College Football Teams Decline Bowls to Avoid Losing Records
TL;DR
- Multiple Power Five programs and other established teams declined the Birmingham Bowl invitation, indicating a preference to avoid additional losses and the negative historical record associated with a losing season.
- Appalachian State accepted the Birmingham Bowl invitation primarily to engage in a rivalry game against Georgia Southern, prioritizing this matchup over a typical bowl season vacation.
- The Birmingham Bowl's participant selection process was significantly impacted by Notre Dame's withdrawal from bowl season, forcing the ACC to scramble for a five-win team to fill the slot.
- The "turned down" status of bowl invitations is subject to interpretation, with some teams like Temple disputing the characterization of their decision to not participate.
Deep Dive
The 2025 Birmingham Bowl highlights a significant shift in college football bowl eligibility and team willingness to participate, driven by a desire to avoid additional losses and the reputational damage they carry. This has led to a notable number of teams declining invitations, forcing the bowl to scramble for participants.
The core of this dynamic is the increasing aversion to finishing a season with a losing record, even if that record is technically bowl-eligible. Teams like Florida State and Baylor reportedly turned down the Birmingham Bowl invitation because they did not want to risk a potential loss that would result in a 5-8 record. This implies a growing emphasis on the narrative and historical record of a team's season, where an additional loss, even in a postseason game, carries more weight than the perceived benefit of participating. The Birmingham Bowl's scramble for a five-win team, ultimately selecting Appalachian State over Georgia Southern due to existing rivalries, underscores the desperation to fill spots when traditional participants opt out. This situation reveals a tension between the tradition of bowl season and the modern team's calculus for managing their season's legacy.
Ultimately, the Birmingham Bowl serves as a case study in the evolving priorities of college football programs, where the avoidance of negative historical markers now outweighs the traditional allure of postseason play for some teams, leading to a reshuffling of participants and a focus on less conventional matchups.
Action Items
- Audit bowl game invitations: Identify 5-7 teams that declined participation to understand selection criteria deviations.
- Track bowl game acceptance rationale: For 3-5 declined teams, analyze reported reasons to prevent future invitation rejections.
- Measure bowl game participation impact: For App State, assess the value of playing Georgia Southern versus a vacation.
Key Quotes
"And the team that they found to do it was none other than the team that hates Georgia Southern the most, Appalachian State, five and seven. They were like, you know what, we could, we could take the winner off, or we could go punch those assholes we hate in Birmingham. What do you think, fellas? We want to go headbutt Georgia Southern again? Yeah, hell yeah, we like that more than vacation."
The author highlights Appalachian State's motivation for accepting a bowl game invitation. This quote shows Appalachian State's preference for playing a rival, Georgia Southern, over a traditional vacation. The author suggests this choice reflects a team's desire for competitive engagement over rest.
"On Selection Sunday, Brett McMurphy reported, reported Florida State, Auburn, and UCF, Baylor, Rutgers, Temple, and Kansas State turned the game down. And then there's some sort of, uh, the haggling over what does 'turned down' mean? Like Temple came out and said, like, well, no, we didn't turn it down, you know. So like, it, it, there's varying interpretations of exactly what that means, but it's quite a list regardless."
The author presents a list of teams that reportedly declined an invitation to the Birmingham Bowl. This quote demonstrates the author's observation that the meaning of "turned down" can be ambiguous, as evidenced by Temple's differing statement. The author notes that regardless of interpretation, the list of teams is significant.
"For some of these, like, okay, for Temple, I can be like, look, Birmingham's far away, you're maybe not like, I don't know, we're gonna sell our ticket allotment, etcetera, etcetera. Florida State, Baylor, this is 100% like, I'm not looking for it, I'm not looking for more losses. Do not put that. No. I have survived this season. Do not put that shit on me."
The author explains potential reasons why certain teams might decline a bowl invitation. This quote shows the author's perspective that teams like Florida State and Baylor would refuse a bowl game to avoid accumulating more losses. The author suggests these teams prioritize preserving their season's record over participating in an additional game.
"You know, society is held up by rules. And I feel like there's a lot of teams, probably today, a lot of, a lot of alums who were like, wait, we can just turn down the Birmingham Bowl pit? I'm looking at you. Most of them went to Pitt. That was their ancestral homeland. Yeah. Yeah. They're like, we can, I didn't know we were allowed to do that."
The author reflects on the perceived novelty of teams declining bowl game invitations. This quote demonstrates the author's idea that many alumni may be unaware of the option to refuse a bowl game. The author implies that this realization is a recent development for some programs, such as those associated with Pitt.
Resources
External Resources
Videos & Documentaries
- 40 FOR 40: The 2025 Birmingham Bowl - Episode of a bowl preview series
Articles & Papers
- "40 FOR 40: The 2025 Birmingham Bowl" (Shutdown Fullcast) - Episode title and description
- "reported Florida State, Auburn, and UCF, Baylor, Rutgers, Temple, and Kansas State turned the game down." (Brett McMurphy) - Reported list of teams that declined bowl invitations
Websites & Online Resources
- preownedairboats.com - Website for purchasing PTKU merchandise
- transohio.org - Website for Trans Ohio
- channel-6.ghost.io - Website for a year-round newsletter about football
- jasonkirk.fyi - Website for Jason's novel and other work
- falconscottproductions.com - Website for Ryan's new show with Steven Godfrey
- linktr.ee/killerantz - Linktree for Surber's band Killer Antz and his new show Podcasterino
Other Resources
- PTKU merch - Merchandise sales benefiting Trans Ohio
- Trans Ohio - Organization receiving proceeds from merchandise sales
- Channel 6 - Year-round newsletter
- Phantom Island - Ryan's new show with Steven Godfrey
- Killer Antz - Michael Ray Surber's band
- Podcasterino - Michael Ray Surber's new show
- sports reference - Website used for looking up team records
- BBVA Compass Bowl - Previous name for the Birmingham Bowl