Penny Production Ceases Due to Unsustainable Manufacturing Costs
TL;DR
- The U.S. Mint's production of pennies ceased because the cost to manufacture each coin exceeded its one-cent face value, reaching 3.7 cents by the end of its run, creating a financial loss for the government.
- The increasing cost of base metals, driven by a hot economy, caused the penny's production cost to surpass its face value, initiating a decades-long debate about its continued circulation.
- Despite significant losses, the penny's production cost was considered a "rounding error" relative to the federal budget, leading Congress to delay urgent action on its discontinuation for years.
- The U.S. Mint's mandate to produce coins at no cost to taxpayers is undermined when production expenses exceed face value, eliminating potential "seigniorage" profits that could reduce national debt.
- The decline in cash usage contributed to reduced demand for pennies, further exacerbating the economic inefficiency of producing a coin that was increasingly being discarded or accumulated.
- The discontinuation of the penny, after 232 years, highlights a shift in currency value where production cost, not just face value, dictates economic viability for coinage.
Deep Dive
The U.S. government has ceased production of the penny after 232 years, driven by the economic reality that it costs more to produce than its face value. This decision, while seemingly minor, signals a shift in how currency is valued and managed, with implications for government revenue, public perception of currency, and even artistic expression. The continued circulation of billions of pennies means this change will not be immediate, but it highlights a long-standing inefficiency in U.S. coinage.
The core argument for ending penny production rests on its cost to the taxpayer. Since 2006, the cost to mint a penny has exceeded its one-cent value, a deficit that has grown to 3.7 cents per coin by the time production stopped. This means the U.S. Mint was losing money on every penny produced, a loss that, while a rounding error in the federal budget, represents a direct drain on public funds. The government's goal is to produce currency at no cost, and the penny has failed to meet this standard. This situation, exacerbated by rising base metal costs, has forced a reevaluation of the penny's future, a problem that has persisted across multiple administrations.
The implications of this decision are multifaceted. Economically, the end of penny production eliminates a source of government expense and could, in theory, contribute to seigniorage--the profit made when the face value of a coin exceeds its production cost--if other coins remain profitable. However, the cost of producing nickels is also reportedly higher than their face value, suggesting a broader challenge in coin production. Socially, the penny has been a symbol of American currency, with its iconic Lincoln imagery even reaching Mars. Its removal from production will alter this tangible connection, shifting it from a circulating artifact to a historical one. This transition is already being felt, with some institutions no longer accepting pennies, and artists like Robert Wechsler, who uses pennies in his extensive sculptures, facing the prospect of their medium becoming purely historical. For children, the penny remains a point of wonder and a tool for learning about history and economics, a role that will now be fulfilled by remaining circulating coins.
Ultimately, the cessation of penny production is a pragmatic response to an unsustainable cost. While the penny will continue to circulate for some time, its status as a manufactured currency is over, marking a significant, albeit quiet, shift in American economic history and forcing a re-evaluation of the value and cost of coinage.
Action Items
- Audit penny production costs: Calculate the cost-to-face-value ratio for nickels and pennies to identify which coin presents the greater financial loss.
- Track nickel production costs: Measure the cost of producing nickels over the last 3-5 years to project future financial implications.
- Analyze historical coin production data: Review the cost trends of penny and nickel production from 2006 to present to identify patterns of increasing material costs.
- Evaluate alternative coin materials: Research and assess the feasibility of using alternative metals or non-metallic materials for coin production to reduce manufacturing costs.
Key Quotes
"In November, the U.S. stopped production of the humble penny after 232 years in circulation. On today’s show, Darian Woods and Wailin Wong from NPR's daily economics podcast The Indicator unpack the fiscal math that doomed the penny, and an artist pay tribute to this American icon."
This quote introduces the central topic of the podcast episode: the cessation of penny production by the U.S. government. The Indicator hosts, Darian Woods and Wailin Wong, are presented as the guides who will explore the economic reasons behind this decision and acknowledge the cultural significance of the penny through an artist's perspective.
"The job of the mint is to make enough circulating coins to meet demand within the economy and ed says the office tries to do this at no cost to the taxpayers and that means it shouldn't cost more to make a coin than the face value of that coin the best case scenario is when a coin's face value is more than the production cost then the government makes a profit there's even a special term for that profit seigniorage"
Ed Moy, former director of the U.S. Mint, explains the operational goal of the mint: to supply coins without incurring costs for taxpayers. Moy highlights that profitability occurs when a coin's face value exceeds its production cost, a concept known as seigniorage, which then contributes to the national treasury.
"In 2006 ed's first year on the job the U.S. mint was making money on dimes quarters and dollar coins but it was losing money on nickels and pennies in fact 2006 was the first year that the cost of making a penny went above one cent ed remembers it going to 1 4 cents"
This quote pinpoints a critical turning point in the penny's financial viability, as stated by Ed Moy. Moy recalls that in 2006, the cost to produce a penny exceeded its face value for the first time, marking the beginning of a sustained financial loss for this denomination, while other coins remained profitable.
"The demand for pennies was also declining as people used less cash that was up to my successor to deliver that report to congress and every other successor has had to deal with this problem by last month when the mint announced it was producing the last penny the cost to make the coin was 3 7 cents"
Ed Moy discusses the dual pressures contributing to the penny's demise: decreasing demand due to reduced cash usage and the escalating production cost. Moy notes that the problem persisted beyond his tenure, with the cost to mint a penny reaching 3.7 cents by the time production finally ceased.
"My name is robert wexler and i'm an artist and for more than two decades now i've been focusing on the u s penny and i just finished 100 000 penny cube"
Robert Wexler, an artist, introduces his long-standing dedication to using the U.S. penny as his artistic medium. Wexler shares his recent completion of a large-scale sculpture, a cube constructed from 100,000 pennies, demonstrating his deep engagement with the coin.
"They're these like lowly gutter things you know they they live in muck and they're exposed to unspeakable filth but that has this incredible effect in that they um they do turn blue and green but they also turn like these spectacular oranges and reds or these like really lovely waxy blacks and it's so unique and special and just it's like a little world"
Robert Wexler describes the aesthetic transformation of pennies due to their exposure to environmental elements. Wexler highlights how the "filth" and wear on these coins result in a range of striking colors, from blues and greens to oranges, reds, and blacks, which he finds uniquely beautiful and evocative.
Resources
External Resources
Books
- "The Indicator" by Darian Woods and Wailin Wong - Mentioned as the source of the featured episode about the penny.
Articles & Papers
- "The Indicator: Take A Penny, Leave A Penny, Get Rid Of The Penny" (Short Wave) - This episode is presented as content from NPR's daily economics podcast, The Indicator.
People
- Robert Wechsler - Artist who created a sculpture from 100,000 pennies.
- Ed Moy - Former director of the U.S. Mint (2006-2011).
- Christina Schutt - Executive director of the Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum.
- Darian Woods - Host of NPR's The Indicator podcast.
- Wailin Wong - Host of NPR's The Indicator podcast.
- Julia Richie - Producer of the episode.
- Sophie McArthur - Engineer for the episode.
- Corey Bridges - Fact-checker for the episode.
- Kicking Cannon - Editor for the episode.
Organizations & Institutions
- NPR - Parent organization for the podcasts Short Wave and The Indicator.
- U.S. Mint - Government office responsible for producing and circulating currency.
- Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum - Institution where Robert Wechsler's penny sculpture is displayed and where pennies are given to schoolchildren.
- Wellesley College - Location where Robert Wechsler's penny sculpture is on display.
Websites & Online Resources
- plus.npr.org/shortwave - Website to sign up for Short Wave+ for ad-free listening and support.
- robertwechsler.com - Website showcasing Robert Wechsler's artwork.
- podcastchoices.com/adchoices - Website for information on sponsor message choices.
- npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy - NPR Privacy Policy.
- vanta.com - Website for Vanta, a trust management platform.
- capella.edu - Website for Capella University.
- donorschoose.org/local - Website for DonorsChoose to fund classroom needs.
Other Resources
- Penny - The U.S. one-cent coin, the primary subject of the episode due to its production ending.
- Seigniorage - The profit made by a government when the face value of a coin is more than its production cost.
- Short Wave+ - A premium subscription service from NPR for ad-free listening and bonus episodes.
- FlexPath learning format - A learning format offered by Capella University that allows students to set their own deadlines.