Protect Essential Systems Over Innovation During December Fatigue
TL;DR
- December's strain reveals system weaknesses, making stability the priority over innovation, as only essential, protected systems can withstand fatigue and prevent program collapse.
- Adding new processes during December's low energy exacerbates strain; leaders must protect existing core systems like communication, scheduling, and volunteer pipelines instead.
- The stabilizing question "Does this stabilize or destabilize?" should precede any change, pausing destabilizing actions even if they seem important to preserve program integrity.
- Protecting margins of time, energy, and patience is crucial, as these are not signs of laziness but essential buffers that prevent burnout and keep individuals functioning.
- Leaders should identify and fiercely protect one essential system, affirming its value and defending it from unnecessary change to maintain program continuity.
- Systems are working if people are still showing up and learning, even if they feel fragile, indicating that preservation, not reinvention, is the December leadership focus.
Deep Dive
December leadership is not about innovation or expansion, but about protecting the essential systems that maintain stability when energy is scarce. Adding new processes during this high-stress period is counterproductive; instead, leaders must focus on preserving the core functions that prevent program collapse. This approach ensures that programs can reach a period of rest without succumbing to the revealed weaknesses of their underlying structures.
The critical implication of this "protection over innovation" strategy is that December acts as a stress test, revealing the true resilience of existing systems rather than creating opportunities for growth. When fatigue sets in, only robust, essential systems--such as communication flow, rehearsal schedules, volunteer pipelines, financial rhythms, leadership decision-making loops, and emotional culture--will endure. Attempting to introduce new solutions during this period is a governance trap that can destabilize rather than solve problems, as energy is already depleted and capacity for learning new processes is minimal. The most effective governance question for December is whether a proposed action stabilizes or destabilizes the program; if it destabilizes, it should be paused, regardless of its perceived importance.
Furthermore, this leadership philosophy emphasizes the vital role of margins--time, energy, emotional capacity, and patience--which are depleted by year-end demands. Leaders are tasked with protecting these margins by simplifying expectations, canceling non-essentials, and preserving off-hours, recognizing that these are not signs of laziness but are crucial for sustained performance. The actionable insight for leaders is to identify one core system that is currently functioning well and defend it vigorously against unnecessary changes. This preservation, rather than enhancement, of existing, functional systems is the key to navigating the end of the year successfully, acknowledging that continued operation and learning, even if fragile, signifies that the systems are working.
The ultimate takeaway is that true leadership during periods of scarcity is defined by steadiness and protection. By safeguarding existing systems and margins, leaders can maintain program integrity and support their teams through exhaustion. This approach not only prevents collapse but also lays the groundwork for future rebuilding, with the assurance that additional support tools are forthcoming.
Action Items
- Audit 5 core systems: Identify 3 critical functions (communication, scheduling, volunteer pipeline) and document current stability metrics.
- Draft 1-page system protection plan: Outline 3-5 essential systems and define 2-3 specific protective actions for each (e.g., cancel non-essential meetings).
- Implement stabilizing question: Before any new initiative, ask "Does this stabilize or destabilize?" and document decisions for 3-5 instances.
- Measure 3-5 key margins: Track time, energy, and patience for 1-2 weeks to identify areas for preservation.
- Identify 1 essential system: Name and defend one current system from unnecessary change for a 2-week period.
Key Quotes
"You don’t need better systems in December. You need the right ones protected. Welcome back to the rest stop. It's Wednesday of week eight. And right now, stability is the most valuable currency in your entire program. Not innovation, not expansion, not growth. Stability."
The speaker, Mike, argues that during December, the focus should shift from improving or adding systems to safeguarding the ones that are already functioning. He emphasizes that stability, rather than innovation or expansion, is the most critical element for a program's success at year-end. This highlights his core message that preservation is key when resources are strained.
"December doesn't break systems. It reveals them. It reveals which schedules are sustainable, which communication channels actually work, which volunteers are supported instead of stretched, which of your expectations are realistic, and which systems are built on clarity versus pressure."
Mike explains that the challenges of December do not cause systems to fail but rather expose their underlying strengths and weaknesses. He points out that this period clarifies which operational elements are truly effective and sustainable, distinguishing them from those that are merely adding pressure or are not robust enough to withstand fatigue. This reveals his perspective on how stress tests reveal true system efficacy.
"Here's the governance trap that shows up this time of year. Leaders see strain, and they try to fix it with new solutions. New systems, new spreadsheets, new meeting rhythms, new rules, new processes. But December is not the month for adding anything. December is a month for protecting what already works."
Mike identifies a common leadership error of introducing new solutions when faced with strain during December. He asserts that this is counterproductive, as the month demands protection of existing, functional systems rather than the implementation of new ones. This highlights his advice against adding complexity during periods of low energy and high demand.
"December collapses margins for everybody. Margins of time, margins of energy, margins of emotional capacity, margins of patience. Your job as a leader right now is to protect the margin. Not consume it."
Mike states that December significantly reduces available resources for everyone involved, including time, energy, emotional capacity, and patience. He instructs leaders that their primary role during this period is to safeguard these limited margins, rather than depleting them further. This underscores his belief that protecting personal and team capacity is essential for navigating the end of the year.
"Identify one system that is holding your program together right now. And I want you to protect it fiercely. And it might be a daily check-in rhythm, a calm rehearsal schedule, a steady volunteer lead, a consistent communication channel, a weekly leadership huddle, a financial process, a shared document system. Name it, affirm it, and defend it from unnecessary change."
Mike issues a challenge to leaders to pinpoint a single system that is currently sustaining their program and to actively protect it. He provides examples of such essential systems and urges leaders to affirm their value and shield them from any changes. This demonstrates his actionable advice for prioritizing and preserving critical operational elements.
"Listen. If your people are still showing up, if your kids are still learning, if your volunteers are still trying, if your program is still moving, then your systems are working. Even if they feel fragile. You don't have to reinvent everything in December. You just have to hold it steady until rest arrives."
Mike offers reassurance by stating that the continued participation and effort of people within a program indicate that its systems are functioning, regardless of how fragile they may seem. He advises against attempting major overhauls in December, suggesting instead that the focus should be on maintaining stability until a period of rest is possible. This conveys his message of acknowledging existing functionality and prioritizing endurance.
Resources
External Resources
Organizations & Institutions
- Virtual Assistant Directors - Community for arts leaders, parents, and educators
- SoundstageEDU - Provider of rescue tools for leadership support
Other Resources
- Governance - Discussed as a system that matters most for year-end stability
- Year-End Stability - Key concept for protecting existing systems during periods of high stress
- Margins (time, energy, emotional capacity, patience) - Discussed as essential for preventing collapse during busy periods
- Culture Rebuild - Mentioned as a process occurring alongside protected systems and rest stops