Donor-Advised Funds Maximize Tax-Smart Charitable Giving and Impact
TL;DR
- Donor-advised funds (DAFs) enable tax-smart charitable giving by allowing contributions of cash or appreciated assets, providing an immediate tax deduction and enabling future investment growth for increased philanthropic impact.
- Donating appreciated assets like stocks or real estate to a DAF maximizes charitable contributions by providing a full tax deduction without incurring capital gains tax on the liquidation.
- DAFs are accessible to a broad range of donors, with no account minimums, countering the misconception that they are exclusively for the ultra-wealthy and thereby increasing overall charitable giving.
- Over 70% of DAF users report giving more due to the fund's structure, which encourages investment and growth of charitable assets, creating a positive cascade of increased giving.
- DAFs can be integrated into estate and retirement planning, allowing individuals to define their legacy and involve family in philanthropic decisions, ensuring their values are reflected in their financial plans.
- Impact investing within DAFs allows donors to align their investments with specific social or environmental goals, ensuring their philanthropic strategy actively works towards desired outcomes.
- Tax law changes, such as the non-itemizer deduction and adjusted gross income limitations, necessitate careful consideration of donation timing and amounts to maximize tax benefits for charitable contributions.
Deep Dive
Donor-advised funds (DAFs) offer a tax-advantaged and flexible approach to charitable giving, enabling individuals to contribute various assets and benefit from immediate tax deductions, while allowing the funds to grow and be distributed to eligible charities over time. This structure facilitates strategic financial planning, including estate and retirement planning, by providing a clear mechanism for philanthropic legacy building.
The core benefit of DAFs lies in their ability to transform non-cash assets, such as appreciated securities, real estate, or even cryptocurrency, into charitable contributions. By donating these assets, individuals receive a tax deduction for their full value without incurring capital gains tax on the appreciation. This maximizes the charitable impact by allowing the entire value, plus potential investment growth, to be directed to nonprofits. DAFs are also accessible, with some providers like DAFgiving360 having no account minimums, demystifying charitable giving for a broader range of individuals beyond the ultra-wealthy. Contrary to the misconception that DAFs might reduce overall giving, evidence suggests that donors using DAFs often increase their charitable contributions, partly due to the investment growth within the fund and the simplified process.
Beyond asset donation, DAFs are increasingly integrated into broader financial strategies. They provide a structured way to plan for legacy, allowing individuals to define their philanthropic priorities and involve family members in the giving process. The flexibility of DAFs extends to investment choices, with options ranging from actively managed socially responsible investment pools to customized strategies developed with registered investment advisors, catering to the growing interest in impact investing where donors want to see a tangible link between their investments and social or environmental goals. Furthermore, DAFs are crucial for navigating the complexities of tax law. Recent changes, such as a new charitable deduction for non-itemizers and adjustments to deduction ceilings, necessitate careful planning to maximize tax benefits. Investors are advised to stay informed about these regulations, especially when considering year-end contributions to take advantage of current tax environments.
The process of selecting charities is often guided by personal values and can be supported by resources provided by DAF administrators. With over 1.5 million eligible charities in the U.S., leveraging tools like charity exploration pages and giving guides helps donors identify organizations that align with their philanthropic vision. This strategic approach, supported by financial advisors and educational resources, ensures that charitable giving is not only tax-efficient but also deeply aligned with personal values and societal impact. The future of charitable giving is expected to be further shaped by technology, including fintech innovations and artificial intelligence, which will likely streamline the giving experience, aid in charity selection, and potentially enhance impact measurement. Ultimately, the practice of giving, facilitated by tools like DAFs, demonstrates a powerful capacity to create positive societal change, driven by a community of individuals and organizations dedicated to increasing philanthropic impact.
Action Items
- Create DAF strategy document: Outline 3-5 scenarios for leveraging appreciated assets (stocks, crypto) for tax-smart charitable giving.
- Audit DAF contribution process: Identify 2-3 bottlenecks in liquidating non-cash assets and propose streamlined workflows.
- Develop family values discussion guide: Create 5-7 prompts for intergenerational conversations about philanthropic legacy and impact.
- Measure DAF impact correlation: For 3-5 donor portfolios, analyze the relationship between investment growth and grant distribution timelines.
- Implement AI charity research tool: Pilot an AI-assisted system to narrow down charity selection from 1.5 million IRS-eligible organizations.
Key Quotes
"A donor advised fund is, I believe, a really simple, tax-smart way to give to charity. How they work is that you make a contribution of either cash or appreciated assets. We take many forms of appreciated assets, everything ranging from real estate to interests in private companies to even cryptocurrency. And essentially help people liquidate those assets. People receive a tax deduction for the value of those assets at the time of contribution. They can then either grant that money out right to charity immediately, or they can invest it in a number of vehicles, either by themselves or have it managed by a registered investment advisor, let that grow over time until they're ready to donate to the charity of their choice."
Julie Sunwoo explains that a donor advised fund (DAF) offers a straightforward and tax-efficient method for charitable giving. Sunwoo highlights that DAFs can accept various assets, including cash and appreciated assets like real estate or cryptocurrency, and that contributions are tax-deductible at the time of donation. She also notes that funds can be invested to grow before distribution to a chosen charity.
"I think one of the misconceptions is that it's a vehicle purely for really wealthy people. So, and philanthropic giving in general, sometimes people believe that that's for people with more means. I think one of the things that DAFs brings is low minimums or no minimums in the case of DAF Giving 360. We have no account minimums, so you could presumably start an account for yourself or for your children with as little as $100, very low amounts, and we do see that activity."
Julie Sunwoo addresses a common misconception about donor advised funds (DAFs), stating they are not exclusively for the wealthy. Sunwoo emphasizes that DAFs can be accessible with low or even no minimum contribution requirements, making them available to a broader range of individuals, including those starting their philanthropic journey or wanting to involve younger family members. This accessibility aims to increase overall charitable giving.
"If you are thinking longer term and have, like I said, non-cash assets, so all of those types of appreciated securities especially that you're looking for a place to give and to leverage, you can make use of a vehicle like donor advised funds to do that. In fact, over 60% of the contributions that we typically receive in a given year are appreciated assets. And so if appreciated assets are something that you want to take advantage of, you can give them to contribute them to a donor advised fund, receive that immediate tax deduction for the full value without getting a tax hit for that contribution because you're giving to a 501(c)(3) and nonprofit, which is what donor advised funds are."
Julie Sunwoo explains the advantage of using donor advised funds (DAFs) for donating appreciated assets, such as stocks. Sunwoo points out that over 60% of contributions to DAFs are in the form of these assets, allowing donors to receive an immediate tax deduction for the full value without incurring capital gains tax. This strategy maximizes charitable contributions by leveraging the growth of these assets.
"Researching charities can be quite overwhelming because right now there are over one and a half million charities in the U.S. deemed eligible by the IRS. So that is a daunting number. So I can understand people's challenges when they think about where do I go? I think the first thing to think about is to go back to your personal values and not only your own, but if you're thinking about establishing a legacy that lives on beyond you, it's a great conversation starter this values discussion to have with kids, grandkids, other members of the family to bring everyone into the conversation."
Julie Sunwoo acknowledges the difficulty of selecting charities from a vast pool of over 1.5 million eligible organizations. Sunwoo suggests that individuals begin by reflecting on their personal values and, if establishing a legacy, engaging family members in a discussion about shared values. This approach helps to narrow down the focus to specific sectors or causes for charitable impact.
"The IRS charitable contribution deadline is December 31st for this year, and that is the deadline if you want to receive a tax deduction for the contributions that you make to nonprofits. So for donors specifically, what that means in the case of donor advised funds is that all contributions are required to be submitted and processed by December 31st in order to get that tax deduction."
Julie Sunwoo clarifies the critical deadline for charitable contributions to receive a tax deduction. Sunwoo states that for the current year, December 31st is the final date for submitting and processing contributions to nonprofits, including those made through donor advised funds. She advises donors to submit their contributions earlier than the deadline to ensure timely processing.
"The bottom line is this: I'm a bit skeptical whenever I hear the phrase that something is a win-win. It always seems a little too good to be true, but not this time. Giving to charity can have a number of positive benefits for both the giver and the receiver."
This quote, attributed to Mark Riepe, expresses a pragmatic view on the benefits of charitable giving. Riepe suggests that while the concept of a "win-win" can often be suspect, charitable giving genuinely offers advantages to both the donor and the recipient. This perspective frames charitable acts as mutually beneficial.
Resources
External Resources
Books
- "A Christmas Carol" by Charles Dickens - Mentioned as a scene used in a podcast episode about happiness and generosity.
Articles & Papers
- "Spending money on others promotes happiness" (Study) - Discussed as an experiment showing increased happiness in participants who spent money on others.
- "Estate planning lessons from a loss" (Schwab Center for Financial Research article) - Referenced as a resource for learning about charitable giving and strengthening legacy while alive.
People
- Julie Sunwoo - President of DAFgiving360, guest on the podcast discussing charitable giving strategies.
- Mark Riepe - Host of the Financial Decoder podcast, head of the Schwab Center for Financial Research.
Organizations & Institutions
- DAFgiving360 - Organization focused on increasing charitable giving in the United States through donor-advised funds.
- Charles Schwab - Financial services company and producer of the Financial Decoder podcast.
- IRS (Internal Revenue Service) - Mentioned in relation to tax deductions for charitable contributions and eligibility of 501(c)(3) organizations.
- National Center for Family Philanthropy - Partner in creating workbooks for discussing philanthropic giving.
Websites & Online Resources
- DAFgiving360.org - Website providing resources on charitable giving, including an "explore charities" landing page and a giving guide.
- Schwab.com - Website offering resources on charitable giving.
Podcasts & Audio
- Financial Decoder (Original podcast from Charles Schwab) - Podcast discussing financial decision-making and charitable giving.
- Choiceology podcast - Mentioned for having an episode on the link between happiness and generosity.
Other Resources
- Donor Advised Fund (DAF) - Discussed as a tax-smart way to give to charity, allowing contributions of cash or appreciated assets.
- Prosocial spending - Concept discussed as spending money on other people, which can increase happiness.
- Impact investing - Mentioned as a growing interest where donors want to see the value and impact of their philanthropic strategy.
- Socially Responsible Investment (SRI) pools - Actively managed investment pools offered for donors seeking to make an impact through their investments.
- 501(c)(3) organization - Type of nonprofit organization eligible to receive grants from donor-advised funds.