Debunking Marching Band Judging Myths: Focus on Performance, Not Politics
Related Episodes
Marching Band Judging: Fact Versus Perception
Marching band judging is subjective and human, not rigged. This episode debunks conspiracy theories by revealing the robust safeguards and actual reasons behind competition results.
View Episode Notes →
Toxic Adult Culture Undermines Youth Arts Programs Through Gatekeeping
Toxic adult culture in youth arts programs stifles volunteerism and harms students. Prioritize community and knowledge sharing over credential flexing to foster safe learning environments and prevent program collapse.
View Episode Notes →
Marching Band Judging: Content Beats Perfection, Not Bias
Marching band judging reveals a nuanced system where music, visual, and general effect content and achievement, not raw scores, determine success, challenging common misconceptions about fairness and execution.
View Episode Notes →
Secondary Music Programs Sacrifice Academic Rigor for Performance Metrics
Secondary music programs sacrifice academic mastery for performance, leaving students unprepared for college. Shift focus from applause to curriculum to foster true musical scholars.
View Episode Notes →
Clarifying Parental Support for Band Programs Through Clear Communication
Prevent costly instrument mismatches and program friction by understanding how to effectively support band directors, not dictate their vision.
View Episode Notes →
Designing Tiered Boosters for Equity and Belonging
Tiered booster memberships can damage trust by implying existing contributions are insufficient. Design them with optional support lanes and recognize diverse contributions to foster belonging, not resentment.
View Episode Notes →Resources
Resources & Recommendations
Organizations & Institutions
- MSBA - Mentioned in the context of the 4A championships and a conspiracy theory about host schools winning.
- BOA (Bands of America) - Referenced in relation to schools dominating regional competitions due to consistent success.
- WGI (Winter Guard International) - Mentioned as an organization where certain groups consistently medal due to established programs.
Websites & Online Resources
- Facebook Group: SoundstageEDU Parent and Booster Support Group - A group for parents and boosters to engage in educated conversations and growth related to the activity.
- SoundstageEDU Insiders - A deeper dive community offering discounts, support, guidance, and community for those wanting more behind-the-scenes truth.