Humanoid Robots: The Next Personal Computer Driving Economic and Geopolitical Competition - Episode Hero Image

Humanoid Robots: The Next Personal Computer Driving Economic and Geopolitical Competition

Bold Names · · Listen to Original Episode →
Original Title:

TL;DR

  • Humanoid robots are positioned as the "personal computer for robotics," representing a general-purpose platform with the potential for widespread adoption and scaling across industries by 2035.
  • Apptronik's strategy focuses on designing and building advanced robot bodies and actuators, partnering with AI experts like Google DeepMind for the "brain" to enable dynamic, sensor-driven AI-powered robots.
  • The development of AI-powered humanoid robots is shifting from programmed tasks to robots learning directly from human actions, enabling rapid addition of new capabilities and broader application potential.
  • The U.S. faces significant competition from China in robotics, which possesses manufacturing capacity, a unified ecosystem, and a national strategy with substantial government funding and demand incentives.
  • Achieving widespread humanoid robot adoption hinges on building trust and transparency, particularly for home use, which will be a critical battleground for companies in this emerging market.
  • Humanoid robots are seen as a fundamental driver of future economic growth and national competitiveness, essential for solving challenges in healthcare, environmental cleanup, and goods production.
  • Apptronik aims for a sub-$50,000 robot cost, leveraging component technologies matured in other industries like drones and EVs, and plans to scale production through contract manufacturing.

Deep Dive

Apptronik, a humanoid robot company, posits that these machines are poised to become the next transformative technology, akin to the personal computer, driving economic growth, national security, and fundamentally altering human productivity. Their vision extends from industrial applications to home healthcare, with a projected timeline for widespread home adoption by 2035, positioning this as a critical race against China for global technological leadership.

The development of sophisticated humanoid robots hinges on integrating advanced AI with robust hardware. Apptronik focuses on building the robot's physical platform, emphasizing control over actuators--the "muscles"--and sensors that enable dynamic environmental responsiveness. This hardware is intended to work in tandem with AI, specifically foundation models, allowing robots to learn tasks directly from human observation. This contrasts with traditional programming, where each new task required significant engineering effort. This learning capability promises a rapid expansion of robot applications, moving beyond discrete, repetitive actions to more complex, adaptable functions. Apptronik's strategy involves a phased rollout: Stage 1 focuses on controlled industrial environments (manufacturing, logistics), Stage 2 introduces robots into public commercial settings (retail, healthcare), and Stage 3 targets the home, with assistive care as the ultimate goal.

The implications of this technological advancement are profound. Economically, robots represent a significant multiplier on human productivity, potentially redefining national competitiveness and security. The CEO likens the current stage of humanoid robotics to the 1980s of personal computers, suggesting that while early commercial applications exist, widespread adoption and capability are still developing. This race for dominance is framed as a geopolitical imperative, with China posing a significant threat due to its manufacturing capacity, rapid iteration, collaborative ecosystem, and substantial government investment, including a national robotics strategy that incentivizes demand. Apptronik's approach, while aiming for cost-competitiveness with vehicles under $50,000, relies on contract manufacturing and partnerships, drawing lessons from companies like Tesla that initially utilized external manufacturers. The success of this strategy hinges on managing cash intensity and supply chain development, while the ultimate adoption of these robots in homes will depend on consumer trust in their security and privacy.

Action Items

  • Audit current manufacturing processes: Identify 3-5 areas for contract manufacturing partnerships (e.g., Jabil) to optimize capital allocation.
  • Draft national robotics strategy proposal: Outline 3 key components (R&D support, capital investment, demand incentives) to foster US competitiveness.
  • Measure robot cost reduction potential: Calculate the correlation between component maturity in other industries (drones, EVs) and potential humanoid robot cost targets (<$50k).
  • Analyze competitor AI stack strategy: Compare Apptronik's approach with Google DeepMind to potential US competitors' reliance on third-party AI.
  • Track pilot program performance: For 2-3 key partnerships (e.g., GXO, Mercedes), define 5-10 key performance indicators for robot task execution and reliability.

Key Quotes

"My primary motivation is to be useful. What does it mean to improve the way we live and work and where do you focus? So I was very interested in healthcare, the way we take care of each other, you know, and in particular in the way we age."

Jeff Cardenas explains that his core drive for starting a robotics company stems from a desire to improve human well-being, specifically focusing on the challenges associated with aging and healthcare. This personal motivation highlights a human-centered approach to technological development.


"So the way I see this rolling out is in three stages. You can kind of think of it in some ways as easy to hard, though I would say all of this is relatively hard. But stage one is the industrial base. This is where you can control the environment and where you have experts that can work around these machines. So these are like logistics and manufacturing."

Cardenas outlines a phased approach to robot deployment, beginning with controlled industrial environments like manufacturing and logistics. This strategy acknowledges the current limitations and complexities of robotics, prioritizing environments where safety and operational parameters can be managed.


"The way robots for the age of AI work is we're now having sensors in the feedback loop. So we have cameras, we have force sensing, touch sensing, we have temperature, we have an accelerometer that can sense position and orientation. So we have all sorts of sensors that we're bringing together so the robot can be aware and can be sort of dynamic and respond to the environment that's out there."

Cardenas describes a fundamental shift in robot design, moving from simple position control to AI-driven systems that incorporate a wide array of sensors. This integration allows robots to perceive and react to their surroundings dynamically, enabling more complex and adaptable interactions.


"The simple idea is the robots are learning. Traditionally, what we'd done is basically program the robot to do a particular function. This is how it was done in the past is essentially it was given instructions on how to do a task. What's changed, what we call this foundation model, so this is generative AI applied to robotics, is that the robots can now learn."

Cardenas explains that a key advancement in robotics is the shift from pre-programmed tasks to AI-driven learning capabilities. This transition, enabled by foundation models and generative AI, allows robots to acquire new skills and adapt to different functions more efficiently than traditional programming methods.


"I think of the humanoid as the general purpose platform that can scale. But it's early. This is the the 80s maybe of, if you use that analogy. And I think, yeah, they could also be the 60s, though that's true. I think it depends on, you know, my view spending a lot of time in this and and I sort of openly admit that we were very naive going into this."

Cardenas likens the current state of humanoid robotics to the early days of personal computers in the 1980s, suggesting significant growth potential but acknowledging the nascent stage of the technology. He admits to initial naivete about the complexities involved in developing these advanced robots.


"I think that by 2035 you will see these robots in homes. The question is how quick is that uptake and I think that's a point of debate. But I think we're now in the window and I think you're going to see a very fast acceleration."

Cardenas projects that humanoid robots will become common in homes by 2035, anticipating rapid adoption and acceleration in the field. He believes the technology has reached a critical point where widespread integration into domestic life is imminent, though the exact pace of adoption remains a subject of discussion.

Resources

External Resources

Books

  • "The Jetsons" - Referenced as an example of a future home robot helper.

Articles & Papers

  • Keywords column by Christopher Mims - Mentioned as a resource to read.
  • Column by Tim Higgins - Mentioned as a resource to read.

People

  • Jeff Cardenas - CEO and co-founder of Apptronik, discussed as a guest on the podcast.
  • Christopher Mims - WSJ journalist and co-host of the Bold Names podcast.
  • Tim Higgins - WSJ journalist and co-host of the Bold Names podcast.
  • Elon Musk - Mentioned in relation to his "idiot test" and Tesla's Optimus humanoid robot.

Organizations & Institutions

  • Apptronik - A startup building humanoid robots.
  • WSJ Podcasts YouTube channel - Where the video version of the episode can be watched.
  • WSJ.com - Where the video version of the episode can be watched.
  • Google - Mentioned as an anchor investor in Apptronik and for its AI innovations.
  • Google DeepMind - Mentioned as a collaborator on AI research for robots.
  • Tesla - Mentioned as a competitor in the humanoid robot space.
  • Figure - Mentioned as a competitor in the humanoid robot space.
  • GXO - Logistics company mentioned as a pilot program partner for Apptronik.
  • Mercedes - Mentioned as a pilot program partner for Apptronik.
  • Boston Dynamics - Previously owned by Google, mentioned in the context of past humanoid robot investments.
  • Meta Redwood Robotics - A company Google previously bought.
  • Jabil - Contract manufacturer mentioned in relation to Apptronik's manufacturing strategy.
  • Foxconn - Mentioned as an example of a contract manufacturer for Apple.
  • Lotus - Mentioned as a contract manufacturer for Tesla's early Roadster.
  • Mobileye - Worked with Tesla on Autopilot in the early days.
  • SAP - Mentioned as an AI-powered capability for business growth.

Websites & Online Resources

  • paycom.com - Where to learn more about Paycom's real-time employee data.
  • megaphone.fm/adchoices - Where to learn more about ad choices.
  • versa networks.com - Where to learn more about Versa's unified security and networking.

Other Resources

  • Humanoid Robots - The primary subject of the podcast episode.
  • AI (Artificial Intelligence) - Discussed as the "brain" for humanoid robots and its advancements.
  • Foundation Model - Generative AI applied to robotics, allowing robots to learn from humans.
  • Personal Computer for Robotics - An analogy used to describe the current stage of humanoid robots.
  • Space Race - An analogy used to describe the competition in humanoid robot development.
  • National Robotics Strategy - Discussed in relation to China's approach and the US's lack thereof.
  • Productivity per person - Discussed as the core of an economy and how robots can change it.

---
Handpicked links, AI-assisted summaries. Human judgment, machine efficiency.
This content is a personally curated review and synopsis derived from the original podcast episode.