Autonomous Vehicle Safety Outperforms Human Drivers Dramatically
TL;DR
- Waymo's autonomous vehicles demonstrate a 91% reduction in serious injury crashes and a 96% lower rate of intersection injury crashes compared to human drivers, suggesting a significant public health benefit and a case for accelerating self-driving technology adoption.
- Relaxing federal fuel economy standards to 34 mpg from 50 mpg incentivizes automakers to prioritize high-profit, less efficient SUVs and trucks, potentially increasing long-term consumer fuel costs and ceding global EV market share to China.
- Spotify Wrapped's success lies in its data-driven marketing tactic, leveraging personal listening habits to create shareable, provocative metrics like "listening age" that drive user engagement and organic social media promotion.
- Bending Spoons employs a "PE rollup" strategy by acquiring underperforming but recognized internet companies, rebuilding them with aggressive feature shipping and price increases, aiming for long-term ownership akin to an "internet era Berkshire Hathaway."
- The Marchetti constant suggests that human travel time is capped at approximately 78 minutes daily, meaning transportation efficiency gains lead to expanded urban sprawl rather than reduced commute times, potentially indicating a limit to current urban expansion.
- Boston's rental market decline, with vacancies rising to their highest since the pandemic, signals broader economic headwinds impacting biotech funding and university enrollment, forcing landlords to lower prices and accept less traditional tenants.
Deep Dive
The discussion begins with Spotify Wrapped, noting that 511,000 different people listened to the podcast, with 240,000 new listeners joining. These listeners collectively spent 286 million minutes with the hosts, and the podcast was a top five show for 239,000 listeners, and number one for 87,000. The source then transitions to a discussion about former President Trump's proposal to slash federal fuel economy rules for passenger vehicles. This action aims to roll back a Biden-era policy that incentivized electric vehicle production, with the administration stating the plan, effective next year, will drive down car prices. Under Biden's previous measure, carmakers were required to average about 50 miles per gallon by model year 2031, but Trump's plan reduces this to 34 miles per gallon. The oil industry and automakers, represented by the CEOs of Ford and Stellantis flanking Trump at the announcement, celebrated this move, viewing Biden's rules as overbearing and out of step with consumer demand for EVs and hybrids. Environmentalists, conversely, reacted negatively, predicting more gas-guzzling cars and increased fuel costs for consumers over the lifetime of their vehicles. Critics also suggested this change signals the U.S. falling behind China in the global EV race. The source elaborates that this policy shift allows automakers to return to producing more profitable pickup trucks and SUVs, which consumers favor in the U.S. While General Motors' CEO Mary Barra stated a continued commitment to EVs, the economic reality suggests a focus on larger, more expensive vehicles. The risk identified is vulnerability to gasoline price shocks, especially since the current price per gallon has fallen to $2.99, a significant drop from previous highs. If oil prices increase, consumers of non-EVs and hybrids will face higher bills. However, a counterargument presented is that these new standards reflect actual demand, and if gas prices rise, consumers might shift back to EVs, allowing the market to dictate demand. The source also notes that U.S. car sales are stagnant, and reliance on the top 20% of households purchasing expensive vehicles could be problematic if economic shocks occur.
Moving to a different topic, the podcast then revisits Spotify Wrapped, now in its 11th edition. New features this year included showing the number of times each favorite song was listened to and a collaborative Wrapped mode for comparing stats with friends. A standout feature highlighted is the listener age, assigned based on music eras users favored. The design aesthetic shifted back to an analog, hand-drawn style, contrasting with last year's tech-focused theme, which received positive reviews. The source analyzes Spotify Wrapped as a successful marketing tactic that collects data and presents users with shareable, provocative metrics like listening age, which is derived from analyzing a five-year span of music engagement within an age group. The hosts share their own listening ages: one host's was 92, attributed to listening to classical music recorded in the 1940s and 1950s, and the other's was 67, influenced by listening to Billie Holiday. An interesting design shift noted is the move from a story feature to a vertical feed resembling TikTok, seen as a reflection of current UX trends. Globally, Bad Bunny was the most played artist for the fourth time, dethroning Taylor Swift, and also had the most streamed album, "De Vuelta a la Vida." In the U.S., Morgan Wallen's "I'm the Problem" was the most streamed album, and "Die With a Smile" by Bruno Mars and Lady Gaga was the biggest song worldwide.
The discussion then shifts to the Italian private equity firm Bending Spoons, which has been acquiring internet companies. Their latest acquisition is the events platform Eventbrite for $500 million. Bending Spoons' strategy involves identifying businesses with strong name recognition and cash flow but stagnant growth, purchasing them at a low price, laying off most staff, bringing in a team of young Italian coders, and rapidly shipping new features to restart growth. CEO Luca Ferrari aims to unlock the "unexpressed potential of unsexy businesses." The company invests for long-term growth, intending to hold acquisitions indefinitely. Bending Spoons has raised significant funding, including $270 million in a recent round valuing them at over $11 billion and $2.8 billion in debt financing. An example of their approach is their acquisition of Evernote, where they reportedly fired over half the staff, steeply increased prices by 63% for personal plans, and shut down U.S. operations to move them to Europe, rebuilding the tech from the ground up. While some, like a former Evernote co-founder, are satisfied with the platform's improvements, others are reportedly upset by price increases. Ferrari dismisses negative feedback from satisfied users as "noise," focusing instead on the price ceiling. The name "Bending Spoons" is derived from a scene in "The Matrix."
Next, the podcast presents "Neal's Numbers," beginning with safety statistics for Waymo's self-driving cars. In data covering 100 million driverless miles across four American cities, Waymo's autonomous cars were involved in 91% fewer serious injury or worse crashes compared to human drivers, 80% fewer crashes causing any injury, and a 96% lower rate of injury-causing crashes at intersections. Neurosurgeon Dr. Jonathan Slotin argues this presents an overwhelming benefit, suggesting that if this were a medical trial, it would be stopped early and the treatment (Waymo) would be adopted. The source frames this as a public health issue, advocating for support of self-driving technology. It's also noted that Waymo has adjusted its software in San Francisco to be more "confidently assertive" drivers, leading to more assertive lane changes and maneuvers, which executives claim can be safer by preventing traffic buildup.
The second number discusses the Boston real estate market, where the average asking rent fell to approximately $3,000 in October, the first decline since 2021, with vacancies rising to their highest rate since the pandemic. This is attributed to economic struggles in Boston, with biotech funding drying up due to high interest rates and a decrease in international students impacting universities. Landlords are reportedly resorting to lowering prices, allowing pets, and accepting undergraduate renters. While Boston has added housing units, the price decreases are attributed to multiple factors beyond supply. The source notes that a quarter of Boston renters were spending over half their salaries on housing.
The final number focuses on global travel habits, citing an international study across 43 countries that found people travel approximately 78 minutes per day, regardless of location, wealth, or transportation mode. This "78-minute rule" has implications for urban planners. The author Eric Goldbarth suggests that increased speed or efficiency in travel does not lead to less travel time but rather greater distances traveled, citing the growth of suburbs after the automobile's introduction. This concept is linked to the Marchetti constant, which posits that urban life is dictated by technology enabling a 30-minute commute, influencing city sizes throughout history, from walking-based cities to those
Action Items
- Audit Waymo safety data: Analyze 100 million driverless miles for 3 injury-causing crash types compared to human drivers.
- Measure Boston rent decline: Track average asking rent and vacancy rates across 5 key neighborhoods for 3 months.
- Analyze travel time consistency: Calculate average daily commute for 5 diverse countries using 78-minute travel rule data.
- Evaluate Bending Spoons acquisition strategy: Identify 3-5 acquired companies and analyze feature shipping rate post-acquisition.
- Track Spotify Wrapped engagement: Measure social media shares and user comments for 3-5 new Wrapped features.
Key Quotes
"In data covering 100 million driverless miles in four American cities, Waymo's autonomous cars were involved in 91 fewer serious injury or worse crashes than human drivers on the same roads. Waymo's were involved in 80 fewer crashes causing any injury and a 96% lower rate of injury causing crashes at intersections."
Neil Fryman highlights these statistics to demonstrate the significant safety advantages of Waymo's self-driving cars compared to human drivers. He presents this data as evidence that autonomous vehicles could be a major public health breakthrough by reducing traffic-related injuries and fatalities.
"The administration touted the plan which will go into effect next year as a way to drive down car prices when the cost of new vehicles crossed $50,000 for the first time ever in October. Under Biden's measure, carmakers needed to average about 50 miles a gallon for vehicles by model year 2031. Trump's plan cuts that to just 34."
This quote explains the core of the policy change regarding fuel economy standards. The author details the reduction in the required average miles per gallon for vehicles, contrasting the Trump administration's goal of lowering car prices with the Biden administration's previous incentive for electric vehicle production.
"The company goes by the name of Bending Spoons, a tech conglomerate that thinks it stumbled upon the next great PE rollup strategy. Bending Spoons was born 12 years ago after the founders of a failed scrapbooking app pivoted to acquiring online businesses and completely rebuilding them."
This passage introduces Bending Spoons and its unique business model. The author explains that the company acquires established but underperforming internet businesses and aims to revitalize them through a strategic rebuilding process, likening their approach to a private equity rollup strategy.
"The most important finding is that people don't travel less when speed or efficiency increases; instead, they travel farther. You saw this with the growth of the suburbs after the automobile came along; people could commute faster in a car than a trolley, so they moved further away from their workplace."
The author uses this quote to illustrate the "78-minute rule" and its implications for urban planning. He explains that increased transportation efficiency does not necessarily lead to shorter travel times but rather to longer commutes as people choose to live further from their workplaces.
"The contract between the Malaysian government and Ocean Infinity is a no find, no fee structure. If they don't find MH370, they get paid zilch. If they do locate it, they'll be cut a check for $70 million."
This quote outlines the financial agreement for the search for Malaysia Airlines Flight 370. The author clarifies the "no find, no fee" model, emphasizing that Ocean Infinity will only be compensated if they successfully locate the missing aircraft, highlighting the high stakes of the operation.
"The forecast in Des Moines, Iowa, today is a high of 14 degrees Fahrenheit, which is approaching an 1886 record. In total, we're on low temperature record watch in 14 states."
This quote provides a specific example of the extreme cold affecting the United States. The author uses the Des Moines temperature and the mention of record-breaking potential across multiple states to illustrate the severity of the historic cold snap.
Resources
External Resources
Books
- "The Matrix" - Mentioned as the origin of the name "Bending Spoons"
Articles & Papers
- "Marketing Brew article" (Marketing Brew) - Discussed as a source for information on Amazon Ads solutions
- "Bloomberg piece" (Bloomberg) - Profiled a landlord in Boston discussing the real estate market
- "New York Times piece" (The New York Times) - Presented safety facts about Waymo's self-driving cars
Research & Studies
- International study on personal and work-related travel (43 countries) - Found that populations travel approximately 78 minutes per day regardless of location or wealth
Tools & Software
- Waymo - Discussed for its safety record in self-driving cars and software updates for assertiveness
- Amazon Ads solutions - Mentioned for helping brands reach customers across various platforms
- NetSuite - Described as an AI cloud ERP for businesses
- Vanguard bonds - Referenced for institutional quality bond funds
People
- Neal Fryman - Host of Morning Brew Daily
- Toby Howell - Host of Morning Brew Daily
- Luca Ferrari - CEO of Bending Spoons
- Dr. Jonathan Slotkin - Neurosurgeon, author of a New York Times piece on Waymo safety
- Eric Schmidt - Former leader of Google, investor in Bending Spoons
- Andre Agassi - Celebrity investor in Bending Spoons
- Ryan Reynolds - Celebrity investor in Bending Spoons
- The Weeknd - Celebrity investor in Bending Spoons
- Mary Barra - CEO of General Motors
- Taylor Swift - Mentioned in relation to Spotify Wrapped and global music streams
- Bad Bunny - Mentioned as the most played artist globally on Spotify
- Morgan Wallen - Mentioned for having the most streamed album in the US
- Bruno Mars - Mentioned for the song "Die with a Smile"
- Lady Gaga - Mentioned for the song "Die with a Smile"
- Billy Holiday - Mentioned in relation to listening age on Spotify
- Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - Mentioned in relation to listening age on Spotify
- Travis Kelce - Mentioned in relation to cold weather in Kansas City
- Taylor Swift - Mentioned in relation to cold weather in Kansas City
- Emily Millian - Executive Producer of Morning Brew
- Raymond Lu - Producer of Morning Brew
- Olivia Graham - Associate Producer of Morning Brew
- Olivia Lake - Associate Producer of Morning Brew
- Shiffon Up - Hair and makeup for Morning Brew
- Devin Emery - President of Morning Brew
Organizations & Institutions
- Morning Brew Daily - Podcast discussed for its listener statistics and content
- LinkedIn Ads - Advertised as a platform for B2B return on ad spend
- Ford - Mentioned in relation to the US government's fuel economy standards
- Stellantis - Mentioned in relation to the US government's fuel economy standards
- General Motors (GM) - Mentioned in relation to the US government's fuel economy standards and EV commitments
- Spotify - Discussed for its "Wrapped" feature and listener data
- Bending Spoons - Tech conglomerate acquiring online businesses
- Eventbrite - Acquired by Bending Spoons
- AOL - Mentioned as an acquired company by Bending Spoons
- Vimeo - Mentioned as an acquired company by Bending Spoons
- Evernote - Acquired and rebuilt by Bending Spoons
- WeTransfer - Mentioned as an acquired company by Bending Spoons
- Oracle - Parent company of NetSuite
- Vanguard Marketing Corporation - Distributor of Vanguard financial advisors
- Ocean Infinity - Marine robotics company searching for Malaysia Airlines Flight 370
- Malaysia Airlines - Mentioned in relation to Flight 370
- Boeing - Manufacturer of the 777 aircraft
- The Matrix - Film referenced for the origin of the name "Bending Spoons"
Websites & Online Resources
- linkedin.com/mbd - URL for more information related to Morning Brew Daily
- marketingbrew.com - Website mentioned for a marketing brew article
- swap.fm/l/mbd-note - URL to listen to Morning Brew Daily
- youtube.com/@MorningBrewDailyShow - URL to watch Morning Brew Daily
- megaphone.fm/adchoices - URL for ad choices information
- linkedin.com - Website mentioned for LinkedIn Ads
- vanguard.com/audio - URL for Vanguard financial advisor information
- netsuite.com/brew - URL for a free business guide on demystifying AI
Podcasts & Audio
- Morning Brew Daily - Podcast discussed for its content and listener statistics
Other Resources
- Spotify Wrapped - Annual feature providing user listening statistics
- Marchetti Constant - Concept explaining urban life dictated by technology enabling a 30-minute commute
- Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 (MH370) - Disappeared aircraft, subject of a renewed search
- Polar Vortex disruption - Atmospheric phenomenon causing cold snaps in the US
- Self-driving cars - Discussed as a potential public health breakthrough
- Fuel efficiency standards - US government regulations discussed in relation to vehicle production