Browns' Coaching Search Hampered by Deshaun Watson Contract Burden - Episode Hero Image

Browns' Coaching Search Hampered by Deshaun Watson Contract Burden

Original Title: Kevin Stefanski FIRED As Browns Head Coach | Where Does Cleveland Go From Here?

TL;DR

  • The Deshaun Watson trade, a product of ownership, has financially crippled the Browns with over $80 million in cap hits, making winning games nearly impossible for the next three years.
  • Firing Kevin Stefanski while retaining GM Andrew Berry signals ownership's responsibility for the Watson trade, leaving Berry to lead a coaching search under significant financial constraints.
  • The Browns' lack of top-50 draft picks from 2022-2024, due to the Watson trade, severely limits their ability to acquire impact players on rookie contracts, hindering competitiveness.
  • Andrew Berry's success in acquiring draft capital and developing talent in previous years suggests he is the right GM to navigate the Browns' rebuild, despite the Watson contract's shadow.
  • The Browns' offensive line is a critical weakness, potentially requiring the replacement of all five starters, necessitating significant draft and free agency investment.
  • Promoting Jim Schwartz to head coach is a plausible, albeit understated, move that maintains defensive continuity and avoids the difficult sell of the current ownership and quarterback situation.
  • The Browns job is a tough sell to top coaching candidates due to the Watson contract anchor and ownership's history of executive overreach, potentially leading to a "retread" hire.

Deep Dive

The Cleveland Browns have fired head coach Kevin Stefanski after a disappointing two-year stretch, marking a significant organizational shift. This decision, however, is overshadowed by the lingering impact of the Deshaun Watson contract, which has financially crippled the franchise and created a difficult environment for any incoming leadership. The Browns' immediate future hinges on GM Andrew Berry's ability to navigate these constraints and rebuild a competitive roster.

The core issue for the Browns is the financial and on-field burden of Deshaun Watson's guaranteed contract. This deal, reportedly an ownership decision rather than one driven by GM Andrew Berry, significantly impacts the team's salary cap by over $80 million in future years, while Watson himself is effectively sidelined. This financial constraint severely limits the team's ability to acquire impact players through free agency or trades, and it has led to a dearth of high draft picks, as evidenced by their lack of selections in the top 50 from 2022-2024. This inability to inject young, cost-controlled talent onto the roster directly correlates with their recent 8-26 record over the past two seasons, making it nearly impossible to win consistently in the NFL.

The implications for the coaching search are profound. The organization's decision to retain GM Andrew Berry, who has a strong track record with draft picks, suggests a belief in his ability to rebuild. However, any prospective head coach must contend with the entrenched Watson contract and the potential for ownership to overrule executive decisions, as seen with the Watson trade itself. This makes the Browns job a difficult sell, particularly for high-demand candidates. Consequently, the Browns may need to consider less conventional options, such as promoting defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz, who has a history with Berry and could provide continuity for an elite defense. Alternatively, they might target a "retread" coach like Mike McCarthy, who can stabilize the team but may not represent a long-term championship solution. The offensive line is identified as a critical area of need, with multiple starters aging or becoming free agents, potentially requiring significant investment in the upcoming draft. The franchise's path forward is thus a multi-year rebuild, heavily dependent on successful draft classes and navigating the financial repercussions of the Watson deal.

Ultimately, the Browns' coaching vacancy is a complex situation where the immediate need for a new leader is complicated by significant long-term financial and structural challenges. While the team possesses an elite defense and a capable GM, the anchor of the Deshaun Watson contract will define the attractiveness of the job and shape the team's competitive window for the foreseeable future.

Action Items

  • Audit offensive line: Identify 3-5 critical positions needing immediate upgrades for the 2026 season.
  • Track draft pick utilization: For the 2022-2024 draft classes, analyze the impact of each pick on team performance.
  • Measure quarterback contract impact: Calculate the percentage of cap space dedicated to the current quarterback contract over the next three seasons.
  • Evaluate GM performance: Assess Andrew Berry's draft and trade history, excluding the Deshaun Watson acquisition, over a 3-5 year period.

Key Quotes

"nfl fans spend an average of 690 minutes a week thinking about football that's over 11 hours you're checking matchups tweaking your fantasy roster reliving big plays arguing calls football lives rent free in your head all week long and when the game's on every decision matters a winning play or the right timeout just 60 seconds can flip the entire outcome but here's the thing off the field we forget to plan we get so caught up in the pre game hype the food the drinks the vibe and forget the most important part of the day how you're getting home you put serious time into your tailgate your outfit your playlist so why not give just one minute to plan a safe ride whether you're hosting heading to a local bar or going to the game make it part of your ritual take a minute make a plan never drive impaired this message was brought to you by diageo mad and the nfl please drink responsibly diageo new york visit takeaminutenow com"

The hosts highlight the intense focus NFL fans have on the sport, dedicating significant time to various aspects of the game. They contrast this deep engagement with a potential oversight in planning for safe transportation after games. This observation underscores the importance of prioritizing safety alongside the enjoyment of football activities.


"welcome into another live edition of pushing the pow brought to you by fanduel sportsbook make every moment more we're coming to you because news dropped monday morning kevin stefanski former head coach of the cleveland browns now out now on his own we we postulated this yesterday with the falcons pod saying that he might be the strongest candidate for an interim head coaching opening that now makes four head coaching openings across the nfl we think it's one of a few names to drop here but 45 and 56 multiple time coach of the year there for the cleveland browns obviously had some of their best success since you know the franchise started again back in the late 90s there in cleveland but the past two seasons 8 and 26 obviously hard to continue with your messaging when you're just not winning football games"

JP Acosta and Mike Renner are reporting on the firing of Kevin Stefanski as the head coach of the Cleveland Browns. They note his previous success, including multiple Coach of the Year awards, but emphasize the recent poor performance with an 8-26 record over the last two seasons. This context sets the stage for discussing the implications of the coaching change.


"yeah it feels like stefanski sort of burnt out towards the end in cleveland i think all the stuff that happened with the watson trade and everything that sort of stemmed from that really became an anchor on stefanski specifically and it just felt like both sides needed to mutually part ways and that's okay sometimes sometimes that stuff happens sometimes you just need to have a change of scenery i do think stefanski's a pretty good coach it's just you know like the browns beat down on you especially if you're not good and especially if you have a contract tied up with a quarterback who actually is not good at football yes"

JP Acosta suggests that Kevin Stefanski may have experienced burnout towards the end of his tenure with the Browns. Acosta believes the circumstances surrounding the Deshaun Watson trade became a significant burden for Stefanski. He posits that a mutual parting of ways was necessary for both Stefanski and the team, indicating that Stefanski is a capable coach but faced difficult conditions.


"and to me the big storyline obviously is that they keep andrew berry as well so they keep gm andrew berry but fire kevin stefanski and say that berry is going to lead the coaching search so obviously they're tied to him long term what that says to me is i think even more confirmation the haslams have never gone out and said it but that to me is confirmation that the deshaun watson trade guaranteed contract all of that was a product of ownership and not andrew berry because if it was andrew berry banging the drum leading the charge saying we got to go out and do this he set your franchise back you know that move has set their franchise back since it's been made five six years i mean truly you cannot win a super bowl with that contract on your books right now"

JP Acosta interprets the decision to retain General Manager Andrew Berry while firing Head Coach Kevin Stefanski as significant. Acosta believes this indicates that the ownership, the Haslams, were the primary drivers behind the Deshaun Watson trade and its associated guaranteed contract, rather than Andrew Berry. He argues that this move has negatively impacted the franchise's long-term prospects.


"yeah i definitely think that this rookie class bought him some more time i mean if you look at what he did with that class outside of um trading for travis hunter you get a whole bunch of picks and you turn it into mason graham who looks like a quality starter you get quinton johnston who looks like a quality starter carson swensen who looks like the defensive rookie of the year already harold fannin jr led all tight ends in receiving yards i believe you have you've those are your first like four or five day two picks and you know like that's building a core that's building a centerpiece for this franchise for years to come and it really is unfortunate for both stefanski and berry that they will have the deshaun watson trade on their resume because it was clear that it was a haslam move it was clear that that's what the ownership wanted so they went out and had to do it and you can tell that neither berry or stefanski actually wanted to make the deal"

JP Acosta credits the Browns' recent rookie class with buying General Manager Andrew Berry more time. Acosta highlights several promising players from this class, such as Mason Graham, Quinton Johnston, and Carson Swensen, suggesting they form a strong core for the franchise's future. He reiterates that the Deshaun Watson trade was an ownership decision, not one made by Berry or Stefanski, and expresses that it's unfortunate this move is on their résumés.


"but until that contract's gone you just you are going to have 8 and 26 over two years you aren't going to win a lot of football games but i do trust in my opinion i think andrew berry is still a very good gm take that move out and just look at draft pick for draft pick trade for trade all the moves he's done how he handles the cap and how he has throughout this i do think he's a good gm it's just that is what's looming over this franchise right now"

JP Acosta asserts that the Browns will struggle to win games until the Deshaun Watson contract is resolved, predicting continued poor performance like an 8-26 record over two years. Despite this, Acosta expresses confidence in Andrew Berry's abilities as a general manager, separate from the Watson situation. He believes Berry has a strong track record in draft picks, trades, and cap management, but acknowledges the Watson contract remains a significant issue for the franchise.

Resources

External Resources

Videos & Documentaries

  • UFC on Paramount+ - Mentioned as the new home of UFC, highlighting its cinematic qualities and storytelling.

Articles & Papers

  • "Episode Title: Kevin Stefanski FIRED As Browns Head Coach | Where Does Cleveland Go From Here?" (Podcast) - The primary subject of the discussion, detailing the firing of Kevin Stefanski and potential future directions for the Cleveland Browns.

People

  • Kevin Stefanski - Former head coach of the Cleveland Browns, discussed in relation to his firing.
  • Andrew Berry - General Manager of the Cleveland Browns, discussed in relation to his retention and leadership of the coaching search.
  • Deshaun Watson - Quarterback for the Cleveland Browns, discussed in relation to his contract and its impact on the team.
  • Mason Graham - Mentioned as a quality starter from the Browns' rookie class.
  • Quinton Johnston - Mentioned as a quality starter from the Browns' rookie class.
  • Carson Swensen - Mentioned as a potential defensive rookie of the year from the Browns' rookie class.
  • Harold Fanin Jr. - Mentioned as a tight end from the Browns' rookie class who led all tight ends in receiving yards.
  • Joel Bitonio - Offensive lineman for the Cleveland Browns, discussed in relation to his age and potential retirement.
  • Jack Conklin - Offensive lineman for the Cleveland Browns, discussed in relation to his age and injury history.
  • Wyatt Teller - Offensive lineman for the Cleveland Browns, discussed as a free agent.
  • Nick Chubb - Mentioned in relation to potential trade rumors or cap casualties.
  • Trevor Grousby - Mentioned as a potential offensive tackle draft pick for the Browns.
  • Max Icho - Mentioned as a potential offensive tackle draft pick for the Browns.
  • Jim Schwartz - Mentioned as a potential candidate for the Browns' head coaching position, former head coach of the Lions.
  • Mike McCarthy - Mentioned as a potential head coach retread candidate for the Browns.
  • Mike Vrabel - Mentioned in relation to the Tennessee Titans and becoming a GM.
  • Jeff Hafley - Mentioned as a potential candidate for the Browns' head coaching position, Packers defensive coordinator.
  • Michael Parsons - Mentioned as a superstar pass rusher with whom Jeff Hafley has worked.
  • Miles Garrett - Defensive player for the Cleveland Browns, discussed as the best defensive player in the world.

Organizations & Institutions

  • NFL (National Football League) - The professional American football league, discussed in relation to fan engagement and team operations.
  • Cleveland Browns - The professional American football team, the central subject of the discussion regarding coaching changes and team performance.
  • Diageo - Mentioned in relation to a responsible drinking message.
  • Falcons - Mentioned in relation to a previous podcast discussion about potential interim head coaching openings.
  • Texans - Mentioned in relation to their success attributed to the trade of draft picks from the Browns.
  • Lions - Mentioned in relation to Jim Schwartz's past coaching tenure.
  • Kansas City - Mentioned in relation to potential coaching hires for the Titans.
  • Philadelphia - Mentioned in relation to the working relationship between Jim Schwartz and Andrew Berry.
  • Green Bay Packers - Mentioned in relation to Jeff Hafley's role as defensive coordinator.

Tools & Software

  • Thumbtack - Mentioned as a service for hiring home professionals and addressing home projects.
  • FanDuel Sportsbook - Mentioned as a sponsor of the podcast.

Websites & Online Resources

  • takeaminutenow.com - Mentioned in relation to planning a safe ride home.

Other Resources

  • Fantasy Roster - Mentioned in the context of NFL fans' engagement.
  • Guaranteed Contracts - Discussed in relation to quarterback contracts and their impact on NFL teams.
  • Cap Hits - Mentioned in relation to the financial implications of player contracts for the Browns.
  • Rookie Contract Span - Discussed in relation to the impact of having players on rookie deals.
  • Offensive Line - Discussed as a significant need for the Cleveland Browns.
  • Mock Draft - Mentioned in relation to predictions for the Browns' draft picks.

---
Handpicked links, AI-assisted summaries. Human judgment, machine efficiency.
This content is a personally curated review and synopsis derived from the original podcast episode.