JMI NIL Deal Hinders Elite Basketball Recruiting Amidst Leadership Uncertainty
TL;DR
- The JMI NIL deal, designed to benefit most athletes, currently hinders elite basketball recruits by potentially restricting their ability to sign with non-UK affiliated partners, leading to recruitment struggles.
- Mitch Barnhart's interview with the Herald Leader, while lengthy, failed to directly answer critical questions about the JMI deal's impact on recruiting and his own future as AD.
- UK's decision to bring NIL operations in-house and eliminate private collectives, based on an assumption that the Score Act would outlaw them, may have negatively impacted their ability to secure top recruits.
- The lack of clarity and direct answers regarding the JMI deal and Barnhart's contract status creates confusion and uncertainty, potentially harming the university's athletic program.
- While the JMI deal benefits the majority of student-athletes, its current structure appears to be a significant impediment for high-profile recruits, raising questions about its long-term viability.
Deep Dive
Kentucky Sports Radio's discussion centers on athletic director Mitch Barnhart's recent interview with the Lexington Herald Leader and its implications for the university's recruiting and NIL (Name, Image, and Likeness) strategies. The core argument is that Barnhart's interview, while lengthy, failed to provide clear answers to critical questions, particularly regarding the university's NIL deal with JMI and its impact on securing top basketball recruits, suggesting a disconnect between the university's approach and the competitive landscape of college sports.
The implications are significant for Kentucky's ability to attract and retain elite talent. Barnhart's explanation of the JMI deal, which consolidated NIL activities in-house after dismantling private collectives, was perceived as overly complex and lacking directness. This lack of clarity, especially concerning whether the deal restricts recruits from signing NIL agreements with non-UK affiliated partners, is directly linked to the recent withdrawal of recruiting commitments from highly sought-after players like Christian Collins and Tyren Stokes. The analysis suggests that while the JMI deal may benefit the majority of student-athletes with less market value, it appears to be a significant impediment for those with high NIL potential, creating a competitive disadvantage compared to other "blue blood" programs that have already secured their top recruits. This situation raises concerns about whether the current NIL structure is sustainable for attracting top-tier talent and whether the university will need to modify its approach or make exceptions for elite recruits to remain competitive.
Furthermore, Barnhart's ambiguous response to questions about his own future as athletic director, citing contract length and a desire to "win some more things," adds another layer of uncertainty. This lack of decisive communication mirrors the opacity surrounding the NIL strategy, potentially creating instability and affecting the confidence of coaches, players, and recruits. The takeaway is that Kentucky's current NIL framework, as explained by Barnhart, is perceived as a barrier to recruiting elite basketball talent, and the continued lack of clear answers from leadership creates a risk of falling behind in a rapidly evolving college sports environment.
Action Items
- Audit JMI NIL deal: Identify specific clauses restricting elite basketball recruits from signing NIL deals with non-UK affiliated partners.
- Analyze NIL deal impact: For 3-5 recent elite basketball recruits, calculate the correlation between their NIL deal restrictions and their decision to commit elsewhere.
- Draft NIL exception policy: Propose a framework for making exceptions to the JMI deal for elite athletes without compromising the existing structure for 97% of student-athletes.
- Evaluate JMI deal modification: Determine if the JMI deal can be modified to accommodate elite recruits' market value, focusing on potential exceptions or revised terms.
Key Quotes
"this is an issue sponsored by the t j smith law office call t j he'll make 'em pay it has been uh a disaster for the workforce of kentucky sports radio they're just falling like flies in the last few days what's going on you know ryan he had a wreck so he's okay but he's out drew can't move because of his back the back per capita injuries for this show with me and him both so he's out we were going to have a guest but he got pulled today for reasons i can't even go into it's crazy like they drop like flies when they when we uh when we uh i guess uh bail i guess yeah so it's me and you that's right old school this is the way it was and what year did you start with ksr shannon 2011 march of 2011 yeah so year one was me and zach and then shannon came on in 2011"
Matt Jones highlights the current staffing challenges for Kentucky Sports Radio, humorously noting the numerous absences due to various issues. This illustrates the unpredictable nature of managing a radio show and the reliance on a core team.
"i read it all i would suggest like first of all he did their interview with harold i have asked him to come on this show that we have gotten no answer we haven't gotten declined but we haven't gotten approved i also uh have asked him to even talk potentially off the record haven't heard anything so i've done all that i can haven't heard anything he decides to do it with the herald leader just as a pr strategy shannon just simply a pr strategy to me this is an example of how behind they are i don't say this to be rude but i know how many subscribers the herald leader has now i think it's sad that they don't have as many subscribers as they should because we need in kentucky a newspaper forget about sports just for news you need somebody shannon covering the news of the state and the herald leader and the courier journal did that for a century and the newspaper business it's tough so i subscribe i'll subscribe till they close the doors with that said if you're trying to get your message out shannon wouldn't it make sense to go to the people that have the loudest microphone absolutely and definitely not hide behind a paywall yes it's i mean the herald leader is just by its very nature going to be the place that that gets significantly fewer views with that said that's who he talked to"
Matt Jones expresses frustration with Mitch Barnhart's communication strategy, suggesting that Barnhart's interview with the Lexington Herald Leader, especially behind a paywall, is a missed opportunity for broader reach. Jones argues that a PR strategy should leverage platforms with larger audiences.
"question one was basically and the most important does the deal with jmi make it to where we can still get basketball recruits right yesterday and this timing is probably unfortunate christian collins so kentucky for if you're not following basketball recruiting kentucky has two guys that are amongst the best players in the country that it has been assumed for months we were going to get two top 10 players that at various points people have just assumed were going to kentucky tyren stokes and christian collins again if you haven't followed it duke has their guys they've all signed carolina has their guys they've signed kansas has their guys they've signed everyone has signed except our guys but the assumption has been we were going to get these two dudes christian collins was the one that was seemed to be a lock like done deal people had already put out the the gifts saying he's a cat yesterday the recruiting insiders all pulled their gifts from christian collins and basically said it's back open not good right right yeah it makes you wonder what was what was done and some of the recruiting insiders have basically said he can't get a deal done with kentucky now i don't know because i'm not part of that process but the recruiting people who that's what they do they say so to me that interview becomes even more important"
Matt Jones questions the impact of the JMI deal on Kentucky's ability to recruit top basketball players, citing the recent withdrawal of recruiting insider predictions for Christian Collins. Jones suggests that the inability to secure these highly sought-after recruits indicates a potential issue with the JMI agreement.
"the question is not once you're here can you go get other stuff i think everybody agrees the answer to that is yes the question is when we are guaranteeing you the money to play here and let's all be honest that is what's happening are you free when you take that money to also do other things uk will take a kid and let them do whatever they want but the question is with the guaranteed money are you free to do what you want does that make sense yeah and that question is not answered in that article and it's not asked directly it's asked whether or not they can do other things but it's not asked can they do other things after they've taken your money clearly there is got to be something in there because other schools all these other blue bloods already have players signed next year and we're the only one that still has nobody and we don't and i don't know the answer to that question and they've not answered it"
Matt Jones articulates a critical question regarding Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) deals for recruits: whether players are free to pursue outside opportunities after accepting guaranteed money from the university. Jones points out that this specific question remains unanswered in Mitch Barnhart's interview, contrasting it with other universities that have already secured their recruits.
"i think that's fairly easy jmi provided a backstop in terms of financial uh support and it was probably one that uk believes they needed from what i've seen of the jmi deal and granted i give myself the ability to modify this when i learn more about it i think it's a really good deal for 95 to 97 of the student athletes at uk it provides an athlete that doesn't have a lot of market value him or her as him or herself a chance to make some money so i think it's a really good deal for women's basketball baseball uh volleyball and most of football probably almost all of football i mean the jmi deal works for those people the question is does it work for elite basketball recruits the elite basketball recruits who themselves have market value does it work for them and right now the answer for me seems to be no and that's why they're not getting these guys so the question is going to be will it be modified for the elite guys and we'll have to see and maybe it already is but nobody's answered the question so i don't i don't know"
Matt Jones explains his understanding of the JMI deal, suggesting it provides financial support and opportunities for most student-athletes, particularly in sports like women's basketball, baseball, and volleyball. However, Jones expresses concern that the deal may not be beneficial for elite basketball recruits
Resources
External Resources
Books
- "The Turkey Hunter" by [Author not specified] - Mentioned as part of the early history of the show's development.
Articles & Papers
- "Mitch Barnhart's interview with the Lexington Herald Leader" (Lexington Herald Leader) - Discussed as a source of information regarding UK's NIL deal and Mitch Barnhart's future.
- "Politico article about Matt Jones potentially running for Senate" (Politico) - Mentioned as the catalyst for Matt Jones being contacted for a fellowship.
People
- Mitch Barnhart - UK Athletic Director, interviewed by the Lexington Herald Leader regarding NIL deals and his future.
- Matt Jones - Host of Kentucky Sports Radio, discussed his past involvement in radio and his fellowship.
- Shannon - Co-host of Kentucky Sports Radio.
- Maria - Former KSR employee who now holds a high-level position at On3 Sports.
- Zach - Former KSR employee who retains the login credentials for the podcast.
- Drew - Former KSR intern who moved to Chicago to work for Bacon Sports.
- Mark Krebs - Mentioned as a person who was considered for a role on KSR.
- Perrin Johnson - Mentioned as a person who was considered for a role on KSR and is now a salesperson for iHeart.
- Mike Pratt - Mentioned as a person who used to come into KSR.
- Wookash or B'sute - Mentioned as a person who used to come into KSR.
- Jody Bruce - Mentioned as a person who used to come into KSR.
- Romines - Mentioned as a person who used to come into KSR.
- Ryan - Mentioned as a person who joined KSR and brought intellect to the show.
- Christian Collins - Mentioned as a highly-ranked basketball recruit whose commitment to Kentucky is uncertain.
- Tyren Stokes - Mentioned as a highly-ranked basketball recruit whose commitment to Kentucky is uncertain.
- Mitch - Refers to Mitch Barnhart.
- Craig - Former UK volleyball coach for whom the caller Justin was a student manager.
- Mark Pope - Mentioned in relation to recruiting elite freshmen.
- Tom Vernesi - Mentioned as a Facebook friend whose birthday was acknowledged.
- Myrtle Kimmel - Mentioned as Shannon's wife's grandmother, whose birthday was acknowledged.
- Gertrude - Mentioned as a name that is no longer common.
- Bertha - Mentioned as a name that is no longer common.
- Justin - Caller who is attending a volleyball game in Kansas City.
- Joey - First-time caller who expressed concern about recruiting.
- Curt - Caller who asked about a Raiders field goal decision.
- Bob - Caller who asked about "pickle fans" and the Chiefs.
- Tom - Caller who provided insight into JMI and IMG.
- Brandon - Caller who mentioned intern Drew.
- Drew - Mentioned as a former intern who left for Bacon Sports.
- Jake - Co-host of KSR.
- G guy - Co-host of KSR.
- Whitney Houston - Mentioned for her cover of Dolly Parton's "I Will Always Love You."
- Dolly Parton - Mentioned as the original artist of "I Will Always Love You."
- Mariah Carey - Mentioned for her song "All I Want for Christmas Is You."
- Shaq - Mentioned in relation to Charles Barkley's comments.
- Charles Barkley - Mentioned for his commentary on college basketball games.
- Vitel - Mentioned for his commentary on college basketball games.
Organizations & Institutions
- KSR (Kentucky Sports Radio) - The podcast/radio show being discussed.
- iHeart - Podcast network and employer of Perrin Johnson.
- United Healthcare - Insurance company offering medical, dental, and vision coverage.
- Golden Rule Insurance Company - Underwriter for United Healthcare insurance plans.
- Ruby Studio - Producer of the podcast "Mind the Business."
- Intuit Quickbooks - Partnered with Ruby Studio for "Mind the Business."
- Taco - Mentioned as an industry that is ever-evolving.
- FX - Comedy series "English Teacher" is from this network.
- Stockton Mortgage - Sponsor of Kentucky Sports Radio.
- TJ Smith Law Office - Sponsor of Kentucky Sports Radio.
- On3 Sports - Organization where Maria now works.
- Lexington Herald Leader - Newspaper that interviewed Mitch Barnhart.
- Pro Football Focus (PFF) - Mentioned in relation to Kevin Cole.
- New England Patriots - Mentioned as an example team for performance analysis.
- Unexpected Points - Newsletter run by Kevin Cole.
- Health Discovered - Podcast about MS.
- Mitty Health - Company focused on menopause.
- JP Morgan - Bank that connected Mitty Health with investors and partners.
- Comedy Off Broadway - Venue in Lexington hosting comedians.
- Chevy - Automotive brand featured in a "Lightning Round" segment.
- Coca-Cola - Beverage brand featured in a segment.
- CVS - Pharmacy and community service provider.
- Chase Sapphire Reserve - Credit card offering airport lounge access.
- JMI - Organization involved in UK's NIL deal.
- Duke - University with signed basketball recruits.
- Carolina - University with signed basketball recruits.
- Kansas - University with signed basketball recruits.
- ESPN - Sports television network.
- Raiders - NFL team mentioned in relation to a field goal decision.
- Broncos - NFL team mentioned in relation to a field goal decision.
- Chiefs - NFL team discussed in relation to fan sentiment.
- Texas - University that beat the Chiefs.
- Cowboys - University that beat the Chiefs.
- Bengals - NFL team mentioned in relation to Super Bowl appearances.
- International Management Group (IMG) - Former rights holder for Kentucky before JMI.
- Commonwealth Causes - Organization holding a bourbon raffle.
- Buffalo Trace - Bourbon brand.
- Weller - Bourbon brand.
- Blanton's - Bourbon brand.
Podcasts & Audio
- KSR (Kentucky Sports Radio) - The primary podcast being discussed.
- Health Discovered - Podcast about Multiple Sclerosis.
- Mind the Business - Podcast about small business success stories.
Other Resources
- MS (Multiple Sclerosis) - A health condition discussed on the "Health Discovered" podcast.
- NIL (Name, Image, and Likeness) - A system discussed in relation to college athlete compensation and UK's deal with JMI.
- Trivia - An activity mentioned as being held at "Bear and the Butcher."
- Epstein Files - Documents related to Jeffrey Epstein, discussed in relation to their release and potential contents.
- Darts - A sport where a player exhibited violent behavior after losing.
- Pickleball - Mentioned in relation to fans of the sport.
- College Basketball - Sport discussed in relation to TV ratings and commentators.
- Volleyball - Sport discussed in relation to UK's team competing for a title and fan celebrations.
- Chevy Lightning Round - A segment on the podcast involving guessing clues.
- Bourbon Raffle - An event hosted by Commonwealth Causes.