Art Transforms Suicide Prevention Through Lived Experience
TL;DR
- Art, specifically the song "Hold The Hope," transforms personal experiences of suicidality and caregiving into a powerful tool for suicide prevention training, making sessions more engaging and fostering open discussion.
- Caregivers in suicidal crises must prioritize the person's immediate needs over their own fears, detaching from potential outcomes to offer focused, steady, and calm presence.
- Validating a person's suicidal feelings by acknowledging their pain and expressing commitment to stay present, rather than disagreeing or panicking, is crucial for effective support.
- The 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline offers a vital resource for caregivers, providing coaching on how to respond to loved ones in crisis, which is often more effective than emergency room interventions.
- Shifting the narrative from weakness to strength by recognizing the "staying power" of individuals experiencing suicidal thoughts can help upend stigma and encourage help-seeking behavior.
- By sharing the experiences of those who live with suicidality, art like "Hold The Hope" increases the likelihood that others in crisis will seek help and find hope.
Deep Dive
This episode highlights how art, specifically a song titled "Hold the Hope," is transforming suicide prevention by centering the experiences of survivors and caregivers, thereby challenging stigma and fostering a more compassionate approach to mental health crises. The "so what" is that this artistic initiative, born from lived experience, offers a powerful model for broader societal engagement in suicide prevention, moving beyond clinical interventions to cultivate empathy and active support.
The core argument is that individuals living with suicidality possess immense inner strength, and caregivers play a crucial role by providing consistent emotional safety and presence rather than panicking or offering platitudes. This perspective is embodied in "Hold the Hope," a song derived from a poem by Joe Lambert, a caregiver. The song's lyrics emphasize the need for companions to "hold the space," "meet my hurt head on," and "embrace my human frailty," illustrating that change happens when someone has the courage to "go down into the hole and sit with them." This approach directly counters the common tendency to either dismiss suicidal ideation or react with an exaggerated, often unhelpful, response like immediate hospitalization. The implication is that by validating feelings and offering steady, calm presence, caregivers can create the emotional safety necessary for individuals to choose life. The episode stresses that this is an active choice, requiring focus on the person's immediate needs rather than the caregiver's fear of the outcome.
Furthermore, the initiative underscores that suicide prevention is not solely a professional domain but "everyone's business." By sharing the experiences of those who live with suicidality, as exemplified by the song's widespread use in NHS training, the likelihood of others in crisis seeking help increases. This is vital because data indicates that for every death by suicide, over 300 individuals experience suicidal thoughts or live with suicidality. The song's power lies in its ability to challenge the stigma that often views suicidal individuals as weak, instead reframing their persistence as a form of "staying power." This artistic expression serves as a critical reminder that with appropriate support, people can and do overcome persistent thoughts of death, reinforcing the idea that survival and recovery are common outcomes, not just tragic exceptions.
Ultimately, the key takeaway is that reframing suicide prevention through art and lived experience cultivates empathy and active participation, demonstrating that compassion and presence are as vital as clinical intervention in helping individuals navigate suicidal crises and choose life.
Action Items
- Create caregiver support framework: Define 3-5 key emotional needs for those supporting individuals in suicidal crisis (ref: "Hold The Hope" song insights).
- Draft training module: Outline 4-6 core principles for validating feelings and offering presence to individuals experiencing suicidal ideation (ref: Ursula Whiteside's advice).
- Implement 988 lifeline coaching: Train 5-10 team members on how to guide caregivers through responding to suicidal disclosures, emphasizing non-panic and presence (ref: 988 Lifeline counselor guidance).
- Audit communication protocols: Review 3-5 existing patient disclosure pathways to ensure they do not lead to invalidation or exaggerated responses for individuals expressing suicidal thoughts (ref: Ursula Whiteside's critique of ER/healthcare responses).
- Develop stigma-reduction campaign: Create 3-5 shareable assets (e.g., short videos, infographics) highlighting the strength of individuals living with suicidality (ref: "Hold The Hope" song's goal).
Key Quotes
"I've been an unpaid full time unpaid carer for loved ones in a suicidal crisis continuously for the last eight years and actually both my loved ones have survived and are thriving now eight years ago Joe first learned that someone she loves was feeling suicidal and as she started to learn how to care for them she made a promise to the universe if I survive this I will do something to change this so that people are not powerless watching a loved one suffer like this."
Rhitu Chatterjee highlights Joe Lambert's personal journey as a caregiver, emphasizing her commitment to transforming a deeply challenging personal experience into a catalyst for broader change. This quote demonstrates Lambert's motivation to prevent others from feeling powerless when supporting a loved one in suicidal crisis.
"The film also titled hold the hope uses this poem as narration and then this year Joe took it to the next level by turning that poem into a song hold the hope for me today on the show how suicide survivors and caregivers are turning their experiences into art and reimagining what suicide prevention work sounds like."
Rhitu Chatterjee explains how Joe Lambert evolved her initial poem into a film and then a song, illustrating a creative approach to suicide prevention. This quote shows how art can be a powerful medium for sharing experiences and reframing the conversation around mental health care.
"The song stresses the importance of emotional safety for the person in crisis keep safe this place for me hold my gaze don't look away meet my hurt head on don't leap back in alarm stay focused steady calm and this message is conveyed by various voices in this spoken word section of the song."
Rhitu Chatterjee points out the core message of Joe Lambert's song, emphasizing the need for emotional safety and steady presence for individuals experiencing suicidal thoughts. This quote demonstrates how the song's lyrics actively encourage caregivers to remain calm and attentive, rather than reacting with alarm.
"The other part of this has to do with the stigma around suicide which according to Joe stems from the fact that people feeling suicidal are often looked upon as weak but her song calls for others to see the strength in someone feeling suicidal by understanding what they've been through and that's the absolute kind of of this project which is the upending of the stigma can you turn stigma on its head and say my staying power instead."
Rhitu Chatterjee explains Joe Lambert's intention to challenge the stigma surrounding suicide by reframing it as a demonstration of strength. This quote highlights how Lambert's project aims to shift perception, encouraging people to recognize the resilience of those who live with suicidality.
"Research shows by the way that when we share experiences of those who live with suicidality it increases the likelihood that others in crisis will seek help that they too will have a sense of hope here's Ursula again when I was listening to this I was I kept coming back to the fact that there are so many times that people survive and what we only count is when they die."
Rhitu Chatterjee presents research findings that underscore the impact of sharing lived experiences with suicidality, suggesting it can encourage others to seek help and find hope. This quote, referencing Ursula Whiteside, points out the critical undercounting of suicide survivors compared to those who die by suicide.
Resources
External Resources
Videos & Documentaries
- "Hold The Hope" song - Mentioned as a creative work used for suicide prevention training and opening conversations about mental health care.
- "Hold The Hope" film - Discussed as an educational film about suicide prevention that uses the poem "Hold The Hope" as narration.
Articles & Papers
- "Why Suicide Prevention is 'Everyone's Business'" (Short Wave) - Episode title and context for the discussion.
- "How to Reach Out When Someone You Know May Be at Risk of Suicide" (NPR) - Referenced as a previous conversation about practical ways to help someone at risk of suicide.
- "Suicide Prevention Survival Song Film Art UK NHS" (NPR) - Article providing more reporting on "Hold the Hope."
People
- Jo Lambert - Creator of the poem "Hold The Hope," which was turned into a song and film for suicide prevention training.
- Rhitu Chatterjee - NPR health correspondent who covers mental health and discussed the song "Hold The Hope" and suicide prevention.
- Emily Kwong - Host of Short Wave, who shared personal experiences related to suicide prevention and discussed the song "Hold The Hope."
- Ursula Whiteside - Psychologist and founder of the suicide prevention nonprofit Now Matters Now, who provided insights on responding to suicidal crises and validation.
- Justine Trippa - Psychiatric nurse and boss of Jo Lambert, who stated that using the film "Hold The Hope" has made suicide prevention training sessions more engaging.
Organizations & Institutions
- UK's National Health Service Mental Health Trust - Uses the poem "Hold The Hope" as suicide prevention training material and is where Jo Lambert works.
- 988 National & Suicide Crisis Lifeline - Referenced as a resource for those struggling with suicidal thoughts and for caregivers seeking guidance on how to respond.
- Now Matters Now - Suicide prevention nonprofit run by psychologist Ursula Whiteside.
Other Resources
- "Hold The Hope" poem - Written by Jo Lambert, it is about what someone in suicidal crisis needs and serves as the basis for the song and film.
- 988 - The suicide prevention lifeline number.