Solar System Volcanoes: From Earth's Fire to Icy Moon Plumes
TL;DR
- Volcanoes on icy moons like Enceladus erupt plumes of gases and ice particles, with some material forming Saturn's E ring, indicating active subsurface oceans and potential for organic molecules.
- Mars's large volcanoes, like Olympus Mons, grew to immense sizes due to its lower gravity and lack of plate tectonics, allowing magma plumes to erupt in the same location for extended periods.
- Earth's magnetic field, crucial for shielding the atmosphere from solar wind, is generated by the molten iron in its outer core, which is sustained by residual heat from formation and radioactive decay.
- Supervolcanoes, such as Yellowstone, pose a significant threat through caldera eruptions that can devastate vast areas, but their eruption cycles are long and difficult to predict with certainty.
- Ice volcanoes, or cryovolcanoes, are common beyond the asteroid belt, erupting materials like water ice, ammonia, and methane, and are a key indicator of internal heat and activity on outer solar system bodies.
- The size of a volcano is determined by factors like planetary gravity and the presence or absence of plate tectonics, with Mars's weak gravity and stagnant lid allowing for much larger volcanic structures than Earth.
- Volcanic activity on Earth, while a manifestation of planetary cooling, is sustained by both residual heat from formation and continuous radioactive decay, with larger planets retaining more internal heat.
Deep Dive
Volcanic activity in the solar system extends beyond Earth, encompassing both fiery eruptions on rocky planets and icy cryovolcanism on celestial bodies further from the Sun. This broadens our understanding of planetary geology and the potential for geological processes to shape diverse worlds.
The solar system hosts a variety of volcanic phenomena, from the well-known terrestrial volcanoes to cryovolcanoes on icy moons and dwarf planets. Earth's neighbor, Venus, shows extensive evidence of past and potentially ongoing volcanic activity, with its surface covered in lava flows, though its thick atmosphere obscures direct observation. Beyond the asteroid belt, moons of gas giants like Jupiter and Saturn exhibit cryovolcanism. These "ice volcanoes" erupt volatile substances like water, ammonia, and methane, driven by internal heat generated through tidal forces. Enceladus, a moon of Saturn, famously ejects plumes of material that contribute to Saturn's E ring, offering direct evidence of subsurface oceans and active geology. This prevalence of ice volcanoes suggests they may be more common than the hot, rocky volcanoes seen in the inner solar system.
The scale and nature of volcanoes are influenced by planetary properties such as gravity and the presence or absence of plate tectonics. Mars, with its lower gravity and lack of plate tectonics, hosts Olympus Mons, the largest volcano in the solar system. Earth's plate tectonics, a unique process where crustal plates move and interact, create volcanic chains and shape volcanic landscapes. In contrast, Mars's stagnant lid, where the crust does not move, allows mantle plumes to repeatedly erupt in the same location, leading to the immense size of volcanoes like Olympus Mons. If such a volcano were placed on Earth, its own weight would cause it to collapse due to Earth's stronger gravity.
Volcanic activity plays a role in a planet's internal heat regulation and the maintenance of its magnetic field. Volcanoes are a primary mechanism by which a planet releases internal heat into space, contributing to its long-term cooling. Earth retains significant internal heat from its formation and from ongoing radioactive decay, which powers its geological activity. The molten outer core of Earth, a consequence of this internal heat, generates the planet's magnetic field, which shields the atmosphere and surface from harmful solar radiation. Mars, having cooled more significantly due to its smaller size, has lost its global magnetic field, leaving its atmosphere more vulnerable to solar wind stripping.
While Earth's gravity prevents volcanic eruptions from ejecting material into space, other celestial bodies demonstrate this capability. The plumes from Enceladus reach significant altitudes, contributing to Saturn's rings. Asteroids and comets can also exhibit volcanic or plume-generating activity, which can alter their trajectories. Comets, in particular, can have unpredictable orbits due to outgassing near the Sun. Regarding supervolcanoes on Earth, while they possess the potential for catastrophic caldera eruptions, our ability to monitor them provides some assurance. Seismic surveys can indicate the presence of magma chambers, and smaller, less devastating eruptions can release pressure over time, potentially mitigating the risk of a single, massive event. However, predicting the exact timing and scale of such eruptions remains a challenge, and efforts to artificially induce or control volcanic activity are deemed too risky and unpredictable.
Action Items
- Audit solar system bodies: Identify 3-5 icy moons and 2-3 rocky planets exhibiting cryovolcanic or volcanic activity.
- Analyze planetary formation: For 2-3 terrestrial planets, investigate how initial heat and radioactive decay influence internal temperature and volcanic activity.
- Measure volcanic impact: For 3-5 celestial bodies, quantify the relationship between tidal heating and observed volcanic activity.
- Track plume composition: For 2-3 active cryovolcanic moons, analyze plume ejecta to determine the presence of organic molecules and potential for life.
- Evaluate geological processes: For 3-5 celestial bodies, compare the influence of plate tectonics versus stagnant lid convection on volcano size and formation.
Key Quotes
"I started out as a geologist because I was fascinated by volcanoes and I'm just wondering how do you if if you're a geologist at all how could you not be fascinated by volcanoes because that reshapes your planet right so well exactly exactly I I think the thing for me was that I didn't even really know what geology was when I was at school because you don't really do it as a core subject"
Natalie Starkey explains that her initial fascination with volcanoes, which led her to study geology, stemmed from their planet-reshaping power. She notes that geology is not a common core subject in schools, implying that many may not discover this field of study. Starkey highlights that the inherent power of volcanoes is what initially captured her scientific curiosity.
"but then suddenly I'm combining all of these expertise and so it kind of led on after my first book which was about comets and asteroids and I wrote all about those first then I was like hold on I'm gonna combine this all and write about volcanoes and space because it just seemed like the natural thing to do"
Natalie Starkey describes how her expertise evolved from studying Earth's geology and volcanoes to incorporating space science. She explains that after writing a book on comets and asteroids, she realized she could combine her knowledge of volcanoes with her newfound interest in space. Starkey views this integration as a natural progression of her scientific inquiry.
"Most of the bodies out there are actually ice volcanoes so these are these are active places wait wait wait wait wait you're speaking like okay yeah most of the volcanoes in the solar system yeah yeah this is cool like do people even know we have volcanoes other places than earth"
Natalie Starkey introduces the concept of "ice volcanoes" or cryovolcanoes, which are prevalent in the outer solar system. She expresses surprise that this might be a novel idea to many, suggesting that the common perception of volcanoes is limited to Earth. Starkey emphasizes that these icy bodies are indeed active geological sites.
"So basically when we talk about magma or lava on for example Pluto let's take Pluto because that's a great example um it's not rocky the stuff that Pluto is made of it's all ice so when we talk about Pluto's magma it's basically just the molten version of whatever it's made of its bedrock is water ice and ammonia and methane and nitrogen"
Natalie Starkey clarifies that the concept of magma and lava applies to icy bodies as well, using Pluto as an example. She explains that on Pluto, the "magma" is composed of molten ice, ammonia, methane, and nitrogen, rather than molten rock. Starkey emphasizes that the composition of volcanic material varies depending on the celestial body.
"And that's exactly what happened with Olympus Mons cool which is the largest volcanic mountain in the solar system I think I think it's the largest mountain isn't it yeah okay good good"
Neil deGrasse Tyson confirms that Olympus Mons on Mars is the largest volcanic mountain in the solar system. He agrees with the assessment that it is the largest mountain overall. Tyson's interjection highlights the immense scale of this Martian geological feature.
"So the volcanoes are basically just a manifestation of a planet cooling itself down so it has all this internal heat and it needs to go somewhere and volcanoes let that heat escape into space which means we are cooling down we we are cooling down"
Natalie Starkey explains that volcanoes serve as a mechanism for planets to release internal heat as they cool down over time. She states that this process is a direct consequence of a planet's internal heat escaping into space. Starkey clarifies that volcanic activity is a sign of a planet's ongoing cooling process.
Resources
External Resources
Books
- "Surviving Galeras" by Stanley Williams - Mentioned as an inspiration for studying volcanoes.
- "Fire and Ice: The Volcanoes of the Solar System" by Natalie Starkey - Mentioned as the author's book on the topic of volcanoes in the solar system.
Articles & Papers
- "Fire and Ice" - Mentioned as the title of Natalie Starkey's book.
People
- Natalie Starkey - Cosmochemist, author of "Fire and Ice: The Volcanoes of the Solar System," public engagement officer at the Open University, and science communicator.
- Stanley Williams - Volcanologist, author of "Surviving Galeras."
- Neil deGrasse Tyson - Host of StarTalk Radio, personal astrophysicist.
- Matt Kirshen - Comedian, co-host of StarTalk Radio, host of the podcast "Probably Science."
Organizations & Institutions
- StarTalk Radio - Podcast where the discussion took place.
- Open University - Institution where Natalie Starkey works.
- Hayden Planetarium - Location where Natalie Starkey wrote the current space show "Worlds Beyond Earth."
- NASA - Space agency mentioned in relation to missions and data.
- ESA (European Space Agency) - Space agency mentioned in relation to missions.
Websites & Online Resources
- statestreet.com/im - Website mentioned for prospectus information regarding the DIA ETF.
- masterclass.com/startalk - Website mentioned for current offers on MasterClass subscriptions.
- sierraclub.org/startalk - Website mentioned for donating to the Sierra Club.
- rosettastone.com/pod50 - Website mentioned for a 50% off lifetime membership offer for Rosetta Stone.
Podcasts & Audio
- StarTalk Radio - Podcast where the discussion took place.
- Probably Science - Podcast hosted by Matt Kirshen.
- Casuals - Podcast hosted by Katie Nolan.
- Literally with Rob Lowe - Podcast hosted by Rob Lowe.
Other Resources
- DIA (SPDR Dow Jones Industrial Average ETF) - ETF mentioned in relation to investment.
- MasterClass - Online learning platform offering courses taught by experts.
- Sierra Club - Organization fighting to protect public lands.
- Rosetta Stone - Language learning program.
- Worlds Beyond Earth - Space show at the Hayden Planetarium written by Natalie Starkey.
- Pluto - Celestial body mentioned as having ice volcanoes.
- Enceladus - Moon of Saturn mentioned as having ice volcanoes and contributing to Saturn's E ring.
- Io - Moon of Jupiter mentioned as volcanically active.
- Europa - Moon of Jupiter mentioned as an ocean world with an ice cap.
- Olympus Mons - Largest volcanic mountain in the solar system, located on Mars.
- Vesuvius - Volcano in Italy famous for Pompeii.
- Yellowstone - Supervolcano in the United States.
- Comets - Celestial bodies mentioned as potentially having volcanoes and unpredictable orbits due to plumes.
- Asteroids - Celestial bodies mentioned as potentially having volcanoes.
- Psyche 16 - Asteroid mentioned as potentially having had iron volcanoes.
- Series - Celestial body in the asteroid belt mentioned as having ice volcanoes.
- Plate Tectonics - Geological process unique to Earth that creates volcanoes.
- Mantle Plumes - Chimneys of hot rock rising from Earth's interior that create volcanoes.
- Geothermal Energy - Energy generated from the heat of the Earth's interior, used in Iceland.
- Tidal Heating - Heat generated by gravitational forces, mentioned in relation to Enceladus.