Challenger Expedition Baseline Reveals Ocean Crises and Conservation Hope
TL;DR
- The HMS Challenger expedition provided a unique, foundational baseline of ocean conditions in the 1870s, enabling comparisons to today's crises like overfishing, ocean warming, and microplastic pollution.
- A biocentric storytelling approach, focusing on marine creatures as protagonists, reframes historical narratives and highlights current threats to ocean life, fostering a deeper connection and conservation imperative.
- The voyage's discoveries, including thousands of new species and detailed environmental data, challenged 19th-century assumptions about inexhaustible oceans and laid the groundwork for modern oceanography and evolutionary science.
- The recovery of green turtle populations demonstrates that targeted conservation efforts and protection of habitats can enable significant rebound of marine life, offering hope for broader ocean restoration.
- The deep sea, once perceived as a static museum of ancient life, is now understood to be geologically and biologically dynamic, meaning its current state is a product of recent changes, not ancient stasis.
- Microplastics have infiltrated the entire marine ecosystem, from the sea floor to the deepest trenches, representing a new frontier of scientific inquiry into their long-term impacts on marine life and human health.
Deep Dive
The HMS Challenger expedition of 1872-1876 established the first global baseline of oceanographic data, revealing a snapshot of marine life and conditions 150 years ago that has become critically important for understanding today's ocean crises. While the expedition was a monumental scientific achievement, its legacy is now being re-examined through a "biocentric" lens, focusing on the marine creatures themselves rather than solely on the human explorers. This shift is essential for fostering a deeper connection with the ocean and driving effective conservation efforts, as the stark contrast between the Challenger's findings and contemporary observations underscores the severity of human impact.
The Challenger's voyage was unprecedented in scope, transforming a warship into a floating laboratory that collected vast amounts of data on temperature, depth, and biology, discovering thousands of new species. This foundational work paved the way for modern oceanography and theories like plate tectonics, with the expedition even plumbing the Mariana Trench. However, author Gillen D'Arcy Wood argues that the true value of the Challenger's findings today lies in their ability to highlight the dramatic changes our oceans have undergone. By organizing his book around specific marine creatures, Wood emphasizes their evolutionary history and their precarious future, illustrating that the Victorian era's understanding of the oceans as inexhaustible is now demonstrably false. The expedition's detailed records of ocean conditions, such as temperature, provide a critical baseline for measuring the impact of climate change and human activity.
The current state of the oceans, as highlighted by the book, is dire, facing significant threats from overfishing, ocean warming, and plastic pollution. Overfishing has depleted large fish populations by as much as 90%, and deep-sea trawling devastates delicate ecosystems. Marine heatwaves, like the Pacific "blob," disrupt marine life and influence global weather patterns, while microplastics have infiltrated the entire marine food chain, from the deepest trenches to apex predators, with their long-term consequences still largely unknown. These issues are compounded by the fact that the deep sea, once thought to be an ancient and unchanging repository of life, is now understood to be geologically dynamic, with rapid turnover.
Despite the grim realities, the book offers a crucial message of hope, exemplified by the recovery of green sea turtles. Their story, from near extinction due to overexploitation to a significant rebound through dedicated conservation efforts and habitat protection, demonstrates the resilience of marine life when given a chance. This narrative underscores that saving the planet requires not just scientific understanding but also a profound re-enchantment with the natural world, fostering a more sympathetic and cooperative relationship with marine ecosystems. The Challenger's legacy, therefore, extends beyond its scientific data; it serves as a call to action to reconnect with and protect the living ocean that sustains us all.
Action Items
- Audit ocean data: Compare 1870s HMS Challenger findings with current conditions for 3 major threats (overfishing, warming, plastic pollution).
- Create biocentric narrative framework: Define 5 criteria for selecting marine creatures to highlight evolutionary history and modern threats.
- Measure species recovery: Track population trends for 2-3 species (e.g., green turtle) to assess conservation effectiveness over 5-10 years.
- Analyze historical oceanographic methods: Document 3-5 key data collection techniques from HMS Challenger for comparative study.
Key Quotes
"my goal in writing the book was to show that it's not a matter of historical curiosity only that in fact challenger has a fresh and urgent story to tell us and that is that it gives us this unique snapshot of the oceans as they were 150 years ago and we can compare what challenger saw in its three year voyage to how our oceans are today and there've been a great many changes that i talk about in the book"
Gillen D'Arcy Wood explains that the HMS Challenger expedition is not just a historical event but offers a vital comparison point for understanding current ocean conditions. Wood's goal was to highlight the urgent relevance of this historical data by contrasting the oceans of 150 years ago with their state today, emphasizing the significant changes that have occurred.
"the achievements of hms challenger are legendary they brought back in in bottles and crates 5 000 new marine creatures unknown to science they recorded temperature data at the sea surface and at depth all across the globe they measured deep sea currents they mapped the sea floor and really paved the way for the modern theories of plate tectonics and they plunged the mariana trench which is the deepest part of the world's oceans"
Wood details the monumental scientific contributions of the HMS Challenger expedition, underscoring its foundational role in oceanography. The expedition's discoveries, including thousands of new species and extensive data on ocean temperature, currents, and the seafloor, laid the groundwork for major scientific theories and explorations.
"i wanted to tell that story retell it but i wanted to shift the focus really to the marine life itself and to make as you say to make the marine creatures the stars of the show and have the scientists really just be a kind of vehicle for telling the stories of the amazing creatures that inhabit the deep sea"
Wood articulates his "biocentric" narrative approach, explaining that he chose to center the story on marine life rather than solely on the human explorers. This perspective elevates the creatures discovered by the Challenger expedition to the main characters, with the scientists serving as conduits to explore their stories and significance.
"the fact that they converted a royal navy warship and turned it into a floating marine science academy they appointed six scientists there was a crew of 250 men they sailed for three and a half years no expense was spared they had the latest cutting edge technology available to them and of course what they had was the most importantly was the infrastructure of the british empire"
Wood emphasizes the unprecedented scale and resources of the HMS Challenger expedition, highlighting its transformation into a dedicated floating laboratory. The combination of advanced technology, a large scientific and crew contingent, and the extensive support of the British Empire allowed for a comprehensive and unparalleled global oceanographic survey.
"the three main issues confronting the oceans today are overfishing ocean warming and also plastic pollution i'll take them each of the three of these one at a time and in a chapter that i write about the challenger's visit to japan and their encounter with the infant japanese salmon fishing industry i talk about how our seafood consumption over the 20th century has increased eight or tenfold not particularly since the second world war that 90 of larger fish in the higher levels of the food chain thinking salmon and tuna and cod have been depleted from the oceans"
Wood identifies overfishing, ocean warming, and plastic pollution as the primary threats facing contemporary oceans, drawing a connection to historical observations from the Challenger voyage. He points out the drastic depletion of large fish populations since the 20th century, illustrating the severe impact of modern fishing practices.
"the story of the green turtles shows us that there is a baseline resilience in ocean life and that all these creatures need is a chance is a kind of fighting chance to bounce back and it's an opportunity for us you know as the human community to cooperate and to create new bonds with these animals we so admire and have so relied on in the past and to help them flourish with us you know in the world rather than seeing our relationship to the world as sort of purely exploitative and consuming without thought"
Wood uses the recovery of green turtles as a hopeful example of ocean conservation, demonstrating the resilience of marine life. He argues that with protection and a shift from exploitation to cooperation, species can rebound, suggesting that a sustainable coexistence with ocean creatures is possible and essential for a better future.
Resources
External Resources
Books
- "The Wake of the HMS Challenger" by Gillan Darcy Wood - Mentioned as the subject of the podcast episode, detailing the HMS Challenger's voyage and its impact on oceanography and conservation.
- "Tambora: The Eruption That Changed the World" by Gillan Darcy Wood - Mentioned as a previous award-winning book by the author.
- "History of Early Antarctic Exploration: Land of Wondrous Cold" by Gillan Darcy Wood - Mentioned as a previous book by the author.
People
- Gillan Darcy Wood - Author of "The Wake of the HMS Challenger," interviewed about his book and the HMS Challenger expedition.
- James Cameron - Mentioned as having piloted a submersible to the Challenger Deep.
Organizations & Institutions
- HMS Challenger - A 19th-century royal navy warship that served as a floating laboratory for the first global oceanographic expedition.
- NASA - Mentioned for naming its second orbiter after the HMS Challenger.
- University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign - Institution where Gillan Darcy Wood is the Schafer Professor of Liberal Arts and Sciences.
- Novo Nordisk - Mentioned in relation to the availability of the "new wegovy pill."
Websites & Online Resources
- weightwatchers.com - Mentioned as a place to check qualification for the "new wegovy pill."
- mathsciencehistory.com - Mentioned as the website where listeners can find transcripts and links to Gillan Darcy Wood's book.
Other Resources
- Wegovy pill - Mentioned as a new pill available through Weight Watchers for GLP-1 results.
- Shifting Baseline Syndrome - Discussed as a concept related to the fading memory of past ocean conditions.
- Generational Amnesia - Discussed as a concept related to the fading memory of past ocean conditions.
- Biocentric narrative - Discussed as a storytelling approach focusing on marine life.
- Plate tectonics - Mentioned as a theory paved the way for by the HMS Challenger expedition.
- Anthropogenic oceans - Refers to oceans impacted by human activity.
- Darwinian evolution - Discussed in the context of the HMS Challenger's voyage and the search for missing links.
- Overfishing - Identified as a major threat to oceans.
- Ocean warming - Identified as a major threat to oceans.
- Plastic pollution - Identified as a major threat to oceans.
- Marine blob - A great heat blob in the Pacific Ocean affecting weather systems.
- Microplastics - Tiny plastic particles that enter the marine food chain.
- Challenger Deep - The deepest part of the Mariana Trench, discovered by HMS Challenger.
- Green turtles - Featured in the book's final chapter, highlighting their recovery due to conservation efforts.