21st-Century Authoritarianism Hollows Out "Zombie Democracies" - Episode Hero Image

21st-Century Authoritarianism Hollows Out "Zombie Democracies"

Offline with Jon Favreau · · Listen to Original Episode →
Original Title:

TL;DR

  • 21st-century authoritarianism erodes democratic checks and balances through gradual institutional co-option, rather than overt force, making it harder for citizens to recognize and resist.
  • The decline of American democracy stems from a confluence of economic stratification, rapid cultural shifts, and the amplification of extreme voices by social media.
  • A "zombie democracy" persists with a veneer of freedom, but its institutions are gradually hollowed out, leaving citizens disengaged and susceptible to authoritarian appeals.
  • Addressing the erosion of democracy requires more than political tactics; it necessitates practicing and re-learning "habits of the heart" like restraint, tolerance, and mutual recognition.
  • The appeal of authoritarianism, particularly to younger generations, lies in its promise of decisive action and a grand cause, contrasting with democracy's perceived boredom and slow progress.
  • Reinvigorating American democracy requires a hopeful narrative rooted in equality and commonality, challenging the divisive identity politics prevalent on both the left and the right.
  • Technological advancements like AI, driven by a belief in elegant solutions and impatience with human messiness, risk further isolating individuals and undermining democratic engagement.

Deep Dive

The core argument is that American democracy is experiencing a "zombie" state, characterized by a veneer of freedom masking an erosion of institutional checks on power, making it susceptible to 21st-century authoritarianism. This decline is not solely attributable to Donald Trump but stems from deeper systemic issues, including economic inequality, rapid cultural change, and the corrosive effects of social media, which collectively foster alienation and cynicism. The future of American democracy hinges on a renewed commitment to its founding ideals of equality and common humanity, offering a compelling counter-narrative to the divisive and nihilistic appeals emerging from the right.

The implications of this "zombie democracy" are profound, extending beyond immediate political concerns to the fundamental fabric of American society. The gradual erosion of checks on power, as detailed by George Packer, means that institutions like Congress, the Justice Department, and the courts are increasingly co-opted or ineffective, allowing leaders to operate with fewer constraints. This creates a dangerous environment where the leader's whims and grievances can dictate policy, and dissent is suppressed not through overt force but through the weakening of democratic mechanisms. The populace, bombarded by noise and distracted by personal concerns, often fails to perceive this erosion until it directly impacts their lives, leading to a paralysis that further entrenches the authoritarian drift.

The roots of this susceptibility are multifaceted. Economically, the shift from an industrial to a knowledge economy has created stark divisions between those with college degrees and those without, leaving many feeling left behind and disenfranchised. Culturally, rapid changes in social norms, identity, and immigration have, for some, created a sense of dispossession and a longing for a perceived past. More recently, social media platforms, driven by profit motives, have amplified extreme voices and fostered division, exacerbating these fissures. These forces have created a "cold civil war" where alienation and cynicism about elites, business, government, and media are rampant, making citizens less likely to believe in the possibility of collective action or a better future.

The future trajectory of American democracy is contested. On the right, there is a growing appetite for national conservatism, which Packer describes as fundamentally anti-democratic, advocating for executive power and the erosion of individual rights and objective truth. Figures like J.D. Vance embody this trend, promoting an ideology that seeks to define America in exclusionary terms. This presents a stark contrast to the ideals of liberal democracy, which champions equality, due process, and inclusivity. The challenge for Democrats and proponents of liberal democracy is to articulate a compelling, hopeful narrative of "equal America" that can counter the divisive appeals from the right, moving beyond mere political tactics to re-cultivate the "habits of the heart" -- restraint, responsibility, and tolerance -- that Tocqueville identified as essential for democratic life.

Ultimately, the path forward requires not just electoral victories but a cultural and moral renewal. The pervasive influence of technology, particularly AI, poses a new and significant threat, offering further avenues for escape from human connection and the complexities of democratic engagement. Packer argues that a commitment to practiced democracy, face-to-face interaction, and a recognition of shared humanity is crucial. This involves moving beyond identity politics in both parties and embracing a vision of America rooted in the promise of equality and opportunity, one that can inspire collective action and reaffirm belief in the possibility of a more just and unified nation.

Action Items

  • Audit the "zombie democracy" framework: Identify 3-5 specific institutional checks on power that have eroded and propose measurable metrics to track their restoration.
  • Draft a "habits of the heart" framework: Define 3-5 actionable practices for fostering civic engagement and mutual respect in face-to-face interactions, distinct from online discourse.
  • Analyze the roots of democratic susceptibility: Identify 3-5 key societal factors (e.g., economic shifts, cultural change, social media impact) that made the US vulnerable to authoritarianism, as discussed by Packer.
  • Create a narrative strategy for "Equal America": Develop 3-5 core messaging pillars that counter divisive rhetoric by emphasizing shared values and aspirational commonality, distinct from identity politics.

Related Episodes

Key Quotes

"We are living in an authoritarian state for people who haven't read it why do you think that I just went through all the sort of boxes of things that could check the power of the leader so it's not authoritarian in the sense that we have jackbooted troops marching through the streets the offices of the Atlantic are not being raided our computers aren't being smashed so it doesn't look like what you might call 20th century authoritarianism it looks more like 21st century authoritarianism which is a sort of veneer of democracy and of freedom but gradually an erosion of all the ways in which the citizenry and the institutions can check the power of the leader."

George Packer argues that the United States is experiencing a form of 21st-century authoritarianism, which differs from historical models. Packer explains that this modern authoritarianism operates with a facade of democracy and freedom, while subtly undermining the checks and balances that citizens and institutions have on a leader's power. This erosion occurs through the co-opting of institutions like Congress, the Justice Department, and the courts, creating a system where the leader's will gradually supersedes democratic norms.

"I think it doesn't feel like it because most Americans are lucky enough not to encounter it in their personal lives most Americans are not undocumented immigrants who might be swept up off the street or show up to a court appointment and get taken away by ICE most Americans um are not getting sued by the president because they're publishing things that he doesn't like so it's where where there's just this big distracted divided um commercially minded busy noisy country and it takes a lot to break through the noise of our lives so that we can actually see clearly those things that I talked about a minute ago if they're not hitting you in the face I think there's a human temptation just to say well how bad can it be it's never happened before."

George Packer suggests that the abstract nature of authoritarianism prevents many Americans from recognizing it in their daily lives. Packer explains that unless individuals directly experience the oppressive actions of such a regime, like being targeted by immigration authorities or legal challenges for their speech, they may dismiss the severity of the situation. The sheer volume of daily distractions and the comfort of routine lead to a human tendency to underestimate threats that have not yet personally impacted them.

"I would say there are three reasons and they go back to the 70s some of them the end of the industrial economy and the rise of the knowledge economy which created categories of winners and losers that were more extreme than anything we'd seen since before the great depression so college degree that's the big dividing line if you're comfortable with symbols with words with computers you have a future in this country if you're in a rural area in a small town in an industrial town if your industry is leaving if you've been working with your hands all your life if you didn't go to college or even finish high school decade after decade your chances are bleaker and bleaker."

George Packer identifies the end of the industrial economy and the rise of the knowledge economy as a primary cause for the susceptibility to authoritarianism. Packer explains that this shift created a stark division between those with college degrees, who are comfortable with symbolic and digital work, and those in rural or industrial areas whose traditional jobs have disappeared. This growing economic disparity has left many feeling left behind and vulnerable, contributing to a sense of alienation.

"The second is cultural change dramatic cultural change beginning I would say with the 60s and the late 60s the immigrant the change in immigration laws that brought in large numbers of people from the global south in a phrase changes in family in rights in sexual mores in identity groups which gave some people a place at the table for the first time so not bad good but over time the speed of it the the scale of it made other people feel as if their America was disappearing and that they were somehow not count not counted not respected."

George Packer points to dramatic cultural shifts, beginning in the late 1960s, as another significant factor contributing to societal division. Packer elaborates that changes in immigration, family structures, rights, and identity groups, while offering inclusion to some, have also made others feel that their traditional understanding of America is disappearing. This perception of loss and lack of respect can foster resentment and a desire for a return to a perceived past.

"And then the third is more recent and it's social media which has because of the greed and wickedness of the tech oligarchs to be blunt about it has has driven us to our worst selves because that's what keeps us glued to the to the screen and that's what you know amplifies the the most extreme and um you know hateful voices and those three things together created a kind of cold civil war that is sort of a class war between the educated less educated urban rural it's sort of a generational war by the way this is what I don't know if we're going to get to talk about it but this is what my my new novel is all about it is about class and generational conflict but in a allegorical story the emergency."

George Packer attributes a third factor to the rise of social media, driven by the motivations of tech leaders. Packer explains that social media platforms, by design, amplify extreme and hateful voices to maintain user engagement, thereby exacerbating societal divisions. He argues that these three forces--economic disparity, cultural change, and social media--have collectively created a "cold civil war" characterized by class, urban-rural, and generational conflicts.

"I think the most compelling narrative to sustain American democracy has to be rooted in a commitment to equality back to the declaration back to Lincoln and I wonder if you think that you know equal America still has a chance against zombie democracy."

George Packer suggests that a narrative centered on a commitment to equality, referencing the Declaration of Independence and Abraham Lincoln, is essential for sustaining American democracy. Packer questions whether this vision of an "equal America" can still contend with the challenges posed by what he terms "zombie democracy." He implies that the current state of democracy is weakened and perhaps only a strong appeal to foundational ideals can revitalize it.

Resources

External Resources

Books

  • "The Emergency" by George Packer - Mentioned as his latest work of fiction, which explores themes of societal collapse and the emergence of new political movements.
  • "The Unwinding" by George Packer - Mentioned as a book that portrayed a landscape where a figure like Trump was conceivable, highlighting alienation, cynicism, and the decline of institutional foundations for middle-class life.

Articles & Papers

  • "America's Zombie Democracy" (The Atlantic) - Mentioned as a piece that argues the United States is experiencing a form of 21st-century authoritarianism through the gradual erosion of checks on a leader's power.

People

  • George Packer - Author and staff writer for The Atlantic, featured as a guest to discuss his writings on American democracy, authoritarianism, and societal issues.
  • Donald Trump - Mentioned as a political figure whose presidency and political movement are central to the discussion of contemporary American politics and the future of democracy.
  • J.D. Vance - Mentioned as an early frontrunner for a post-Trump political vision, characterized by a nationalist ideology that is seen as anti-democratic.
  • Stephen Miller - Quoted as having said "America is for Americans and Americans only," representing a specific ideological stance.
  • Charlie Kirk - Mentioned as a figure who could potentially galvanize young people with a mix of Christianity, nationalism, and self-improvement.
  • Vivek Ramaswamy - Mentioned for contesting the "blood and soil nationalism" embraced by J.D. Vance in a New York Times piece.
  • Peter Thiel - Mentioned as an influence on J.D. Vance's political evolution.
  • Reverend Marian Edgar Buddy - Episcopal bishop of Washington, mentioned for delivering a sermon at the National Cathedral that called for mercy and unity, which reportedly angered the President and Vice President.
  • Sam Altman - Mentioned in the context of AI, specifically for his hypothetical idea of an AI president and his views on technology's role in society.
  • Gavin Newsom - Mentioned for having published a book about improving government through technology in the early 2010s.
  • Ben Horowitz - Partner of Marc Andreessen, quoted as having discussed the similarity between Marxists and libertarians in their belief in perfect systems.
  • Marc Andreessen - Mentioned in the context of Silicon Valley's views on regulation and government.
  • Neil Postman - Mentioned in relation to his warning in "Amusing Ourselves to Death" about entertainment and performance leading to passivity.
  • Toby Ziegler - Mentioned as a character in "The West Wing" who discussed the importance of patriotism rooted in founding ideals.
  • Barack Obama - Mentioned for a patriotic speech at the 2004 convention, rooted in the founding ideals of the country.
  • Abraham Lincoln - Mentioned in relation to the ideal of equality in America.
  • Thomas Jefferson - Mentioned in relation to the ideals expressed in the Declaration of Independence.
  • Victor Orban - Mentioned as a comparison point for the speed at which authoritarianism has been implemented.
  • Nick Fuentes - Mentioned as a figure associated with extreme right-wing ideologies.
  • Tucker Carlson - Mentioned as a figure associated with extreme right-wing ideologies.
  • Bronze Age Pervert - Mentioned as a figure associated with extreme right-wing ideologies.
  • Raw Egg Nationalist - Mentioned as a figure associated with extreme right-wing ideologies.
  • Francis Fukuyama - Mentioned for his essay "The End of History" and the idea that liberal democracies face the challenge of boredom.
  • John Dewey - Mentioned for his belief that democracy is not just a system of government but a way of life.
  • Alexis de Tocqueville - Mentioned for his observations on the "habits of the heart" necessary for democracy and the idea that democracy is not natural.

Organizations & Institutions

  • The Atlantic - Publication where George Packer's article "America's Zombie Democracy" appeared.
  • Cards Against Humanity - Mentioned as a company that engages in political stunts and sells games.
  • Crooked Media - Mentioned as the producer of the podcast "Offline with Jon Favreau" and other shows.
  • Turning Point USA - Organization associated with Charlie Kirk, mentioned in the context of galvanizing young people.
  • The Claremont Institute - Mentioned in relation to a speech by J.D. Vance.
  • The New Yorker - Publication where George Packer previously worked as a journalist.
  • The Episcopal Church - Denomination of Reverend Marian Edgar Buddy.
  • The White House - Mentioned in the context of the President's interactions and the administration.
  • The Supreme Court - Mentioned as an institution that should challenge executive power but may not be doing so.
  • The Justice Department - Mentioned as a tool of the President's whims and grievances.
  • The military - Mentioned as becoming more partisan.
  • The Republican Party - Mentioned as a tool of a cult of personality and in relation to elections.
  • The Democratic Party - Mentioned in relation to its role in power and its approach to messaging.
  • The National Football League (NFL) - Mentioned in the context of sports analytics.
  • Pro Football Focus (PFF) - Mentioned as a data source for player grading.
  • New England Patriots - Mentioned as an example team for performance analysis.
  • ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) - Mentioned in the context of potential actions against undocumented immigrants.
  • The House of Representatives - Mentioned in relation to revolting over issues like healthcare and the Epstein files.
  • State Street Investment Management - Sponsor of ETFs like MDY and DIA.
  • Alps Distributors Inc. - Distributor for State Street ETFs.
  • Progressive Commercial Insurance - Sponsor offering commercial auto insurance.
  • Zbiotics - Sponsor offering a pre-alcohol probiotic.
  • Squarespace - Sponsor offering an all-in-one website platform.

Websites & Online Resources

  • nakedwines.com - Website for a wine club, offered as a sponsor with a discount code.
  • statestreet.com/im - Website for State Street Investment Management, providing information on ETFs.
  • squarespace.com - Website for Squarespace, offering a free trial and discount for first-time purchasers.
  • crooked.com/friends - Website for subscribing to "Friend of the Pod" and other Crooked Media content.
  • zbiotics.com - Website for Zbiotics, offering a pre-alcohol probiotic with a discount code.
  • brainhealthmatters.com - Website for information on brain health and dementia risk factors.

Other Resources

  • Cards Against Humanity Tails - A game mentioned by the sponsor Cards Against Humanity.
  • Shitlist - A game mentioned by the sponsor Cards Against Humanity.
  • Party Mouth - A game mentioned by the sponsor Cards Against Humanity.
  • MAGA - Mentioned as a political movement.
  • AI (Artificial Intelligence) - Discussed as a transformative technology with potential implications for governance and humanity.
  • MDY (Mid-Cap ETF) - An ETF from State Street Investment Management.
  • DIA (Dow Jones Industrial Average ETF) - An ETF from State Street Investment Management.
  • The Declaration of Independence - Mentioned as a foundational document asserting innate human equality and dignity.
  • The Emergency - George Packer's latest novel, a political fable.
  • The Last Best Hope - An essay by George Packer that became a short book, focusing on the narrative of equality for American democracy.
  • Amusing Ourselves to Death - A concept from Neil Postman's work, discussed in relation to entertainment and passivity.
  • Zombie Democracy - A concept from George Packer's article, describing a state with a veneer of democracy but an erosion of checks on power.
  • National Conservatism - An ideology discussed in relation to J.D. Vance, characterized as fundamentally anti-democratic.
  • Christianity - Mentioned as a component of Charlie Kirk's appeal.
  • Nationalism - Mentioned as a component of Charlie Kirk's appeal and J.D. Vance's ideology.
  • Self-improvement - Mentioned as a component of Charlie Kirk's appeal.
  • Liberal Democracy - Discussed as a system of government facing challenges from authoritarianism and boredom.
  • Fascism - Mentioned as a historical ideology, contrasted with contemporary right-wing movements.
  • White Christian Identity Politics - Mentioned as a form of identity politics practiced by the right.
  • Friend of the Pod Subscription - A subscription service offered by Crooked Media.
  • Dan Show Polar Coaster - An exclusive show behind the paywall of Friend of the Pod.
  • Progressive Commercial Insurance - Mentioned as a type of insurance for business owners.
  • Dementia - Mentioned in the context of brain health and risk factors.
  • Alzheimer's Disease - Mentioned as a condition related to dementia.
  • Cognitive Assessment - Mentioned as a tool for assessing brain health.

---
Handpicked links, AI-assisted summaries. Human judgment, machine efficiency.
This content is a personally curated review and synopsis derived from the original podcast episode.