Language's Dynamic Nature: From Weather Archives to Gig Work
TL;DR
- The "tempestry project" extends the concept of temperature blankets beyond personal records to create historical weather archives, offering a tangible, visual record of past climates for future study.
- The phrase "you dropped your pocket" functions as a "made you look" prank, designed to distract and momentarily disorient individuals, with parallels in other verbal pranks like "your sock is untied."
- Efficacy measures a treatment's performance under controlled clinical trial conditions, whereas effectiveness assesses its real-world performance in uncontrolled, everyday settings.
- The term "gig" for a short-term engagement, originating in music, has broadened to encompass various freelance or temporary work in the "gig economy."
- The expression "go gunny bags" signifies a sudden failure or descent into chaos, potentially linked to the frantic, desperate action of using gunny sacks to extinguish a fire.
- The historical present tense is used by historians to imbue past events with immediacy and maintain narrative flow, avoiding disorienting shifts between past and present timelines.
- The phrase "gooder than snuff, but not near as dusty" compares something favorably to the stimulating effect of snuff tobacco, while acknowledging its less pleasant, dusty texture.
Deep Dive
The podcast "A Way with Words" explores the nuances of language through listener contributions, revealing how everyday expressions evolve and carry hidden cultural significance. This episode highlights how seemingly simple phrases can reflect deeper societal values, technological shifts, and even personal philosophies, prompting listeners to reconsider their own vocabulary and its impact.
The discussion delves into several distinct linguistic phenomena. The "temperature blanket" or "weather blanket" is presented not just as a craft project but as a modern method of data visualization and historical record-keeping, akin to ancient mnemonic devices like Inca quipu. This concept is extended by the "Tempestry Project," which actively creates such blankets for historical periods, offering a tangible, artistic representation of past climates. The implications are profound: these crafts transform abstract data into personal, tactile experiences, fostering a deeper connection to environmental history and potentially serving as future historical archives.
Separately, the common prank phrase "you dropped your pocket" is analyzed as a "made you look" gag, a category of verbal trickery found in folklore and schoolyard traditions. Its persistence across different regions and generations suggests a universal human impulse for playful deception and the enjoyment of moments that momentarily disrupt social routines. The analysis links this to similar phrases like "your sock is untied" and "your epidermis is showing," underscoring a shared humor rooted in creating minor, harmless confusion.
The distinction between "efficacy" and "effectiveness" is clarified, particularly for academic and scientific contexts. Efficacy refers to a treatment's performance under controlled, ideal conditions, such as in clinical trials, while effectiveness measures its real-world performance in uncontrolled, everyday settings. This distinction is critical for accurate scientific reporting and public health policy, as interventions that are highly efficacious in a lab may not perform as well when broadly applied. The implication is that understanding this difference prevents misinterpretations of data and leads to more informed decision-making regarding treatments and public health strategies.
The term "gig" is traced from its origins, likely in music, to its widespread adoption for any short-term engagement, particularly within the "gig economy." This evolution reflects a broader societal shift towards flexible, project-based work, where the term "gig" now signifies a fundamental unit of labor outside traditional employment structures. The uncertainty surrounding its ultimate etymology highlights how slang often emerges organically and solidifies through popular usage rather than precise historical documentation.
The phrase "gone gunny bags" is explored as an idiom for something failing or going haywire. While the precise origin is debated, potential links to the frantic, chaotic act of beating out a fire with coarse gunny sacks suggest the idiom captures a sense of desperate, last-ditch effort or a sudden descent into disorder. The analysis connects this to the material nature of gunny sacks, implying that their coarse, utilitarian purpose might inform the idiom's sense of things breaking down or becoming unmanageable.
The concept of reframing "bucket list" to "bliss list" is presented as a strategy for focusing on achievable, joyful moments rather than solely on final goals. This linguistic shift encourages a more mindful appreciation of the present and the process of working towards aspirations, suggesting that happiness is often found in the journey itself, not just the destination. This reframing has implications for personal well-being and goal-setting, promoting a more sustainable and fulfilling approach to life's pursuits.
Finally, the use of the "historical present" tense in narratives about past events is explained as a technique to create immediacy and coherence for the audience. By describing past actions as if they are happening now, speakers and writers can avoid disorienting shifts between past and present timelines, making historical accounts more engaging and easier to follow. This grammatical choice, while potentially confusing if inconsistently applied, serves to bridge the temporal gap between the audience and the historical subject matter.
The episode demonstrates that language is not static but a dynamic reflection of human experience, creativity, and societal change. The implications of these linguistic explorations extend beyond mere etymology, touching upon how we record history, understand scientific data, organize work, cope with failure, find joy, and narrate our past.
Action Items
- Create runbook template: Define 5 required sections (setup, common failures, rollback, monitoring) to prevent knowledge silos.
- Audit authentication flow: Check for three vulnerability classes (SQL injection, XSS, CSRF) across 10 endpoints.
- Implement mutation testing: Target 3 core modules to identify untested edge cases beyond coverage metrics.
- Profile build pipeline: Identify 5 slowest steps and establish 10-minute CI target to maintain fast feedback.
- Track 5-10 high-variance events per game (fumble recoveries, special teams plays) to measure outcome impact.
Key Quotes
"one of the expressions i've been sharing when you and i do live presentations before audiences is temperature blanket also known as a weather blanket and i can't believe the response i've been getting people love these terms yeah i love them too i didn't know them before you started talking about them in these presentations what i learned from you is that this is like a knitted blanket or it could be a scarf where the colors of each row represent the weather on that particular day in that particular place so it's like a diary in yarn you know different blues for cool and different reds for warmth and so on yes"
Martha Barnette explains that a "temperature blanket" is a knitted item where each row's color corresponds to the day's temperature, serving as a yarn-based diary of weather. Barnette highlights that this concept has garnered significant positive responses from audiences.
"but i've discovered it goes much deeper martha it does yeah there are a lot of people who make weather and temperature blankets and scarves for themselves and they're beautiful lovely stuff but since 2017 there has been something called the tempestry project t e m p e s t r y the people involved are not only crafting the weather into tapestries but they're doing it for historical periods they've standardized it makers are even extending the concept backward through time they're doing what amounts to weather blankets for things like their grandparents' lifetimes oh my gosh that is beautiful and i love the word tempestry that's just incredible"
Grant Barrett introduces the "Tempestry Project," which expands on the concept of temperature blankets by creating weather tapestries for historical periods, even extending back to previous generations. Barrett expresses admiration for the project and the term "tempestry."
"so i don't know if folklorists have a fixed name for these kinds of pranks but in books of folklore these kinds of pranks are often under the heading of made you look made you look because there are other types of pranks just like this and this particular one is often found but now i haven't found it in any books of folklore but you know where i find it in high school yearbooks going back at least 30 years what yes including being used to distract opponents on the basketball court wow yes where like somebody's like trying to make like the free throw that's going to like clinch the game and somebody says somebody says you dropped your pocket yeah"
Grant Barrett discusses the prank "you dropped your pocket," categorizing it as a "made you look" prank, similar to others found in folklore. Barrett notes that while not always documented in folklore books, this specific prank appears in high school yearbooks and has been used to distract people, even in sports.
"so so efficacy is about under controlled conditions and effectiveness is about uncontrolled conditions and so that's where you run up against differences generally efficacy tends to pair with words like controlled conditions specialized valuations clinical trial treatment effectiveness tends to pair with words like applied settings everyday performance policy strategy outreach enforcement prevention efforts gotcha do you see where we're going with this yeah okay that makes a lot of sense which that implies that i've also been using it wrong for a couple years now so okay what's encouraging here is that a you're recognizing that you can change the way you use the word and b you're still getting your degree so uh you're learning and that's okay"
The speaker explains that "efficacy" refers to performance under controlled conditions, such as in clinical trials, while "effectiveness" pertains to performance in uncontrolled, real-world settings. The speaker reassures Sarah that recognizing and correcting word usage is part of the learning process, especially while pursuing a degree.
"so i don't know if it's a military term it sort of had that flavor to me but she said oh gosh i think my mother used to say it more often so that's what i heard from her oh it's so interesting because you know it's not all that common to go gunny bags meaning to become broken to to fail suddenly so you can say this about people who go a little nutso you can say this about machines that stop working you can say this about plans that fail to work um or you can say this about a situation that just erupts into chaos to go gunny bags and so typically when you see it written out it's g u n n y b a g s usually as one word always plural sometimes as two words and what we're talking about here are usually given as gunny sacks and other forms and a gunny sack is made of martha what would you call this kind of a coarse fabric gunny is a fabric that originally was made of is this jute is this kind of originally from india and actually the word originally comes from indian languages as in the continent of of the country of india so it's a little bit of a pleonasm gunny means sack so gunny sack means sack sack it's redundant it's redundant yeah"
The speaker clarifies that "to go gunny bags" means to fail suddenly or erupt into chaos, applicable to people, machines, plans, or situations. The speaker explains that a "gunny sack" is a coarse fabric, often made of jute from India, and notes that "gunny" itself means sack, making "gunny sack" a redundant term.
"and i have a proposal that in construction projects where they have a punch list which sounds really negative they also use bliss list punch list being the all the little random items that you have to do before the project is done sure sure and just think how great you'll feel afterward you know it'll be bliss all the grout and caulking and broken things that have to be done it's a bliss list you tell your contractor he'll get it yeah just reframe it think about it differently anyway i really enjoy this newsletter by gwen moran it's called bloom anywhere you can find all of our past episodes and a zillion ways to reach us on our website at waywardradio org"
Grant Barrett proposes applying the "bliss list" concept to construction projects, suggesting it as an alternative to the negative-sounding "punch list." Barrett believes reframing tasks as part of a "bliss list" can foster a more positive outlook on completing necessary work.
Resources
External Resources
Books
- "Unabridged: The Thrill of and Threat to the Modern Dictionary" by Stephen Fatsis - Mentioned as a comprehensive history of dictionaries, particularly in the United States, and a love letter to dictionaries and lexicographers.
- "Word Freak" by Stephen Fatsis - Mentioned as a previous book by the author about competitive Scrabble.
- "The Lore of Language of Schoolchildren" by Iona and Peter Opie - Mentioned as a resource for understanding "made you look" pranks, similar to the "you dropped your pocket" joke.
Articles & Papers
- "A Way with Words" (Podcast) - Mentioned as the source of the episode and a platform for language discussions.
- "Bloom Anywhere" (Newsletter) by Gwen Moran - Mentioned for its discussion of reframing "bucket list" as "bliss list."
People
- Stephen Fatsis - Author of "Unabridged: The Thrill of and Threat to the Modern Dictionary" and "Word Freak," and a former sports reporter and lexicographer in training.
- Iona Opie - Co-author of "The Lore of Language of Schoolchildren."
- Peter Opie - Co-author of "The Lore of Language of Schoolchildren."
- Gwen Moran - Author of the newsletter "Bloom Anywhere."
- Rod Newkirk (W9BRD) - Amateur radio magazine columnist who wrote about mentors and inspired the term "Elmer."
- Elmer Frodehart Jr. (W9DIY) - The ham radio mentor who inspired the term "Elmer."
- Judith Jance - Fiction author whose novels may have popularized the phrase "to go gunny bags."
- Noah Webster - Historical figure associated with dictionaries.
- Millard Fillmore - Former Vice President who ordered the removal of a snuff box from the Senate desk.
- Melvyn Bragg - Host of the BBC show "In Our Time," known for using the historical present tense.
Organizations & Institutions
- A Way with Words - The podcast where the discussion took place.
- Wayword, Inc. - The 501(c)(3) corporation that produces "A Way with Words."
- Merriam Webster - A famous dictionary company where Stephen Fatsis trained as a lexicographer.
- Dictionary.com - Mentioned in the context of its acquisition and transitions.
- QST Magazine - An amateur radio magazine where the term "Elmer" was discussed.
- FCC (Federal Communications Commission) - The agency that previously handled amateur radio license exams.
- Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center's Manhattan Breast Cancer Treatment Center - Where Gwen Moran received chemo treatments.
- Liberty Mutual - Mentioned in a sponsored segment about car insurance.
- Mint Mobile - Mentioned in a sponsored segment about wireless plans.
Websites & Online Resources
- waywardradio.org - The website for "A Way with Words," used for episodes, contact, and donations.
- tempestryproject.com - A website for the Tempestry Project, focused on crafting weather into tapestries.
- mintmobile.com - Website for Mint Mobile.
- libertymutual.com - Website for Liberty Mutual.
- stitchfix.com/spotify - Website for Stitch Fix.
Other Resources
- Temperature blanket (also known as a weather blanket) - A knitted item where colors represent daily temperatures, serving as a record of weather.
- Tempestry Project - An initiative that standardizes weather blankets for historical periods.
- Ipu - Knotted cord record-keeping of the Inca.
- Marshallese stick charts - Navigation tools used to map the ocean.
- Bucket list - A list of things to do before one dies.
- Bliss list - A reframed concept of a list focusing on smaller steps toward goals and finding joy in the process.
- Punch list - A list of items to be completed in construction projects.
- Gig economy - A labor market characterized by short-term contracts or freelance work.
- Gig - A short-term engagement, originally in music, now used more broadly.
- Voiceless labial-velar approximant - A specific phonetic sound discussed in relation to pronunciations.
- Historical present - A tense used in English to describe past events with immediacy.
- Ham radio Elmer - A mentor who teaches new amateur radio operators.
- 73s - A ham radio term meaning "best regards."
- Sudando tinta - A Cuban phrase meaning "sweating ink," used to describe someone working very hard, especially writers.
- Safe as houses - A British expression meaning very safe.
- The Great Passage (Anime) - A 2016 anime series about a young man becoming a lexicographer.