Independent Artists Showcase Diverse Cover Songs Amidst Competition - Episode Hero Image

Independent Artists Showcase Diverse Cover Songs Amidst Competition

Original Title: 2025 Cover Song Challenge

TL;DR

  • The Motown Media four-day tour, featuring 30 songs with at least 11 unique tracks each night, emphasizes improvisation and distinct show experiences to engage audiences.
  • Independent artists face significant challenges competing with major labels like Columbia Records, which continue to promote legacy albums decades after their release.
  • The cover song challenge format, where only one winner is selected, inherently creates controversy and disappointment for the many talented participants.
  • The podcast promotes limited-edition vinyl records, positioning them as valuable, collectible items that are expected to increase in price as they sell out.
  • The host's creative process is fueled by intense jealousy of successful artists like Bruce Springsteen and John Darnielle, driving the creation of new material.
  • The "Keep Being Awesome" album's upcoming 10th-anniversary vinyl release, featuring a curated 20-track selection from an original 73, is positioned as a must-have for fans.

Deep Dive

This podcast episode, "2025 Cover Song Challenge," showcases a diverse array of musical submissions, highlighting the creative spirit of independent artists and their engagement with existing songs. The overarching theme is the celebration of musical interpretation and the personal connection artists forge with music, all within the context of a friendly competition.

The episode features a wide range of cover songs, demonstrating varied approaches to reinterpreting existing works. Trey Warren's rendition of "Get Away Our Way" sets a soulful tone, while Donji's "Whoa" brings an intense energy. Joe Clark and Arcana's live performance of "The Mothman Song" adds a dynamic, horn-driven element, and Bill Dwayne Rain's "Marco Polo Punch in the Face" delivers high-octane fun. Christopher Canyon's "The Upper Decker" and Frankie Dead and the Grateful Teardrop's take on Bruce Springsteen's "Nebraska" showcase unique lyrical interpretations and intimate performances, respectively. Jim Sanders' "Sparrow's Art" and Tom Cassidy's "Postcards and Memories" continue the trend of energetic and heartfelt performances. Spudcaster's "Existential Crisis" explores introspective themes, while Todd Got Over Excited's "Regrets in a Fort Made Out of Blankets" and DJ Narthax's "Take It For Granted" offer further varied interpretations. Wilf Kirby Clark's cover of "Been a Long Time" and Brother Jim and the Brimstone Trio's "I Killed an Owl" add distinct flavors, with the latter notably drawing from a personal anecdote. Finally, Biskue's "You Don't Get Me To Kick Around No More" provides a thoughtful conclusion, incorporating elements of The Mountain Goats.

The implication of this curated selection of covers is the democratization of music creation and appreciation. By providing a platform for these artists, the podcast fosters a sense of community and validation for independent musicians. The host's commentary, including discussions about the creative process, the challenges of independent artistry versus major labels (drawing parallels to Bruce Springsteen's sustained success), and even admitting the potential for forgetting entries, underscores the raw, personal, and often challenging nature of pursuing a music career. The recurring mention of merchandise, live tours, and upcoming vinyl releases highlights the entrepreneurial spirit required to sustain such creative endeavors, demonstrating that while the joy of creation is central, the practicalities of building an audience and generating revenue are also implicitly present. The competition itself, with its emphasis on a single winner and the acknowledgment of the difficulty in choosing, speaks to the subjective nature of art and the shared passion that unites the participants, regardless of the outcome.

Action Items

  • Audit 30+ cover songs: Identify recurring lyrical themes or musical patterns across entries to inform future creative challenges.
  • Track 5-10 participant submissions per week to ensure timely review and feedback for the cover song challenge.
  • Measure engagement with promotional content: Analyze click-through rates for tour dates and merchandise links to optimize marketing efforts.
  • Evaluate 20-30 song submissions for the next vinyl release: Prioritize tracks with strong potential for broad appeal and longevity.

Key Quotes

"there's still time plan a weekend it's gonna be amazing i mean your favorite musicians are doing something wild four shows in three days and the way we're doing it folks is we're gonna um we have about 30 songs on the set list each night and i think 11 at least 11 of them are different every night too so uh they'll be there's it's not the same exact show every night every show is gonna be different from the last and there's always a great level of improvisation that goes on um from one show to the next each show is its own thing"

The speaker, Matt Farley, highlights the unique nature of the Motown Media four-day tour. He emphasizes that each night offers a distinct experience with a large setlist and a significant number of songs changing daily. This approach aims to provide variety and encourage repeat attendance by ensuring no two shows are identical.


"well this ain't no sparrow and it ain't no owl with its high spying feet and its pipe hit power not a hawk nor an eagle nor a bat nor a pheasant it's the mothman of point pleasant believe believe yes you can believe in the power of the mothman believe believe yes you can believe in the power of the mothman"

Joe Clark, through his song "The Mothman Song," presents a vivid description of the Mothman. The speaker uses comparisons to various birds and animals to emphasize the unique and powerful nature of this cryptid. This lyrical approach aims to build a strong, memorable image of the Mothman for the listener.


"The author argues, 'The main problem is we don't -- we don't work for columbia records who you know any of our best stuff could be handed over to the columbia records promo team and and they could make turn it into a legendary album like they did with bruce's is all i'm saying okay and they're still promoting it guys they just made a movie about about it -- that's what we're up against us independent artists okay 40 years after an album's being made they're still pushing it and like trying to add to the the mythology behind it that's what we're up against'"

Frankie Dead and the Grateful Teardrop, through their interpretation of Bruce Springsteen's "Nebraska," express frustration with the challenges faced by independent artists. The speaker contrasts their own efforts with the marketing power of major record labels like Columbia Records. This quote illustrates the significant disparity in resources and established legacy that independent musicians must contend with.


"I mean gary's already i mean dj narthax also known as gary has already won this thing but he knows he knows how to button it up you know the way to do it is is do a cover of the song that just came out 'cause then you know you make farley think yeah i still got it i still got it that's what I was thinking while listening to this song even even in the section where where dj narthax made it abundantly clear that these chords -- are outrageously similar if not identical to the main chords from take on me by aha you hear it did you hear it there I heard it"

The speaker, Matt Farley, acknowledges DJ Narthax's previous win and his strategic choice to cover a recently released song. Farley points out the similarity in chords to A-ha's "Take On Me," suggesting that DJ Narthax is adept at both covering new material and creating songs that resonate. This highlights DJ Narthax's skill in navigating the challenge by referencing current music and established popular chord progressions.


"I got corner poopia corner of my poop poop of my poop I got corner of my poop poop of my poop poop of my poop I got corner of my poop poop of my poop poop of my poop"

Brother Jim and the Brimstone Trio, in their song "Corner Poopia," present a repetitive and somewhat nonsensical lyrical structure. The speaker uses a consistent, almost chant-like phrase to create a distinct sonic texture. This approach emphasizes rhythm and a potentially humorous or absurd lyrical theme over narrative development.

Resources

External Resources

Books

  • "The Beyond" by Brennan McFarley - Mentioned as the album from which the song "Get Away Our Way" originates.
  • "Nebraska" by Bruce Springsteen - Referenced multiple times as an example of an intimate and heartfelt album, and as a benchmark for independent artists.
  • "The Motern Method" - Mentioned as a book available for purchase, and as a potential prize for the cover song challenge.

Articles & Papers

  • "Tour Diaries London" - Mentioned as a past podcast episode featuring Wilf.

People

  • Brennan McFarley - Artist whose song "Get Away Our Way" was covered.
  • Bruce Springsteen - Artist whose album "Nebraska" was discussed as a benchmark.
  • Christopher Canyon - Artist whose song "Upper Decker" was covered.
  • DJ Narthax (Gary) - Participant in the cover song challenge, also noted for writing lyrics and having a song similar to "Take On Me" by a-ha.
  • Donji - Artist whose song "Whoa" was covered.
  • Frankie Dead and the Grateful Teardrop - Artist whose cover of Bruce Springsteen's "Nebraska" was discussed.
  • Jim Sanders - Participant in the cover song challenge, noted for being an internet friend.
  • Joe Clark and Arcana - Artist whose song "Mothman" was covered.
  • Kirk - Participant in the cover song challenge, who covered "I Killed an Owl."
  • Matt Farley - Host of the podcast, also referred to as "Motown Media."
  • Pete Peterson - Co-writer of "Been a Long Time" by The Finkelsticks.
  • Spudcaster - Participant in the cover song challenge from England, UK.
  • The Finkelsticks - Band whose song "Been a Long Time" was covered.
  • Tom Cassidy - Artist whose song "Postcards and Memories" was covered.
  • Tom Scalzo - Mentioned as a co-writer of lyrics and as someone who helped remove an owl from a car.
  • Trey Warren - Artist whose song "Get Away Our Way" was covered.
  • Wilf (Wilfred Kirby Clark) - Participant in the cover song challenge, who covered "Been a Long Time."
  • Winnipeg Bisk - Participant in the cover song challenge, who performed a mashup including "You Don't Get Me to Kick Around No More."

Organizations & Institutions

  • Aha - Band whose song "Take On Me" was referenced due to chord similarity.
  • Motern Media - The podcast host and associated entity.
  • The Mountain Goats - Band whose song "You Don't Get Me to Kick Around No More" was referenced, and whose members are expressed as a source of jealousy for the host.

Other Resources

  • "I Killed an Owl" - A song covered by Kirk, based on a real-life event.
  • "Marco Polo Punch in the Face" - A song covered by Bill Dwayne Rain.
  • "Nice Dress" - A song covered by Donji.
  • "Postcards and Memories" - A song covered by Tom Cassidy.
  • "Regrets in a Fort Made Out of Blankets" - A song covered by Todd Got Over Excited.
  • "Take It For Granted" - A song covered by DJ Narthax.
  • "The Mothman Song" - A song by Joe Clark and Arcana that was covered.
  • "Upper Decker" - A song covered by Christopher Canyon.
  • "Whoa" - A song covered by Donji.
  • "You Don't Get Me to Kick Around No More" - A song covered by Winnipeg Bisk, with a mashup.
  • "Existential Crisis" - A song covered by Spudcaster.
  • "Get Away Our Way" - A song covered by Trey Warren, originally by Brennan McFarley.
  • "Keep Being Awesome" - An album by Spudcaster, with a 10th-anniversary vinyl release planned.
  • "Been a Long Time" - A song by The Finkelsticks, covered by Wilf.
  • "Marco Polo Punch in the Face" - A song covered by Bill Dwayne Rain.
  • "Nebraska" (Bruce Springsteen album) - Discussed in relation to independent artists and album production.
  • "Take On Me" (Aha song) - Referenced for chord progression similarity to DJ Narthax's song.

---
Handpicked links, AI-assisted summaries. Human judgment, machine efficiency.
This content is a personally curated review and synopsis derived from the original podcast episode.