Eagles' Coaching Deficiencies Undermine Talented Roster - Episode Hero Image

Eagles' Coaching Deficiencies Undermine Talented Roster

The Herd with Colin Cowherd · · Listen to Original Episode →
Original Title:

TL;DR

  • Nick Sirianni's coaching ineffectiveness is highlighted by his inability to secure an offensive coordinator role, suggesting his success was due to organizational support rather than his own strategic acumen.
  • Jalen Hurts' reluctance to utilize his dual-threat abilities limits his potential, indicating a strategic deficiency that prevents him from maximizing his talent and overcoming team weaknesses.
  • The 49ers' resilience despite significant injuries underscores the impact of team character and innovative coaching, contrasting sharply with the Eagles' perceived lack of coaching and offensive creativity.
  • Justin Herbert's repeated playoff struggles, marked by a 0-3 record, raise questions about his ability to perform under pressure and elevate his team in critical games.
  • Matt Ryan's transition to a front-office role demonstrates a willingness to embrace the demanding "grind" of football operations, suggesting a deep addiction to the sport's intensity beyond game days.
  • The Eagles' offensive struggles, evidenced by low second-half scoring and a lack of creativity, suggest a fundamental coaching issue that overshadows their talented roster.

Deep Dive

The NFL Wild Card Weekend revealed critical coaching and quarterbacking deficiencies, particularly highlighted by the Philadelphia Eagles' decisive loss to the San Francisco 49ers. This outcome suggests that the Eagles' recent success, including two Super Bowl appearances, was more a product of fortunate circumstances and strong organizational talent than effective head coaching by Nick Sirianni, raising serious questions about his future and the team's offensive strategy.

The Eagles' offensive struggles, especially in the second half of games, point to a fundamental lack of creativity and an over-reliance on passing, even when running the ball proves more effective. Jalen Hurts, despite his dual-threat capabilities, appears hesitant to utilize his running ability, a stark contrast to quarterbacks like Josh Allen who consistently leverage their athleticism. This tactical inflexibility, combined with a perceived disconnect with key players like A.J. Brown, suggests Sirianni's coaching staff is ill-equipped to adapt and maximize their roster's potential. The implication is that the Eagles' significant investment in talent is being squandered by coaching that fails to translate that talent into consistent playoff success, potentially necessitating a significant overhaul.

Furthermore, the analysis of other playoff games underscores the importance of adaptable and innovative coaching. Josh Allen's heroic performance against the Jaguars demonstrated a quarterback willing to do "whatever it takes," a trait seemingly lacking in other playoff contenders. Conversely, Justin Herbert's continued struggles in the playoffs, marked by a 0-3 record and uninspired play, indicate that even elite physical talent requires effective coaching to succeed on the biggest stage. The narrative around Herbert suggests that while he possesses the physical gifts, his current coaching situation and strategic approach are preventing him from reaching his full potential, making him a focal point of criticism until he can secure a playoff victory.

The podcast also touches on the career transition of Matt Ryan into a front-office role with the Falcons. While Ryan amassed significant wealth as a player, his decision to return to the demanding environment of football operations suggests an addiction to the "grind" and "juice" of the game, a common trait among successful athletes. His potential success as a GM, leveraging his intelligence and network, could signal a new archetype for athlete transitions, moving beyond broadcasting and into leadership roles, though the inherent pressures of such positions remain a significant factor.

Ultimately, the weekend's games served as a stark reminder that coaching innovation and quarterback adaptability are paramount in the NFL playoffs. Teams that fail to evolve their strategies and fully utilize their talent, like the Eagles, face rapid elimination, while those with dynamic coaching and versatile quarterbacks, like the Bills, advance. The financial capacity of owners to make coaching changes further intensifies this dynamic, creating a league where only the most strategically adept and adaptable organizations can consistently contend.

Action Items

  • Audit Eagles' offensive play-calling: Analyze 5 recent games for creativity and adaptability to identify systemic coaching weaknesses.
  • Evaluate Jalen Hurts' dual-threat utilization: Measure QB run play frequency against passing plays across 10 games to assess strategic alignment.
  • Track 49ers' player resilience metrics: Monitor injury impact on team performance over 5 games to quantify character and coaching effectiveness.
  • Analyze Justin Herbert's playoff decision-making: Review 3 playoff games for critical errors and compare to elite QB performance benchmarks.
  • Measure Josh Allen's game-defining plays: Quantify impact of Allen's individual efforts on 5 key drives to assess player-coach synergy.

Related Episodes

Key Quotes

"If I ask you or anyone, they don't even need to work in the NFL, just a football fan, if Nick Sirianni was fired on Monday, would he get another coaching job this season? And when I say coaching job, would anyone hire him to be their head coach? Since none of you are here, I will answer that question for you. The answer is no."

John Middlekauff questions Nick Sirianni's coaching value by posing a hypothetical firing scenario. Middlekauff suggests that Sirianni would not be hired as a head coach, and critically, would not even be considered for an offensive coordinator position, implying a lack of fundamental coaching ability beyond his current role.

"I'd argue he hit the lottery. He got Howie Roseman as a general manager. He got an owner that's willing to spend unlimited amounts of money, not just on his own roster. They obviously have been well-renowned now for front-loading contracts and being able to pay guys more cash upfront and how they can manipulate the books."

John Middlekauff attributes the Eagles' success to external factors rather than Nick Sirianni's coaching. Middlekauff argues that Sirianni benefited from a strong general manager and an owner willing to invest heavily in the team, suggesting that the team's achievements were a result of favorable circumstances and financial commitment.

"And the crazy part is Nick Sirianni's been to two of the last three Super Bowls. But I think if we're all being honest, how much did he really have to do with that? He leads some team meetings, he's good with personalities, but it feels like he does nothing in the game."

John Middlekauff expresses skepticism about Nick Sirianni's actual contribution to the Eagles' Super Bowl appearances. Middlekauff suggests that Sirianni's role is limited to team meetings and managing personalities, implying that his impact on the actual game strategy and execution is minimal.

"And yet, when you watch the Eagles, they're the complete opposite. Jalen's like, 'I just want to pass, I don't want to run,' and clearly doesn't because you would call more quarterback runs. I'm watching Josh Allen, I'm watching the two quarterback Sunday night, 'I'll do it, you need me to take off, I'll take off.' That is not the way Jalen plays anymore."

John Middlekauff contrasts Jalen Hurts' playing style with that of other dual-threat quarterbacks like Josh Allen. Middlekauff criticizes Hurts for seemingly avoiding running plays, which he believes is a key strength, and highlights Allen's willingness to use his legs as a more effective approach for a dual-threat player.

"But what it mattered the most for a game-winning drive, it didn't matter what the play call was or what was needed, they just did whatever they had to do. Do you need me to run it? Do you need me to pass it? Do you need my Pro Bowl fullback to make crazy catches? Do you need Christian McCaffrey to make a catch? And that's what happened, and that's why the 49ers drove down the field."

John Middlekauff praises the 49ers' adaptability and determination during a crucial game-winning drive. Middlekauff emphasizes that the team executed whatever was necessary, whether running, passing, or utilizing key players like their fullback and Christian McCaffrey, to achieve their objective.

"But like, Drake May outplayed him, not that he played great. I'm not comparing Drake May to Josh Allen on Sunday, but he definitely outplayed Justin Herbert. And Drake May's played one real year of football because I definitely don't count last year. And his college careers at North Carolina, did he ever play in a big game in college? Not trying to shit on the ACC here, but definitely that program's not like they're playing, you know, Alabama and LSU in the playoffs."

John Middlekauff argues that Drake May performed better than Justin Herbert in their playoff game, despite May's limited experience. Middlekauff suggests that May's college career at North Carolina did not prepare him for high-stakes games, yet he still managed to outperform Herbert, who has more experience.

Resources

External Resources

Books

  • "The Shanahan Tree" by Mike Silver - Mentioned in relation to the coaching tree of Kyle Shanahan.

Articles & Papers

  • "32 page essay" - Mentioned as an essay written by Mike McDaniel and Kyle Shanahan to help them leave the Cleveland Browns.

People

  • Mike McDaniel - Mentioned as a coach who was fired and is interviewing for head coaching jobs.
  • Kevin Stefanski - Mentioned as a coach who was fired and is interviewing for head coaching jobs.
  • Kyle Shanahan - Mentioned as a head coach who gave props to his linebackers after a win and as part of the "Shanahan Tree."
  • Nick Sirianni - Mentioned as a coach whose job security is in question after a loss.
  • Jeff Bezos - Mentioned as an example of someone who created a business from scratch.
  • Elon Musk - Mentioned as someone who has created multiple companies.
  • Sam Walton - Mentioned as someone who created Walmart from scratch.
  • Howie Roseman - Mentioned as the General Manager of the Eagles and as someone who taught the importance of "football smarts."
  • Jeffrey Lurie - Mentioned as the owner of the Eagles.
  • Vic Fangio - Mentioned as a potential defensive coordinator.
  • Brock Purdy - Mentioned as the quarterback for the 49ers who threw interceptions and had a significant run.
  • DeMarcus Robinson - Mentioned as a player who caught a pass from Brock Purdy.
  • George Kittle - Mentioned as a tight end for the 49ers and as the "heart and soul" of the team.
  • Fred Warner - Mentioned as a player for the 49ers.
  • Nick Bosa - Mentioned as a player for the 49ers.
  • AJ Brown - Mentioned as a talented wide receiver for the Eagles.
  • DeVonta Smith - Mentioned as a wide receiver for the Eagles.
  • Saquon Barkley - Mentioned as a running back.
  • Dallas Goedert - Mentioned as a tight end for the Eagles.
  • Jalen Hurts - Mentioned as the quarterback for the Eagles, a dual-threat player, and compared to Russell Wilson.
  • Lamar Jackson - Mentioned as an MVP caliber quarterback for the Ravens.
  • Russell Wilson - Mentioned as a comparison for Jalen Hurts.
  • Lincoln Riley - Mentioned as a coach at Oklahoma.
  • Baker Mayfield - Mentioned as a former Oklahoma quarterback.
  • Kyler Murray - Mentioned as a former Oklahoma quarterback.
  • Frank Gore - Mentioned as a comparison for Jalen Hurts' running style.
  • Robert Salah - Mentioned as a coach.
  • John Harbaugh - Mentioned as a potential head coach for the Eagles and as someone who worked for Jim Harbaugh.
  • Todd Monken - Mentioned as a former offensive coordinator who worked with Lamar Jackson.
  • Jimmy Garoppolo - Mentioned as a former quarterback for the 49ers.
  • Patrick Mahomes - Mentioned as a quarterback for the Kansas City Chiefs.
  • Josh Allen - Mentioned as a quarterback for the Bills, compared to Michael Jordan and a "one man wrecking crew."
  • Deebo Samuel - Mentioned as a wide receiver for the 49ers who was a high school quarterback recruit.
  • Joe Burrow - Mentioned as a quarterback recruit.
  • Sam Darnold - Mentioned as a quarterback recruit.
  • Deshaun Jackson - Mentioned in relation to a past conflict with Jeff Tedford.
  • Jeff Tedford - Mentioned in relation to a past conflict with Deshaun Jackson.
  • Tony - Mentioned as a freshman wide receiver from Miami.
  • Jason Kidd - Mentioned as a former basketball player at Cal.
  • Albert Einstein - Mentioned as a comparison for basketball IQ.
  • Howie Roseman - Mentioned as a coach who taught about "football smarts."
  • Robert Saleh - Mentioned as a coach.
  • Vic Fangio - Mentioned as a defensive coordinator.
  • John Harbaugh - Mentioned as a potential head coach for the Eagles.
  • Todd Monken - Mentioned as a potential offensive coordinator.
  • Jimmy Garoppolo - Mentioned as a former 49ers quarterback.
  • Brock Purdy - Mentioned as the current 49ers quarterback.
  • Patrick Mahomes - Mentioned as a quarterback.
  • Josh Allen - Mentioned as a quarterback.
  • Trevor Lawrence - Mentioned as a quarterback for the Jaguars.
  • Jordan Love - Mentioned as a quarterback.
  • Aiden Hutchinson - Mentioned as a player who spoke about playing Aaron Rodgers.
  • Aaron Rodgers - Mentioned as a quarterback for the Jets.
  • Danielle Hunter - Mentioned as a player for the Texans.
  • Will Anderson - Mentioned as a player for the Texans.
  • DK - Mentioned as a player.
  • Darnell Washington - Mentioned as a player with a broken arm.
  • John Harbaugh - Mentioned as a coach.
  • Jalen Warren - Mentioned as a player for the Steelers.
  • Walter Payton - Mentioned as a comparison for Jalen Warren's running style.
  • Earl Campbell - Mentioned as a comparison for Jalen Warren's running style.
  • Mike Tomlin - Mentioned as a coach.
  • Raheem Morris - Mentioned as a coach who was not retained.
  • Andy Reid - Mentioned as a coach who is safe.
  • Sean McVay - Mentioned as a coach who is safe.
  • Kyle Shanahan - Mentioned as a coach who is safe.
  • Matt Ryan - Mentioned as a former quarterback who is taking a job in Atlanta.
  • Arthur Blank - Mentioned as the owner of the Falcons.
  • John Lynch - Mentioned as a former player and current GM.
  • Dan Marino - Mentioned as a former quarterback.
  • Magic Johnson - Mentioned as a former basketball player.
  • Lane Kiffin - Mentioned as a coach.
  • Pete Golding - Mentioned as a coach.
  • Ryan Day - Mentioned as a coach.
  • LaFleur - Mentioned as a coach.
  • Green Bay - Mentioned as a team.
  • Kyle Shanahan - Mentioned as a coach.
  • Mike Tomlin - Mentioned as a coach.
  • John Harbaugh - Mentioned as a coach.
  • Raheem Morris - Mentioned as a coach.
  • Andy Reid - Mentioned as a coach.
  • Sean McVay - Mentioned as a coach.
  • Kyle Shanahan - Mentioned as a coach.
  • Matt Ryan - Mentioned as a former quarterback.
  • Mike Delaroccha - Host of Sacred Lessons.
  • Dr. Priyanka Wally - Host of Health Stuff.
  • Hari Kondabolu - Host of Health Stuff.
  • Michelle Williams - Host of Checking In.
  • Dr. Laurie Santos - Host of The Happiness Lab.
  • Katie Couric - Host of Next Question.

Organizations & Institutions

  • Apple Card - Mentioned as a sponsor.
  • Goldman Sachs Bank USA - Mentioned as the issuer of Apple Card.
  • McDonald's - Mentioned for their value meals.
  • Granger - Mentioned for industrial-grade products and delivery.
  • Netflix - Mentioned as a platform for the "Three and Out" podcast.
  • Cleveland Browns - Mentioned in relation to Mike McDaniel and Kyle Shanahan.
  • Atlanta Falcons - Mentioned as the team Matt Ryan is joining.
  • Miami Dolphins - Mentioned in relation to Mike McDaniel.
  • New England Patriots - Mentioned as a team.
  • Kansas City Chiefs - Mentioned as a team.
  • Baltimore Ravens - Mentioned as a team.
  • Jacksonville Jaguars - Mentioned as a team.
  • Chicago Bears - Mentioned as a team.
  • Houston Texans - Mentioned as a team.
  • Pittsburgh Steelers - Mentioned as a team.
  • Tennessee - Mentioned as a college football program.
  • University of Oregon - Mentioned as a college football program.
  • University of Texas - Mentioned as a college football program.
  • Oklahoma - Mentioned as a college football program.
  • Fresno State - Mentioned as a college football program.
  • Alabama - Mentioned as a college football program.
  • Cal - Mentioned as a college basketball and football program.
  • Miami - Mentioned as a team.
  • Green Bay Packers - Mentioned as a team.
  • Raiders - Mentioned as a team.
  • Texans - Mentioned as a team.
  • Jets - Mentioned as a team.
  • ESPN - Mentioned as a media company.
  • CBS - Mentioned as a media company.
  • Iheart Radio - Mentioned as a podcast network.
  • Black Effect Podcast Network - Mentioned as a podcast network.

Podcasts & Audio

  • Up on Game - Mentioned as a podcast.
  • Sacred Lessons - Mentioned as a podcast hosted by Mike Delaroccha.
  • Three and Out Podcast - Mentioned as a podcast hosted by John Middlekoff.
  • Health Stuff - Mentioned as a podcast.
  • Checking In - Mentioned as a podcast hosted by Michelle Williams.
  • The Happiness Lab - Mentioned as a podcast hosted by Dr. Laurie Santos.
  • Next Question - Mentioned as a podcast hosted by Katie Couric.

Other Resources

  • Apple Card - Mentioned for its daily cash back feature.
  • McDonald's Extra Value Meals - Mentioned for a limited-time offer.
  • Industrial-grade products and fast delivery - Mentioned as offerings from Granger.
  • The Shanahan Tree - Mentioned as a coaching lineage.
  • "Football smarts" - Mentioned as a key factor in player evaluation.
  • "The juice" - Mentioned as the addictive aspect of the grind in football.
  • "The game of life" - Mentioned as a board game.
  • "F1" - Mentioned as a racing series.
  • "Project 2025" - Mentioned as a topic discussed on Next Question.
  • "Presidential pardons" - Mentioned as a topic discussed on Next Question.
  • "Year's biggest scandals" - Mentioned as a topic discussed on Next Question.
  • "Same game parlays" - Mentioned

---
Handpicked links, AI-assisted summaries. Human judgment, machine efficiency.
This content is a personally curated review and synopsis derived from the original podcast episode.