Steelers' Ceiling Limited by Tomlin's Consistent Success - Episode Hero Image

Steelers' Ceiling Limited by Tomlin's Consistent Success

First Things First · · Listen to Original Episode →
Original Title:

TL;DR

  • Mike Tomlin's consistent success in avoiding losing seasons, while impressive, may have become an impediment to reaching a higher ceiling due to a lack of quarterback development and offensive coaching innovation.
  • The Steelers' strategy of prioritizing defense and patching together offenses with veteran quarterbacks, rather than drafting and developing a franchise signal-caller, has limited their postseason potential.
  • Mike Tomlin's departure creates an opportunity for the Steelers to reset, potentially bottoming out to acquire a top quarterback, despite the risk of a prolonged rebuilding phase and the departure of a stable, long-term coach.
  • The Eagles' offensive struggles this season, marked by stagnant playcalling and a significant drop in production, suggest that firing offensive coordinator Kevin Patullo may be a symptom of deeper issues with player personnel and offensive line health.
  • Aaron Rodgers' final playoff game, characterized by pressure and a pick-six, highlighted his historical weaknesses in handling intense pass rushes and emotional responses, potentially signaling the end of his career.
  • The Steelers' historical reliance on defensive-minded coaches and their lack of a clear quarterback succession plan present a challenging environment for any new head coach, potentially leading to a period of instability.
  • The Eagles' offensive coordinator carousel, with Jalen Hurts having ten coordinators in ten years, indicates a systemic issue with continuity and player buy-in, impacting offensive performance despite talented personnel.

Deep Dive

Mike Tomlin's departure from the Pittsburgh Steelers after 19 seasons marks the end of an era defined by remarkable consistency and a commitment to maintaining a winning culture, even if playoff success plateaued. While Tomlin's unprecedented streak of never having a losing season and achieving 193 wins, including a Super Bowl, cements his legacy as a Hall of Fame coach, the Steelers now face a critical juncture. The core argument is that while Tomlin excels at establishing a high floor--ensuring competitive seasons and strong team culture--this very success may have inadvertently limited the team's ceiling, particularly in developing quarterbacks and consistently advancing in the playoffs. This creates a tension for the Steelers: how to replace a coach who guarantees competitiveness with one who can elevate them to championship contention, especially in a division featuring strong quarterback play.

The implications of Tomlin's exit are multifaceted. For the Steelers, the immediate challenge is identifying a successor who can navigate the team's current roster dynamics, which include aging veterans and a lack of a clear franchise quarterback, a stark contrast to the stability they enjoyed with Ben Roethlisberger. The team's history of prioritizing defense and hiring defensive-minded coaches suggests a potential continuation of this philosophy, though the league's evolving offensive landscape and the success of teams with strong quarterback play might prompt a strategic shift. The risk for the Steelers is that a new coach might not replicate Tomlin's ability to maintain a winning record, potentially leading to a period of rebuilding that fans, accustomed to consistent competitiveness, may find difficult to accept. This also opens the door for the Steelers to potentially bottom out, acquiring draft capital for a future quarterback, a path that Tomlin's consistent winning may have previously precluded.

For Mike Tomlin, the second-order implications suggest a strategic career move. His departure, rather than a firing, allows him to control his next steps, with television and consulting roles being immediate possibilities, offering financial rewards and a less demanding schedule. However, the allure of coaching, especially with a team that has a stable quarterback situation, remains strong. The potential for him to join a division rival like the Baltimore Ravens, should circumstances align, highlights the complex coaching carousel in the AFC North. This move signifies a potential shift in coaching philosophy across the league, where the emphasis might move from maintaining a high floor to actively pursuing championship ceilings, potentially through aggressive quarterback acquisition and offensive innovation. The Steelers' decision to move on, despite Tomlin's consistent success, underscores the NFL's relentless pursuit of ultimate victory and the recognition that even sustained competitiveness may not be enough to satisfy championship aspirations.

Action Items

  • Audit Steelers' offensive coordinator turnover: Analyze 5 past OCs (Smith, Canada, Haley, Fichtner) for common strategic or personnel issues contributing to stagnation.
  • Evaluate Steelers' quarterback development strategy: Review draft and free agent acquisitions over the last 10 years to identify patterns of prioritizing veteran stopgaps over long-term development.
  • Create a framework for assessing coach-quarterback synergy: Define metrics for evaluating how well offensive schemes and play-calling align with a quarterback's strengths and weaknesses.
  • Draft a succession plan for offensive leadership: Outline criteria for selecting future offensive coordinators and quarterbacks, emphasizing player development and scheme continuity.

Related Episodes

Key Quotes

"Mike Tomlin is stepping down from the Steelers. With Venmo Stash, a taco in one hand and ordering a ride in the other means you're stacking cash back. Nice. Get up to 5% cash back with Venmo Stash on your favorite brands when you pay with your Venmo debit card. From takeout to rideshares, entertainment and more, pick up a bundle with your go-tos and start earning cash back at those brands. Earn more cash when you do more with Stash. Venmo Stash terms and exclusions apply. Max $100 cash back per month. See terms at venmo.me/stashtterms."

This quote, presented as an advertisement within the podcast transcript, highlights the promotional content that often accompanies such discussions. It demonstrates how unrelated commercial messages are integrated into the audio stream, serving as a brief interlude between segments. The ad's focus on earning cash back through everyday purchases illustrates a common marketing strategy aimed at engaging listeners with practical benefits.

"Mike Tomlin is stepping down from the Steelers. 19 years, never had a losing season, 13 trips to the playoffs, one Super Bowl 43, the sixth in the Steelers franchise. Also, most recently, seven straight playoff games with a loss. His last win coming in January of 2017. Your reaction to the change in Pittsburgh?"

This quote marks the official announcement of Mike Tomlin's departure from the Pittsburgh Steelers, setting the stage for the subsequent discussion. The speaker meticulously lists Tomlin's significant achievements, including his remarkable streak of non-losing seasons and playoff appearances, while also acknowledging the recent playoff struggles. This provides a balanced overview of his tenure, prompting an immediate reaction from the panel.

"So, I think ultimately the Steelers and Mike Tomlin could be better off apart. Could just be time for a change. And I think the thing that I've struggled with with Tomlin for years now is I see a little bit of a disconnect between how I see him and how the football media and fans at large seems to, which is like, let's get the obvious things out of the way. It's wildly impressive to have 19 years without a losing season. That is obviously impressive. 200 wins, a Super Bowl championship, incredible. If we were doing that in ratings of coaching attributes like leadership and culture, he might be the best. Yeah. And he read Dan Campbell. Like, he might actually, he might be 100 out of 100, the best you could possibly be as a football coach."

This quote introduces a nuanced perspective on Mike Tomlin's coaching career, suggesting that a separation might be mutually beneficial. The speaker acknowledges Tomlin's exceptional leadership and cultural impact, even comparing him favorably to other highly regarded coaches. However, this is immediately followed by a contemplation of the "disconnect" between this perception and the team's ultimate success, setting up a deeper analysis of his coaching philosophy and its limitations.

"What I've struggled with it is how valuable is high floor? Like, how valuable is it if your skills as a coach do also not align with developing quarterbacks or coaches? He has no coaches on his coaching tree. Not a one. No Mike Tomlin assistant has gone on to be an NFL head coach. He keeps turning over offensive coordinator. Arthur Smith, Matt Canada, Randy Fichtner, Todd Haley. He inherited Ben Roethlisberger, so he doesn't really, he's, he won with him, but he wasn't his guy. But he's so good at the leadership culture stuff that you're always going to win eight, nine, 10, 11 games. But then that puts you in a position where you're too good to draft a quarterback at the top. But then you're a defensive coach, and your defense falls apart in these playoff games where you are the first coach in NFL history to have five straight playoff losses by double digits. Like, what's the value in winning 10 games, getting boat-raced in the playoffs, and never developing an offensive coach or quarterback?"

This quote delves into the core of the speaker's critique of Mike Tomlin's coaching tenure, questioning the value of a consistently high "floor" when it doesn't translate to developing key personnel or achieving ultimate success. The speaker highlights the lack of a coaching tree and the failure to develop quarterbacks as significant drawbacks. They also point to the pattern of playoff losses and the inability to consistently develop offensive talent as reasons for concern, despite the team's regular-season success.

"I would argue, though, that the low ceiling is quarterback related, but he's the, he's the head coach. Like, he's not the GM, and I get, I know he has a lot of say, obviously, with his stature in the organization, but when he had a top-flight quarterback, he got to two Super Bowls and won one. And I know the after that, you know, they didn't always make the Super Bowl, obviously, with Ben Roethlisberger, but I'm saying we can't say he has a low ceiling because he's, when he had a guy, I don't, there is nobody when, when your quarterback is not elite, who is consistently like competing for the Super Bowl. I think Kyle Shanahan is the only one."

This quote offers a counterargument, attributing the perceived "low ceiling" to the quarterback situation rather than Tomlin's coaching ability. The speaker emphasizes that with a top-tier quarterback like Ben Roethlisberger, Tomlin achieved significant success, including a Super Bowl win. They contend that consistently competing for a Super Bowl without an elite quarterback is exceptionally rare, citing Kyle Shanahan as one of the few exceptions, thus defending Tomlin's performance under less-than-ideal circumstances.

"Rough night for Aaron Rodgers. First time he hasn't led his team to a touchdown in the playoffs. 146 yards on the night was a fewest in his playoff career. Passer rating 51, career worst for the playoffs. Here he is after the game. I'm not going to make any emotional decisions. Disappointed, you know, obviously, and such a fun year, you know, a lot of adversity, but a lot of, a lot of fun. Been a great year, you know, overall in my life. And the last, you know, last year, and this is, you know, a really good part of that coming here and being a part of this team. So, it's disappointing to be sitting here with the season over."

This quote captures Aaron Rodgers' post-game reaction following a particularly poor playoff performance. It highlights his statistically worst playoff game, marked by a lack of offensive touchdowns and a career-low passer rating. Rodgers' own words express disappointment but also reflect on the overall positive experience of his season, suggesting a potential decision about his future in the league.

"One of the best quarterbacks to ever do it. Like, and it's, it'

Resources

External Resources

Books

  • "The Standard Is the Standard" by Mike Tomlin - Mentioned as a philosophy that guided the Pittsburgh Steelers organization.

People

  • Mike Tomlin - Stepped down as head coach of the Pittsburgh Steelers after 19 seasons.
  • Aaron Rodgers - Mentioned in relation to his performance in a playoff game and speculation about his retirement.
  • C.J. Stroud - Mentioned in relation to his performance in a playoff game and his potential.
  • Drake Maye - Mentioned in relation to his performance in a playoff game and his potential.
  • Matthew Stafford - Mentioned in relation to his performance in a playoff game and his potential MVP status.
  • Joe Burrow - Mentioned in relation to his status as a top quarterback in the AFC North and his potential impact on coaching decisions.
  • Lamar Jackson - Mentioned in relation to his potential interest in playing for Mike Tomlin and his involvement in Ravens' head coaching interviews.
  • Bill Belichick - Mentioned in relation to his tenure with the Patriots and his departure.
  • Sean Payton - Mentioned in relation to his coaching approach and impact on the Broncos.
  • Dan Campbell - Mentioned as an example of a coach who achieved success with a lower-ceiling team.
  • Philip Rivers - Mentioned in relation to his return to play at an older age, suggesting the possibility of other quarterbacks returning.
  • Jalen Hurts - Mentioned in relation to his performance and the Eagles' offensive struggles.
  • AJ Brown - Mentioned in relation to potential roster changes for the Eagles.
  • T.J. Watt - Mentioned in relation to the Steelers' potential roster changes.
  • Minka Fitzpatrick - Mentioned in relation to a trade made by the Steelers.
  • Derrick Henry - Mentioned in relation to the Steelers' decision to acquire him.
  • Jackson Dart - Mentioned as a potential quarterback prospect for the Steelers.
  • Tyler Shuck - Mentioned as a potential quarterback prospect for the Steelers.
  • Russell Wilson - Mentioned in relation to his time with the Steelers and his potential future.
  • Justin Fields - Mentioned in relation to his time with the Steelers and his potential future.
  • Kenny Pickett - Mentioned in relation to his time with the Steelers.
  • Mason Rudolph - Mentioned in relation to his time with the Steelers.
  • Sam Darnold - Mentioned in relation to potential quarterback options for the Steelers.
  • Baker Mayfield - Mentioned in relation to potential quarterback options for the Steelers.
  • Daniel Jones - Mentioned in relation to potential quarterback options for the Steelers.
  • Jordan Love - Mentioned in relation to his draft position and potential.
  • Jalen Hurts - Mentioned in relation to his performance and the Eagles' offensive struggles.
  • Carson Wentz - Mentioned in relation to his time with the Eagles.
  • Brock Purdy - Mentioned in relation to his performance in a playoff game.
  • Bo Nix - Mentioned in relation to his performance and potential.
  • Caleb Williams - Mentioned in relation to his performance and potential.
  • Trevor Lawrence - Mentioned in relation to his performance and potential.
  • Bryce Young - Mentioned in relation to his performance and potential.
  • Devante Adams - Mentioned in relation to his performance and potential.
  • DK Metcalf - Mentioned in relation to his performance and potential.
  • Christian McCaffrey - Mentioned in relation to his performance.
  • Lane Johnson - Mentioned in relation to the Eagles' offensive line.
  • Cam Jurgens - Mentioned in relation to the Eagles' offensive line.
  • Landon Dickerson - Mentioned in relation to the Eagles' offensive line.
  • Saquon Barkley - Mentioned in relation to the Eagles' offense.
  • Zach Wilson - Mentioned in relation to his potential future.
  • Mike Vrabel - Mentioned in relation to his coaching potential.
  • Robert Saleh - Mentioned in relation to his coaching potential.
  • Brian Flores - Mentioned in relation to his coaching potential.
  • John Harbaugh - Mentioned in relation to his departure from the Ravens and potential future.
  • Chuck Noll - Mentioned as a former Steelers head coach.
  • Bill Cowher - Mentioned as a former Steelers head coach.
  • Art Rooney - Mentioned in relation to his statement about Mike Tomlin.
  • Omar Khan - Mentioned in relation to the Steelers' front office.
  • Willie Colon - Former Steelers player who played under Mike Tomlin.
  • Greg Jennings - Former NFL player.
  • Dave Portnoy - Mentioned in relation to a take of the month.
  • Big Cat - Mentioned in relation to a take of the month.
  • Fernando Mendoza - Mentioned as a potential addition to a quarterback ranking.
  • Deontay Wilder - Mentioned as an analogy for a player's potential.
  • Dirk Nowitzki - Mentioned in relation to a comparison with Matthew Stafford.
  • Shaquille O'Neal - Mentioned in relation to a comparison with Aaron Rodgers.
  • Steve Young - Mentioned in relation to his mobility as a quarterback.
  • Peyton Manning - Mentioned in relation to his MVP awards and career achievements.
  • Brett Favre - Mentioned in relation to his playing style.
  • Terry Bradshaw - Mentioned as a former Steelers quarterback.
  • Patrick Mahomes - Mentioned in relation to his status as a top quarterback.
  • Josh Allen - Mentioned in relation to his status as a top quarterback.
  • Kyle Shanahan - Mentioned as an example of a coach who can maintain success with injuries.
  • Zac Taylor - Mentioned in relation to the Bengals' head coach.
  • Sean McDermott - Mentioned in relation to the Bills' head coach.
  • Mike McDaniel - Mentioned in relation to his coaching style.
  • Matt Rhule - Mentioned in relation to his coaching.
  • Clint Kubiak - Mentioned as a potential head coaching candidate.
  • Kevin Stefanski - Mentioned in relation to his coaching.
  • Jim Harbaugh - Mentioned in relation to his coaching.
  • Jerry Jones - Mentioned in relation to the Dallas Cowboys.
  • Howie Roseman - Mentioned in relation to the Eagles' front office.
  • Nick Sirianni - Mentioned in relation to the Eagles' head coach.
  • Arthur Smith - Mentioned as a former Eagles offensive coordinator.
  • Matt Canada - Mentioned as a former Eagles offensive coordinator.
  • Randy Fickner - Mentioned as a former Eagles offensive coordinator.
  • Todd Haley - Mentioned as a former Eagles offensive coordinator.
  • Ben Johnson - Mentioned in relation to offensive coordinator potential.
  • Derrick Henry - Mentioned in relation to the Steelers' acquisition.
  • Jalen Ramsey - Mentioned in relation to the Steelers' potential roster changes.
  • Leonord Williams - Mentioned in relation to the Seahawks' defense.
  • JSN - Mentioned in relation to the Seahawks' offense.
  • George Kittle - Mentioned in relation to the 49ers' injuries.
  • Davis Mills - Mentioned in relation to the Texans' quarterback situation.
  • Bryce Young - Mentioned in relation to his performance.
  • Puka Nacua - Mentioned in relation to his performance.
  • Devante Parker - Mentioned in relation to his performance.
  • Jalen Ramsey - Mentioned in relation to the Steelers' potential roster changes.
  • TJ Watt - Mentioned in relation to the Steelers' potential roster changes.
  • Derrick Henry - Mentioned in relation to the Steelers' acquisition.
  • Jackson Dart - Mentioned as a potential quarterback prospect for the Steelers.
  • Tyler Shuck - Mentioned as a potential quarterback prospect for the Steelers.
  • Russell Wilson - Mentioned in relation to his time with the Steelers and his potential future.
  • Justin Fields - Mentioned in relation to his time with the Steelers and his potential future.
  • Kenny Pickett - Mentioned in relation to his time with the Steelers.
  • Mason Rudolph - Mentioned in relation to his time with the Steelers.
  • Sam Darnold - Mentioned in relation to potential quarterback options for the Steelers.
  • Baker Mayfield - Mentioned in relation to potential quarterback options for the Steelers.
  • Daniel Jones - Mentioned in relation to potential quarterback options for the Steelers.
  • Jordan Love - Mentioned in relation to his draft position and potential.
  • Jalen Hurts - Mentioned in relation to his performance and the Eagles' offensive struggles.
  • AJ Brown - Mentioned in relation to potential roster changes for the Eagles.
  • Lane Johnson - Mentioned in relation to the Eagles' offensive line.
  • Cam Jurgens - Mentioned in relation to the Eagles' offensive line.
  • Landon Dickerson - Mentioned in relation to the Eagles' offensive line.
  • Saquon Barkley - Mentioned in relation to the Eagles' offense.
  • Zach Wilson - Mentioned in relation to his potential future.
  • Mike Vrabel - Mentioned in relation to his coaching potential.
  • Robert Saleh - Mentioned in relation to his coaching potential.
  • Brian Flores - Mentioned in relation to his coaching potential.
  • John Harbaugh - Mentioned in relation to his departure from the Ravens and potential future.
  • Chuck Noll - Mentioned as a former Steelers head coach.
  • Bill Cowher - Mentioned as a former Steelers head coach.
  • Art Rooney - Mentioned in relation to his statement about Mike Tomlin.
  • Omar Khan - Mentioned in relation to the Steelers' front office.
  • Willie Colon - Former Steelers player who played under Mike Tomlin.
  • Greg Jennings - Former NFL player.
  • Dave Portnoy - Mentioned in relation to a take of the month.
  • Big Cat - Mentioned in relation to a take of the month.
  • Fernando Mendoza - Mentioned as a potential addition to a quarterback ranking.
  • Deontay Wilder - Mentioned as an analogy for a player's potential.
  • Dirk Nowitzki - Mentioned in relation to a comparison with Matthew Stafford.
  • Shaquille O'Neal - Mentioned in relation to a comparison with Aaron Rodgers.
  • Steve Young - Mentioned in relation to his mobility as a quarterback.
  • Peyton Manning - Mentioned in relation to his MVP awards and career achievements.
  • Brett Favre - Mentioned in relation to his playing style.
  • Terry Bradshaw - Mentioned as a former Steelers quarterback.
  • Patrick Mahomes - Mentioned in relation to his status as a top quarterback.
  • Josh Allen - Mentioned in relation to

---
Handpicked links, AI-assisted summaries. Human judgment, machine efficiency.
This content is a personally curated review and synopsis derived from the original podcast episode.