Declining US Happiness Correlates With Populism; Well-being Metrics Offer Solutions - Episode Hero Image

Declining US Happiness Correlates With Populism; Well-being Metrics Offer Solutions

What A Day · · Listen to Original Episode →
Original Title:

TL;DR

  • Declining US happiness correlates with increased support for populist presidents, as dissatisfaction drives voters toward radical alternatives regardless of political leaning.
  • Focusing on non-material metrics like well-being in national statistics, mirroring most wealthy nations, can prioritize societal harmony and individual improvement over GDP.
  • Meaningful work and strong social connections significantly impact happiness more than income, suggesting a shift from material pursuits to purpose and community engagement.
  • Individual happiness is influenced by genetics and personality, but can be actively improved through conscious effort in managing attitudes and engaging in fulfilling activities.
  • Social isolation in the US is a key factor in declining happiness, highlighting the need for increased daily interactions and community building to foster well-being.

Deep Dive

The current decline in U.S. happiness rankings, plummeting from 11th to 24th globally between 2012 and 2025, is a significant indicator of societal distress with profound political and economic implications. This pervasive unhappiness, exacerbated by economic hardship like rising grocery costs and unemployment, directly correlates with increased support for populist political movements. Research indicates that dissatisfaction with life fuels a propensity to vote for populist leaders, with low trust in others leaning towards right-wing populism and dissatisfaction combined with high trust leaning towards left-wing populism, suggesting that a populace feeling left behind is more susceptible to radical political shifts.

The science of well-being, distinct from traditional economic measures like GDP, offers a more accurate lens for assessing societal progress and informing governance. While the U.S. has historically prioritized economic indicators, most wealthy nations now include well-being metrics in their national statistics. This shift is crucial because individual happiness is determined not solely by material wealth, but significantly by factors such as mental and physical health, meaningful employment, relationships, and a sense of purpose and connection to others. Income, while a factor, has a surprisingly lower impact on happiness compared to these human elements. Consequently, a government focused on well-being, as envisioned by the nation's founding principles, could foster a more civil and harmonious society, moving beyond the economic anxieties that currently drive political polarization.

Addressing widespread unhappiness requires a societal refocus on non-material values and individual pursuits that foster meaning and connection. While personality traits and genetics play a role in predisposition to happiness, actionable strategies exist for improving well-being. These include cultivating gratitude, strengthening social connections through activities like volunteering or engaging in work that feels purposeful, and actively pursuing enjoyable hobbies. Crucially, combating the rising social isolation in the U.S., evidenced by increased rates of people eating alone, is vital. Encouraging daily interactions and strengthening the social fabric can lead to both individual and collective improvements in happiness, offering a path toward a more stable and content society.

Action Items

  • Track 5-10 key well-being indicators (e.g., life satisfaction, perceived social connection) for personal reflection and progress assessment.
  • Implement one new social connection activity weekly (e.g., coffee with colleague, community group) to combat isolation and enhance personal happiness.
  • Audit personal daily activities for 3-5 hours to identify opportunities for increased meaning or purpose beyond essential tasks.
  • Measure correlation between personal happiness levels and external factors (e.g., economic news, political climate) over 2-4 weeks to understand influences.

Key Quotes

"Well happiness is feeling good overall but um in the science of well being there are quite a few different measures of happiness so the sort of standard one is life satisfaction how do you feel about your life overall so you're probably familiar with the idea that the nordic countries are the happiest on earth that's based on this measure of life satisfaction and then there's a kind of experiential measure that's what we tend to mean in happiness in ordinary language that's how good or bad you feel those are the main two"

Michael Plant explains that happiness can be measured in different ways, primarily through overall life satisfaction and immediate experiential feelings. Plant highlights that while life satisfaction is often used in global rankings, the everyday understanding of happiness relates to how good or bad one feels moment to moment.


"Actually researching happiness is much easier than people think it turns out that if you want to find how happy someone is you just ask them how happy are you zero to 10 it's the sort of solution hiding in plain sight and this contrasts with how we often try and work out how people's lives are going which is effectively we look in their wallets and then we tell them how their lives are and this is this generalizes to our approach to um social welfare where we think that what makes a society going well or badly is just its level of gdp"

Michael Plant points out that assessing happiness is straightforward, often as simple as asking individuals to rate their happiness on a scale. Plant contrasts this direct approach with societal metrics like GDP, which he suggests are indirect and potentially misleading indicators of a society's well-being.


"America has been getting steadily less happy since records began where records began was 1972 the us general social survey and i think i would be bold enough to say that probably part of the reason that you have your current president is because happiness has been going down over that time period so there's new research that came out this year in the world happiness report which finds that when people are dissatisfied with their lives they're more likely to vote for populist presidents"

Michael Plant suggests a correlation between declining happiness in the U.S. and the rise of populist presidents. Plant references research indicating that dissatisfaction with life can lead individuals to support populist political movements, regardless of their ideological leaning.


"So if you remember the us declaration of independence what are some of the key words that we have these inalienable rights life liberty and the pursuit of happiness and then um thomas jefferson said in 1810 that human happiness and the care of life are the only legitimate objects of good government so i think we should get back to happiness we got sidetracked in the 20th century where we focused on gdp and the economy but now there is a new happiness of science that really started in the 70s"

Michael Plant argues for a return to prioritizing happiness as a governmental objective, referencing historical American ideals. Plant notes that the focus shifted to GDP and economic growth in the 20th century, but a growing field of happiness science, emerging in the 1970s, offers a different perspective.


"So the things we think are important are borne out by happiness research so there's differences between how important we think these things are so income has a surprisingly low effect in happiness research compared to things like mental health and you can capture better the impact of the human aspects of life than you would do if you were just looking at sort of standard economic measures like gdp"

Michael Plant states that common beliefs about what contributes to happiness are largely supported by research, with some surprising findings. Plant highlights that income has a less significant impact on happiness than factors like mental health, and that happiness research can better quantify the importance of human connections than economic indicators alone.


"Our lives are happier if we feel useful to other people and if we feel connected we feel part of something larger than ourselves you can think about volunteering participating in political activity in work where you feel like you're making a difference so so jane you probably feel like you're doing a job which matters so you can have jobs which matter"

Michael Plant asserts that a sense of purpose and connection to others significantly enhances happiness. Plant suggests that activities like volunteering, political engagement, or work that feels meaningful contribute to this sense of usefulness and belonging, which are crucial for well-being.

Resources

External Resources

Books

  • "The Declaration of Independence" - Referenced for its mention of inalienable rights: life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
  • "The Wealth of Nations" by Adam Smith - Mentioned as a foundational text for the 20th-century focus on GDP and the economy.

Articles & Papers

  • "World Happiness Report" (This year) - Cited for research finding that life dissatisfaction increases the likelihood of voting for populist presidents.
  • "US General Social Survey" (1972) - Referenced as the starting point for tracking US happiness trends since records began.

People

  • Michael Plant - Founder and director of the Happier Lives Institute, interviewed about happiness research and wellbeing.
  • Jane Coaston - Host of "What A Day," conducting the interview with Michael Plant.
  • Donald Trump - Mentioned in relation to economic sentiment and populist voting.
  • J.D. Vance - Mentioned in relation to economic messaging and seeking patience from Americans.
  • Mike Lawler - New York Republican Representative, quoted on the decision not to vote on extending Affordable Care Act subsidies.
  • Mike Johnson - House Speaker, discussed regarding potential votes on healthcare legislation and ACA subsidies.
  • Abraham Lincoln - Mentioned in relation to the production of pennies bearing his face.
  • Ryan Reynolds - Mentioned in a promotional segment for Mint Mobile.

Organizations & Institutions

  • Happier Lives Institute - Described as a nonprofit researching cost-effective ways to improve global wellbeing.
  • Common Good Institute - Cited for a finding that the US fell in global happiness rankings.
  • Nordic countries - Referenced as the happiest on earth based on life satisfaction measures.
  • United States Mint - Mentioned in relation to the auction of final minted pennies.
  • Crooked Media - Production company for "What A Day" and the "Strict Scrutiny" podcast.
  • Zbiotics - Company offering a pre-alcohol probiotic drink, featured in an advertisement.
  • Valvoline Instant Oil Change - Featured in a promotional segment.
  • Mint Mobile - Featured in a promotional segment with Ryan Reynolds.
  • Bureau of Labor Statistics - Source for unemployment rate data.
  • Associated Press - Contributor to the news segment.
  • Irish Cattle Breeding Federation - Developer of the Herd+ app for dairy farmers.
  • DSW - Retailer featured in a holiday PSA.

Websites & Online Resources

  • Truth Social - Platform where President Trump posted about the economy.
  • CNBC - News outlet where Kevin Hassett made comments about economic data.
  • Crooked.com/subscribe - URL for subscribing to the "What A Day" newsletter.
  • Zbiotics.com/what - URL for Zbiotics, with a discount code mentioned.

Podcasts & Audio

  • What A Day - The podcast featuring the discussion on quantifying happiness.
  • Strict Scrutiny - Crooked's legal podcast, recommended for listeners interested in legal battles and court decisions.

Other Resources

  • Affordable Care Act (ACA) subsidies - Discussed in relation to an approaching deadline for extension and potential premium increases.
  • GDP (Gross Domestic Product) - Mentioned as a traditional economic measure that has overshadowed wellbeing in the 20th century.
  • Life Satisfaction - A standard measure of happiness used in wellbeing science.
  • Experiential Measure of Happiness - The measure of how good or bad someone feels, akin to ordinary language use of "happiness."
  • Populist Presidents - Discussed in relation to voter dissatisfaction and trust levels.
  • Obamacare - Referred to in the context of a subsidy created by Democrats.
  • Penny - Discussed in relation to its production ending and the auction of final minted sets.
  • Herd+ app - Developed by the Irish Cattle Breeding Federation to help dairy farmers find genetic matches for their cows.

---
Handpicked links, AI-assisted summaries. Human judgment, machine efficiency.
This content is a personally curated review and synopsis derived from the original podcast episode.