The "So I Can What?" Trap: Why Your Agency Goals Are Likely Misaligned

In this conversation, branding expert Phil Davis and host Jason Swenk explain a common mistake agency owners make when setting goals. Most leaders focus on external metrics like revenue, headcount, or awards without considering the long-term impact of those targets. This creates a cycle of busywork that drains the business and leaves the founder unhappy. The discussion shows that growth is often treated as a default, when it can actually become a runaway system that destroys the peace and freedom the owner originally wanted. This analysis helps agency leaders at a turning point stop chasing the wrong metrics and start building a business that supports their actual life goals.

The Hidden Cost of Big Goals

Agency owners are often told to set aggressive revenue targets. Davis argues that this is a trap. When you set a goal, such as hitting $20 million in revenue, without questioning why you want it, you are building a machine you might not want to run.

The system is simple: you chase a dollar figure, which forces you to hire more people and take on difficult retail accounts to keep up. This creates a loop where the business becomes a burden rather than an asset. Davis calls these the blur years, where the owner is so caught up in billing and management that they lose sight of their original purpose.

> "I was told by my VISTAGE group at the time pick a big ballsy number or something or a goal... that's what got me on the whole wrong path. So I started chasing dollar numbers and I thought success was measured in the size of your account."
>
> -- Phil Davis

Why Your Solution Often Becomes the Problem

Systems thinking requires looking at how a decision, such as hiring a top salesperson or chasing awards, affects the entire organization. Davis shares the story of a Vistage member whose top salesperson, responsible for 40% of sales, quit after the owner began questioning the agency mission.

While the first reaction was panic, the result was a major increase in team morale. The salesperson had been a difficult employee who hoarded accounts and hurt the culture. By aligning the agency with a clear purpose, the system corrected itself by removing the person who was blocking progress. The immediate loss of revenue was the price paid for a long-term improvement in team performance.

Alignment as an Operating System

Davis defines his agency, Tungsten, through the lens of alignment. He compares a business to electricity: current only flows when the electrons move in the same direction. When an agency tries to be everything to everyone, it wastes its energy.

The key insight is that elimination is a strategy. Many owners fear that turning away work will stop their growth, but Davis suggests that keeping a messy service offering prevents the focus needed to lead the market. Real competitive advantage comes from picking one goal and discarding everything else.

> "If you think about electricity, electricity moves and current moves when the electrons are in alignment. When things point the same direction, you create flow."
>
> -- Phil Davis

The "So I Can What?" Acid Test

The most useful tool discussed is the "So I can what?" inquiry. It is a process that forces you to trace a goal to its end point.

1. The Goal: "I want a $20M agency."
2. The Question: "So I can what?"
3. The Response: "So I can have generational wealth."
4. The Question: "So I can what?"
5. The Terminal Point: "Peace of mind and freedom."

Most owners find that the big goal is actually a barrier to the peace and freedom they want. By identifying the end goal early, you can avoid years of unnecessary work and build a business that provides the desired outcome without the extra overhead.

Key Action Items

• The "So I Can What?" Audit: For every major goal on your roadmap, ask "So I can what?" at least three times. If the final answer is peace or freedom, check if your current growth strategy is the best way to get there. (Immediate)
• Identify Your Track Event: Stop trying to be a full-service agency that does everything. Decide if you are a sprinter or a shot putter. Cut the services that do not fit your core focus. (Over the next quarter)
• Conduct a Sophie’s Choice Session: List the top three things your agency stands for. If two had to go, which one would remain? Build your brand around that single pillar. (Over the next 30 days)
• Right-Size Your Culture: Identify if any high-performers are actually toxic to your team. Be ready for the short-term revenue dip that comes from removing them; the long-term gain in team speed will pay off in 12 to 18 months. (Ongoing)
• Decouple Lifestyle from Revenue: As your agency grows, resist the urge to inflate your personal lifestyle. By keeping your costs low, you gain the freedom to stop chasing growth for the sake of growth and start building an asset you actually want to own. (Ongoing)