Phase-Based Habit Formation Leverages Neurochemistry and Task Bracketing
TL;DR
- Habit formation varies significantly, taking 18 to 254 days per person, necessitating personalized approaches rather than a one-size-fits-all timeline.
- "Linchpin habits," which are enjoyable activities, facilitate the adoption of other, more challenging behaviors by positively influencing neurochemistry and motivation.
- Task bracketing, engaging neural circuits before and after a habit, creates a robust neural imprint that increases habit automaticity and context independence.
- Aligning habits with daily biological phases--action-oriented mornings (Phase 1) and calmer afternoons (Phase 2)--leverages neurochemical states to overcome limbic friction.
- Breaking bad habits involves immediately engaging in a positive replacement behavior after the unwanted action, rewiring neural circuits to link negative behaviors with positive outcomes.
- The 21-day habit program focuses on the habit of habit formation, aiming for 4-5 completions daily, allowing for natural integration rather than rigid adherence.
Deep Dive
The discussion begins by defining habits as learned behaviors of the nervous system, estimating that up to 70% of waking behavior is habitual. Learning, in this context, is explained as neuroplasticity, the process by which the nervous system changes through experience, forming new neural circuits and pathways. The source distinguishes between immediate goal-based habits, which aim for a specific outcome with each performance, and identity-based habits, which are linked to a larger self-concept or overarching theme.
The conversation then addresses the common notion that habits take 21 days to form. Citing a 2010 study by Lally et al., the source clarifies that habit formation can actually take anywhere from 18 to 254 days, depending on the individual and the specific habit. This variability is linked to individual differences in managing "limbic friction," a term coined to describe the strain of overcoming states of anxiousness or tiredness that hinder engagement in desired activities. Limbic friction is presented as a metric for how much activation energy is needed to engage in a behavior or break an unwanted one.
The concept of "linchpin habits" is introduced. These are enjoyable habits that, by their nature, make other, more difficult habits easier to perform. Examples include resistance training or running, which can positively influence alertness for work, sleep quality, hydration, and food choices. These linchpin habits act as catalysts, shifting the likelihood of performing other behaviors that are harder to access.
Habit strength is then explained as being determined by two criteria: context dependence and the degree of limbic friction required. Context dependence refers to the ability to perform a habit consistently across different environments and times. The ultimate goal of habit formation is described as achieving "automaticity," where neural circuits perform the habit automatically.
A tool for habit formation is presented, derived from a review article by Wood and Runger. This involves mentally reviewing the procedural steps of a habit once or twice. This mental exercise is said to activate the same neurons required for habit execution, thereby lowering the threshold for performing the habit when it is actually attempted.
The powerful tool of "task bracketing" is discussed, which involves the dorsolateral striatum in the basal ganglia. This brain area becomes active at the beginning and end of a habit, a process that underlies context dependence and habit strength. Task bracketing creates a neural imprint that signals a habit needs to happen at a particular time, making it reflexive. This process can be enhanced by orienting the nervous system toward habit execution, akin to a warm-up for exercise.
The source then critiques the idea that strict scheduling is the key to long-term habit formation. Instead, it emphasizes the importance of the brain and body's state rather than the specific time of day. A phase-based habit plan is proposed, dividing the 24-hour day into three phases: Phase 1 (0-8 hours after waking) characterized by elevated norepinephrine, epinephrine, and dopamine, making it ideal for challenging habits with high limbic friction. Phase 2 (9-15 hours after waking) involves tapering neuromodulators and rising serotonin, lending itself to more relaxed states and "mellower" habits like journaling or practicing music, requiring less limbic friction override. Phase 3 (16-24 hours after waking) is dedicated to low light, cooler temperatures, and minimal stress to support sleep, neuroplasticity, and habit consolidation.
The discussion revisits habit flexibility, noting that once a habit is well-established and context-independent, its timing can be varied without diminishing its strength. This context independence, achieved when information migrates to different brain areas beyond the hippocampus, signifies true habit formation.
The episode then shifts to breaking habits, proposing that the key lies in intervening immediately after a bad habit is executed. By engaging in a replacement behavior right after the unwanted habit, two effects are achieved: linking the bad habit to a good one and remapping the neural circuits associated with the bad habit. This replacement behavior should be positive and relatively easy to execute to avoid additional struggle.
A 21-day habit program is detailed as a structured approach to habit formation. This involves setting out to perform six new habits daily, with the expectation of completing four to five. This system builds the "habit of performing habits" and allows for flexibility, as not all suggested activities may be suitable for daily execution. After 21 days, the focus shifts to assessing which habits have become automatic, with the option to add more only after existing ones are reflexive. The program emphasizes not compensating for missed days by doing more the next day, thus avoiding habit slip compensation.
Finally, the source touches upon supplements and their role in sleep and habit consolidation, mentioning products like AG1's AGZ for sleep and Element for electrolyte balance, as well as various sleep-supporting compounds. The overall goal is to provide biological and psychological tools for establishing adaptive habits and dismantling unhealthy ones.
Action Items
- Create a "linchpin habit" inventory: List 3-5 enjoyable activities that make other desired behaviors easier to execute.
- Design a phase-based habit schedule: Assign 2-3 challenging habits to Phase 1 (0-8 hours post-waking) and 1-2 mellower habits to Phase 2 (9-15 hours post-waking).
- Implement a 21-day habit program: Select 4-5 habits to consistently perform daily, allowing for occasional misses without compensation.
- Draft a habit replacement plan: For 1-2 unwanted habits, identify a simple, positive replacement behavior to execute immediately after the unwanted behavior.
- Evaluate habit strength: For 3-5 established habits, assess context dependence and limbic friction to determine automaticity.
Key Quotes
"Habits are things that our nervous system learned but not always consciously sometimes we develop habits that we're not even aware of until they become a problem or maybe they serve us well who knows but the fact of the matter is that habits are a big part of who we are in fact it's estimated that up to 70 of our waking behavior is made up of habitual behavior so if habits are largely learned consciously or unconsciously we have to ask ourselves what is learning well learning is neuroplasticity neuroplasticity is simply the process by which our nervous system changes in response to experience but at the end of the day neuroplasticity is about forming new neural circuits new pathways by which certain habits are likely to occur and other ones are less likely to occur."
Andrew Huberman explains that habits are learned behaviors, often unconsciously, and constitute a significant portion of daily actions. He connects habit formation directly to neuroplasticity, which is the brain's ability to change and form new neural circuits based on experience. This highlights that habits are not static but are actively shaped by our nervous system.
"it turns out that there's excellent peer reviewed data on this there's a study published in 2010 first author lally l a l l y this study found that for the same habit to be formed it can take anywhere from 18 days to as many as 254 days for different individuals to form that habit so for those of you listening some of you might be thinking i can't believe it would take some people 254 days to get into that habit but as i said people are highly variable and if you can't form one habit easily it doesn't mean that you can't form other habits easily"
Andrew Huberman challenges the common notion that habits form in a fixed timeframe, citing a study that shows significant individual variability, ranging from 18 to 254 days. He emphasizes that this variability means some people may find habit formation easier than others, and this difference is not necessarily a reflection of their overall ability to form habits. This suggests that personalized approaches to habit formation are crucial.
"linchpin habits are certain habits that make a lot of other habits easier to execute now the sorts of linchpin habits that i'm referring to are always going to be things that you enjoy doing i'll just give you an example from my life i happen to like exercise not all forms of exercise but i happen to like resistance training and i happen to like running and for reasons that i'll get into a little bit later i place those activities typically early in the day because of the neurochemistry and the various types of hormones etcetera that are associated with performing those activities but i really place those activities under the umbrella of what i call linchpin habits why because those particular habits are easy to execute because i enjoy them but they also make a lot of other habits easier to execute things like being alert for work things like making sure that i get good sleep the night before things like hydration things like making sure that i eat the foods that are better for me than maybe some of the other foods that i would more reflexively reach to if i weren't doing that training"
Andrew Huberman introduces the concept of "linchpin habits," which are enjoyable activities that facilitate the adoption of other behaviors. He uses his own enjoyment of resistance training and running as an example, explaining that these habits not only are easy to perform due to personal preference but also positively influence other behaviors like alertness, sleep quality, and dietary choices. This highlights how foundational enjoyable habits can create a cascade of positive behavioral changes.
"procedural memory is holding in mind the specific sequence of things that need to happen in order for a particular outcome to occur let's say i want to get into the habit of making myself or someone else in my household a cup of espresso every morning i would actually think through each of those steps walk into the kitchen turn on the espresso machine draw the espresso walking through each of those steps from start to finish and it turns out just that simple mental exercise done once can shift people toward a much higher likelihood of performing that habit regularly not just the first time but as they continue out into the days and weeks that follow"
Andrew Huberman explains procedural memory as the internal sequence of actions required for a specific outcome. He suggests a tool for habit formation: mentally rehearsing the steps of a desired habit, such as making espresso. Huberman notes that this simple visualization exercise can significantly increase the likelihood of performing the habit consistently, demonstrating the power of mental rehearsal in solidifying new behaviors.
"task bracketing is what underlies whether or not a habit will be context dependent or not whether or not it will be strong and likely to recur even if we didn't get a good night's sleep the night before even if we're feeling distracted even if we are not feeling like doing something emotionally or if we are you know completely overwhelmed by other events if the neural circuits for task bracketing are deeply embedded in us meaning they are very robust around a particular habit well then it's likely that we're going to go out for that zone two cardio no matter what that we're going to brush our teeth no matter what"
Andrew Huberman describes task bracketing as a neural mechanism that determines a habit's context dependence and strength. He explains that when task bracketing is robustly embedded, the habit is more likely to be performed regardless of external factors like sleep quality or emotional state. Huberman uses examples like zone two cardio and brushing teeth to illustrate how strong task bracketing can lead to habitual behaviors occurring consistently, irrespective of circumstances.
"one of the challenges in breaking habits is that many habits occur very very quickly and so there isn't an opportunity to intervene until the habit has already been initiated and in some cases completed so it turns out that the key to generating long term depression in these pathways is actually to take the period immediately following the bad habit execution and in that moment capture the sequence of events not that led to the bad habit execution but actually to take advantage of the fact that the neurons that were responsible for generating that bad habit were active a moment ago and to actually engage in a replacement behavior immediately afterward"
Andrew Huberman addresses the difficulty of breaking habits due to their rapid execution. He proposes that the key to long-term habit change involves intervening immediately after a bad habit occurs. Huberman suggests leveraging the activated neural pathways from the recent bad habit by engaging in a replacement behavior right afterward, which helps to rewire the neural circuits associated with the undesirable behavior.
Resources
External Resources
Books
- "Psychology of Habit" by Wendy Wood and Dennis Runger - Referenced as a source for understanding habit formation mechanisms and procedural memory.
Articles & Papers
- Lally et al. (2010) - Cited for peer-reviewed data indicating habit formation can take 18 to 254 days for different individuals.
People
- Andrew Huberman - Host of the podcast, professor of neurobiology and ophthalmology at Stanford School of Medicine.
Other Resources
- Linchpin Habits - Habits that make other habits easier to execute, often enjoyable activities.
- Limbic Friction - A coined term describing the strain or activation energy required to overcome states of anxiousness or fatigue to engage in a particular activity.
- Neuroplasticity - The process by which the nervous system changes in response to experience, forming new neural circuits.
- Procedural Memory - Memory for performing specific sequences of actions required for a particular outcome.
- Task Bracketing - A neural mechanism involving the dorsolateral striatum that becomes active at the beginning and end of a habit, contributing to its context dependence and strength.
- Goal-Based Habits - Habits designed to bring a specific, immediate outcome with each repetition.
- Identity-Based Habits - Habits linked to a larger, overarching theme about oneself or what it means to be a certain type of person.
- Habit Strength - Measured by context dependence and the amount of limbic friction required to perform the habit.
- Automaticity - The state where neural circuits perform a habit automatically.
- Phase-Based Habit Plan - A program dividing the 24-hour day into three phases (0-8 hours, 9-15 hours, 16-24 hours after waking) to align habits with biological underpinnings.
- Replacement Behaviors - Engaging in a positive habit immediately following the execution of a bad habit to remap neural circuits.
- 21-Day Habit Program - A system involving setting out to perform six new habits per day for 21 days, with the expectation of completing four to five, focusing on the habit of performing habits.