must have washed from the ark.'"
The hosts provide context for the scientific understanding of the era, noting that explanations for unusual findings often relied on biblical narratives like Noah's Ark. This quote illustrates the limited scientific frameworks available to people before major advancements like Darwin's theory of evolution and carbon dating.
"He made this connection because he went to zoos frequently. He was a huge animal lover and very interested in animals. He noticed that these stones looked a lot like the hyena enclosure, or the enclosures that he had visited at the zoo, and the poop that they left everywhere. He was thinking that these stones were perhaps not just stones."
The hosts describe how William Buckland's personal interests and observations led him to a scientific breakthrough. Buckland's familiarity with zoo animals and their waste allowed him to recognize the fossilized stones as coprolite, challenging prevailing explanations.
"Buckland understood that he had landed on a fruitful research topic, and this kind of became his thing. A few years after this, he traveled to this part of England that's known as the Jurassic Coast because there are so many fossils there. He linked up with this woman named Mary Anning, who was an avid fossil collector, and she had found this incredible fossilized fish creature that looked basically like a prehistoric swordfish."
The hosts explain how Buckland's initial discovery propelled his scientific career and led him to collaborate with other notable figures. This quote shows Buckland's continued dedication to studying fossils and his connection with Mary Anning, a prominent fossil collector.
"At baseline, Buckland was an eccentric man. From his earliest days lecturing in Oxford, he was that over-the-top professor where he'd be stomping around, acting out the animals he was talking about. He carried around a little bag of coprolite and bone and stuff to show off when he was talking to people."
The hosts describe William Buckland's personality and teaching style, characterizing him as an eccentric and engaging professor. This quote illustrates Buckland's unconventional approach to education and his passion for his subject matter, even in his daily interactions.
"William Buckland apparently at some point became interested in this idea of eating every animal on Earth just to try it. So the Bucklands had these crazy dinners, and they would invite people over, and they would be serving like elephant trunk and frogs and mice on toast and moles and hedgehogs and just all of these different creatures."
The hosts detail the unusual dining habits of William Buckland and his wife, highlighting their adventurous and eclectic culinary experiments. This quote showcases Buckland's extreme curiosity and willingness to taste a wide variety of animals, extending his scientific exploration into his personal life.
Resources
External Resources
Books
- "Atlas Obscura: An Explorer's Guide to the World's Hidden Wonders" by Johanna Mayer and Amanda McGowen - Mentioned as the podcast's co-production.
People
- William Buckland - Subject of the episode, known for his work in paleontology and his creation of a "poop table."
- Mary Anning - Fossil collector who collaborated with William Buckland.
- King Louis XIV - His mummified heart was mentioned as something William Buckland ate.
Organizations & Institutions
- Lyme Regis Museum - Location of the "poop table."
- Oxford - Location where William Buckland lectured.
- Sirius XM Podcasts - Co-producer of the podcast.
Websites & Online Resources
- Atlas Obscura - Co-production of the podcast.
- Angie.com - Mentioned for home projects.
Other Resources
- Coprolite - Scientific term for fossilized feces, the material used in the "poop table."
- Ichthyosaur - A fossilized fish creature with a long tusk, found by Mary Anning.
- The Ark - Biblical reference used to explain the presence of non-native animal bones in England.
- Darwin - Mentioned in relation to the timeline of scientific understanding.
- Carbon dating - Mentioned as a technology that did not exist in William Buckland's time.
- The Jurassic Coast - A region in England known for its fossils.
- The Poop Table - The central artifact discussed in the episode, made from coprolite.